Heat Exchange: Ice added to water

Click For Summary

Homework Help Overview

The discussion revolves around a heat exchange problem involving a glass of water at 20°C, a glass with a specific heat capacity, and ice cubes being added to the system. Participants are tasked with determining the final temperature of the mixture and the mass of any remaining ice.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory, Assumption checking, Conceptual clarification

Approaches and Questions Raised

  • Participants discuss the application of heat exchange equations and express concerns about the specific heat of ice, particularly whether to use 0.5 or 1 cal/g°C. There are attempts to clarify the role of latent heat in the melting of ice and how it affects the overall energy balance.

Discussion Status

Some participants have provided guidance on setting up the equations for heat exchange and the implications of negative temperature results, indicating that not all ice may melt. There is an ongoing exploration of how to account for the melting of ice and the assumptions regarding its initial temperature.

Contextual Notes

Participants note that the problem does not specify the initial temperature of the ice, leading to discussions about reasonable assumptions. There is also mention of imposed homework rules regarding the treatment of specific heat and latent heat in the calculations.

XwyhyX
Messages
15
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement



A glass containing water is initially of temperature 20oC. The mass of the glass is 100 g and of specific heat 0.16 cal/g-co and water is of mass 200g. If 5 cubes of ice each of mass 15g will be added to the glass of water, solve for
(a) The temperature of the mixture.
(b) The mass of ice remaining if any.

Homework Equations



Qloss+Qgained=0
Q=mCΔt

The Attempt at a Solution



Ok so used the equation for heat exchange and I arrived at the equation,

mCΔt of water + mCΔt of glass + mCΔt of ice = 0

My concern is the Specific heat that I will use for C of ice, because my teacher said to only use 0.5 when below 0 degrees but it doesn't really say its temperature in the problem. Will I use 1 or 0.5?

And for part b, I need some tips on how to start solving for the possible remaining ice
 
Physics news on Phys.org
well if you want to find the temperature of the mixture, you'll have to do the following:

0=\mu_{cup}(\theta_{f}-\theta_{i})+m_{1}C_{w}(\theta_{f}-\theta i)+m_{2}C_{ice}(\theta_{f}-\theta_{i})

after you write that down you'll have to foil everything out then factor out what needs to be factored out with θf and just do simple algebra to find the final temperature.
 
XwyhyX said:

Homework Statement



A glass containing water is initially of temperature 20oC. The mass of the glass is 100 g and of specific heat 0.16 cal/g-co and water is of mass 200g. If 5 cubes of ice each of mass 15g will be added to the glass of water, solve for
(a) The temperature of the mixture.
(b) The mass of ice remaining if any.


Homework Equations



Qloss+Qgained=0
Q=mCΔt

The Attempt at a Solution



Ok so used the equation for heat exchange and I arrived at the equation,

mCΔt of water + mCΔt of glass + mCΔt of ice = 0

My concern is the Specific heat that I will use for C of ice, because my teacher said to only use 0.5 when below 0 degrees but it doesn't really say its temperature in the problem. Will I use 1 or 0.5?

And for part b, I need some tips on how to start solving for the possible remaining ice

The ice is probably starting at 0o, so you don't have to worry about it warming up. You do have to account for the ice melting though - you need to use the latent heat of fusion.

Part (b) suggest not all the ice will be melted, so I would be working out how much heat energy has to be absorbed to cool the glass and water to 0o, and see how much ice that heat would melt.
Suppose that will melt 55 grams of ice, then the final mix will be at 0o, with 20g [of the original 75g,] still remaining.
 
mtayab1994 said:
well if you want to find the temperature of the mixture, you'll have to do the following:

0=\mu_{cup}(\theta_{f}-\theta_{i})+m_{1}C_{w}(\theta_{f}-\theta i)+m_{2}C_{ice}(\theta_{f}-\theta_{i})

after you write that down you'll have to foil everything out then factor out what needs to be factored out with θf and just do simple algebra to find the final temperature.

SO what about melting the ice!
 
@PeterO

So you mean that instead of (mCΔt) of ice for the Qloss, i'll just have to use (mLatent) of ice instead and that only?
 
XwyhyX said:
@PeterO

So you mean that instead of (mCΔt) of ice for the Qloss, i'll just have to use (mLatent) of ice instead and that only?

In most of these problems, yes.

Sometimes we are told that the ice cubes begin at a negative temperture - like -10o - and you then also need a bit of (mCΔt) of ice to allow for the ice warming up to 0o. If you are not given the beginning temperature of the ice, it is reasonable to assume it begins at 0o.
 
I tried that, making the equation

mcΔt of water + mcΔt of glass +mLf

I used this for part a. but i get a negative value,-7.78 degrees is that possible, since i assumed that the ice started from 0 degrees it can't go lower than that can they?
 
bro,

some part of the ice melts, and the other doesnt. madali lng yn homework :)
 
blackandyello said:
bro,

some part of the ice melts, and the other doesnt. madali lng yn homework :)

Ano sagot? haha!
 
  • #10
XwyhyX said:
I tried that, making the equation

mcΔt of water + mcΔt of glass +mLf

I used this for part a. but i get a negative value,-7.78 degrees is that possible, since i assumed that the ice started from 0 degrees it can't go lower than that can they?

That negative temperature is an indicator that not all the ice melted. If you considered the ice had a smaller mass, the answer would have been zero degrees.
That leads to part (b)

re-read post #3; my first response.
 
  • #11
PeterO said:
That negative temperature is an indicator that not all the ice melted. If you considered the ice had a smaller mass, the answer would have been zero degrees.
That leads to part (b)

re-read post #3; my first response.

Thanks. I get it now. :D Last concern, is the negative temperature acceptable as the final temperature of the mixture? Just so I can clear things out. Haha

Thanks again! :D
 
  • #12
XwyhyX said:
Thanks. I get it now. :D Last concern, is the negative temperature acceptable as the final temperature of the mixture? Just so I can clear things out. Haha

Thanks again! :D

The final temperature will never be higher than the beginning highest temperature, nor lower than the beginning lowest temperature.

If we assume the ice begins at 0o that means the final temperature will be at, or above 0o.The only way to get a negative final temperature would be to begin with ice at a very negative temperature - and then the final mix would be solid [ice].
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
963
  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
1K
Replies
12
Views
1K
  • · Replies 17 ·
Replies
17
Views
6K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
2K
  • · Replies 10 ·
Replies
10
Views
4K
  • · Replies 8 ·
Replies
8
Views
3K
Replies
11
Views
2K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
2K
Replies
4
Views
2K