Hadamard's lemma and continuity of φₐ at a

2 replies · 2K views · last reply
Math Amateur
Gold Member
MHB
Messages
3,920
Reaction score
48
I am reading "Multidimensional Real Analysis I: Differentiation" by J. J. Duistermaat and J. A. C. Kolk ...

I am focused on Chapter 2: Differentiation ... ...

I need help with another aspect of the proof of Lemma 2.2.7 (Hadamard...) ... ...

Duistermaat and Kolk's Lemma 2.2.7 and its proof read as follows:
Statement of Lemma 2.2.7 (Hadamard): for open U in R^n, a in U and f: U to R^p, assertions (i) f is differentiable at a and (ii) an operator-valued map phi_a: U to Lin(R^n, R^p) continuous at a with f(x) = f(a) + phi_a(x)(x - a) are equivalent.

Printed textbook page with a proof: phi_a(x) defined piecewise as Df(a) + (1/||x-a||^2) epsilon_a(x-a)(x-a)^t for x in U minus {a}, and Df(a) for x = a, followed by the continuity argument and Corollary 2.2.8.


Near to the end of the above text D&K write the following:

" ... ... A direct computation gives ##\| \epsilon_a(h) h^t \|_{ Eucl } = \| \epsilon_a(h) \| \| h \|## , hence##\lim_{ h \rightarrow 0 } \frac{ \| \epsilon_a(h) h^t \|_{ Eucl } }{ \| h \|^2 } = \lim_{ h \rightarrow 0 } \frac{ \| \epsilon_a(h) \| }{ \| h \| } = 0## This shows that ##\phi_a## is continuous at ##a##. ... ... "

My questions are as follows:

Question 1

... how/why does the above show that ##\phi_a## is continuous at ##a##. ... ...?

Can someone please demonstrate explicitly, formally and rigorously that ##\phi_a## is continuous at ##a##. ... ...?Question 2

How/why does the proof of Hadamard's Lemma 2.2.7 imply that ##f## is continuous at ##a## if ##f## is differentiable at ##a## ... ?
Help will be much appreciated ... ...

Peter==========================================================================================

NOTE:

The start of D&K's section on differentiable mappings may help readers of the above post understand the context and notation of the post ... so I am providing the same as follows:
Printed page from a textbook section 2.2 'Differentiable mappings', showing the definition of differentiability as the limit of (f(x) - f(a))/(x - a) and Proposition 2.2.1 with assertions (i) and (ii).

Textbook page showing a lemma on differentiability: conditions (i) to (iii) for f'(a) = φ_a(a) = L(a), the definition of φ_a(x) piecewise, and Definition 2.2.2 of the differential mapping Df(a) with its limit condition.

The start of D&K's section on linear mappings may also help readers of the above post understand the context and notation of the post ... so I am providing the same as follows:
Printed textbook page showing section 2.1 Linear mappings, with a paragraph on notation for linear mappings and matrices, followed by the centred expression Lin(R^n, R^p).

Textbook page on linear mappings: defines the linear space of linear maps from R^n to R^p, the matrix of a linear map with entries a_ij, and the notation Mat(p x n, R), End(R^n) and GL(n, R).

Equation 2.1 defining the map c(A) that stacks the columns of an p by n matrix A into a row vector, followed by equations 2.2 and 2.3 giving the Euclidean (Frobenius) norm of A.

Hope the above helps readers understand the context and notation of the post ...

Peter
 
Attachments
  • Statement of Lemma 2.2.7 (Hadamard): for open U in R^n, a in U and f: U to R^p, assertions (i) f is differentiable at a and (ii) an operator-valued map phi_a: U to Lin(R^n, R^p) continuous at a with f(x) = f(a) + phi_a(x)(x - a) are equivalent.
    D&K - 1 - Lemma 2.2.7 ... ... PART 1 ... .png
    13.5 KB · Views: 599
  • Printed textbook page with a proof: phi_a(x) defined piecewise as Df(a) + (1/||x-a||^2) epsilon_a(x-a)(x-a)^t for x in U minus {a}, and Df(a) for x = a, followed by the continuity argument and Corollary 2.2.8.
    D&K - 2 - Lemma 2.2.7 ... ... PART 2 ... .png
    24 KB · Views: 681
  • Printed page from a textbook section 2.2 'Differentiable mappings', showing the definition of differentiability as the limit of (f(x) - f(a))/(x - a) and Proposition 2.2.1 with assertions (i) and (ii).
    D&K - 1 - Start of Section 2.2 on Differentiable Mappings ... PART 1 ... .png
    29.9 KB · Views: 506
  • Textbook page showing a lemma on differentiability: conditions (i) to (iii) for f'(a) = φ_a(a) = L(a), the definition of φ_a(x) piecewise, and Definition 2.2.2 of the differential mapping Df(a) with its limit condition.
    D&K - 2 - Start of Section 2.2 on Differentiable Mappings ... PART 2 ... .png
    26.9 KB · Views: 488
  • Printed textbook page showing section 2.1 Linear mappings, with a paragraph on notation for linear mappings and matrices, followed by the centred expression Lin(R^n, R^p).
    D&K - 1 - Linear Mappings ... Start of Section - PART 1.png
    8.6 KB · Views: 511
  • Textbook page on linear mappings: defines the linear space of linear maps from R^n to R^p, the matrix of a linear map with entries a_ij, and the notation Mat(p x n, R), End(R^n) and GL(n, R).
    D&K - 2 - Linear Mappings ... Start of Section - PART 2 ... ... .png
    33.7 KB · Views: 551
  • Equation 2.1 defining the map c(A) that stacks the columns of an p by n matrix A into a row vector, followed by equations 2.2 and 2.3 giving the Euclidean (Frobenius) norm of A.
    D&K - 3 - Linear Mappings ... Start of Section - PART 3 ... ... .png
    40.3 KB · Views: 538
.
Math Amateur said:
" ... ... A direct computation gives##\| \epsilon_a(h) h^t \|_{ Eucl } = \| \epsilon_a(h) \| \| h \|## , (1)

hence

##\lim_{ h \rightarrow 0 } \frac{ \| \epsilon_a(h) h^t \|_{ Eucl } }{ \| h \|^2 } = \lim_{ h \rightarrow 0 } \frac{ \| \epsilon_a(h) \| }{ \| h \| } = 0## (2)This shows that ##\phi_a## is continuous at ##a##. ... ... "

My questions are as follows:

Question 1

... how/why does the above show that ##\phi_a## is continuous at ##a##. ... ...?
Let ##h=x-a##. With that substitution we have

$$\frac{ \| \epsilon_a(h) h^t \|_{ Eucl } }{ \| h \|^2 }
= \frac{ \| \epsilon_a(x-a) (x-a)^t \|_{ Eucl } }{ \|x-a \|^2 }
=\|\phi_a(x)-\phi_a(a)\|
$$
per the above definition of ##\phi_a(x)##

So what you have quoted shows that the limit as ##x\to a## of ##\|\phi_a(x)-\phi_a(a)\|## is zero, which is one way of defining continuity of ##\phi_a## at ##a##..
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Math Amateur
Thanks Andrew ...

Appreciate your help ...

Peter