Homogeneous coordinates in projective plane

4 replies · 2K views · last reply
Math Amateur
Gold Member
MHB
Messages
3,920
Reaction score
48

Homework Statement



I am reading the undergraduate introduction to algebraic geometry entitled "Ideals, Varieties and Algorithms: An introduction to Computational Algebraic Geometry and Commutative Algebra (Third Edition) by David Cox, John Little and Donal O'Shea ... ...

I am currently focused on Chapter 8, Section 1: The Projective Plane ... ... and need help getting started with Exercises 5(a) and 5(b) ... ...Exercise 5 in Section 8.1 reads as follows:

Printed textbook exercise 5 with four parts (a to d) on the parabola y = x^2 in the projective plane, asking for homogeneous equation, points at infinity, tangency at infinity, and a hyperbola in (y, z) coordinates.


Can someone please help me to get started on Exercises 5(a) and 5(b) shown above ...

2. Homework Equations


The definitions 1, 2 and 3 in Cox et al Section 8.1 may be relevant ... see the text provided below ...
...

The Attempt at a Solution


[/B]
I am very unsure how to start on this exercise ... but i suspect that the following transformation or map as given in Cox et al Section 8.1 directly after Definition 3 is involved:

##\mathbb{R}^2 \longrightarrow \mathbb{P}^2 ( \mathbb{R} ) ##

where ##(x, y) \in \mathbb{R}^2## is sent to the point ##p \in \mathbb{P}^2 ( \mathbb{R} )## whose homogeneous coordinates are ##(x, y, 1)##Hope someone can help ...

Peter

======================================================================To give readers of the above post some idea of the context of the exercise and also the notation I am providing some relevant text from Cox et al ... ... as follows:
Printed textbook page titled "§1 The Projective Plane" introducing the real projective plane P^2(R), points at infinity for parallel lines, and Definition 1 of the projective plane over R as R^2 union one point at infinity per equivalence class of parallel lines.

Diagram of parallel lines in the plane with slope lines meeting at a point at infinity, marked with arrows and labelled, with a second pair meeting at a different point at infinity.

Printed textbook page discussing the projective plane over the reals: points at infinity forming the line at infinity, the horizon of a perspective picture, and the principle of duality.

Textbook page excerpt on homogeneous coordinates: defines P^2(R) as (R^3 - {0})/~, gives examples of homogeneous coordinates, and states Definitions 2 and 3 of the projective line Ax + By + Cz = 0.

Textbook page showing Proposition 4 on the map from affine plane to projective plane, with a table relating affine lines, projective lines and points at infinity.

Diagram of a line through the origin in three-dimensional coordinates with x, y and z axes, showing points lambda(x,y,z) and (x,y,z) lying on the same line.
 
Attachments
  • Printed textbook exercise 5 with parts a to d on the parabola y = x^2 in the projective plane, asking for homogeneous equation, points at infinity, tangency, and hyperbola form.
    Cox et al ... Exercise 5, Section 8.1 ... ....png
    15.2 KB · Views: 747
  • Printed textbook page titled §1 The Projective Plane, with Definition 1 defining the projective plane over R as R² together with one point at infinity for each equivalence class of parallel lines.
    Cox et al ...- 1 - The Projective Plane - page 1 ... ....png
    54.6 KB · Views: 678
  • Diagram of two parallel lines in the plane meeting at a point at infinity, with a second pair of lines meeting at a different point at infinity; below, a perspective drawing with two vanishing points on a horizon.
    Cox et al ...- 2 - The Projective Plane - page 2 ... ....png
    23.8 KB · Views: 762
  • Textbook page excerpt on the projective plane: the points at infinity form the line at infinity, and the principle of duality swapping point and projective line.
    Cox et al ...- 3 - The Projective Plane - page 3 ... ....png
    42.7 KB · Views: 715
  • Textbook page with printed text and Definitions 2 and 3 on projective plane homogeneous coordinates, including the equivalence relation and set notation for the projective line Ax + By + Cz = 0.
    Cox et al ...- 4 - The Projective Plane - page 4 ... ....png
    37.2 KB · Views: 725
  • Textbook page with Proposition 4 and its proof on the map from affine plane to projective plane, plus a table of affine lines, projective lines and points at infinity.
    Cox et al ...- 5 - The Projective Plane - page 5 ... ....png
    43.6 KB · Views: 733
  • Diagram of a line through the origin in three-dimensional coordinate axes labelled x, y and z, with points (x,y,z) and λ(x,y,z) marked on the line.
    Cox et al ...- 6 - The Projective Plane - page 6 ... ....png
    44 KB · Views: 746
Last edited:
I can have a go at (a).
We want the equation to be compatible with the equation ##y=x^2## and we also want it to give a well-defined curve, which means it must be homogeneous in x,y and z.

A simple equation that satisfies both those is ##yz=x^2##. Then for ##z=1## this gives the original equation. Any point in ##\mathbb R^2## with nonzero ##z## is the same as a point with ##z=1##. The only other points are those with ##z=0##, which are at infinity. For such points we will also have, courtesy of the equation, ##x=0##. So the set of points on the curve at infinity are those on the y-axis in ##\mathbb R^2##. This comprises two equivalence classes: [(0,0,0)] and [(0,1,0)]. So there are two points at infinity, which sounds like what we would want for a parabola (which answers part (b)).

So far so good. I haven't thought about c or d yet.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Math Amateur
andrewkirk said:
I can have a go at (a).
We want the equation to be compatible with the equation ##y=x^2## and we also want it to give a well-defined curve, which means it must be homogeneous in x,y and z.

A simple equation that satisfies both those is ##yz=x^2##. Then for ##z=1## this gives the original equation. Any point in ##\mathbb R^2## with nonzero ##z## is the same as a point with ##z=1##. The only other points are those with ##z=0##, which are at infinity. For such points we will also have, courtesy of the equation, ##x=0##. So the set of points on the curve at infinity are those on the y-axis in ##\mathbb R^2##. This comprises two equivalence classes: [(0,0,0)] and [(0,1,0)]. So there are two points at infinity, which sounds like what we would want for a parabola (which answers part (b)).

So far so good. I haven't thought about c or d yet.

Thanks for the help Andrew ... but ... your solution seems to have been achieved with some good insight ...

Is there a method or process for transforming curves in ##\mathbb{R}^2## to curves in ##\mathbb{P}^2 ( \mathbb{R} )##?

Thanks again ...

Peter

P.S. if you have any ideas about parts (c) and (d) please let me know ...
 
I don't know of any general method but, for curves whose equations are polynomial in x and y, the method is easy enough. You just write out the equation and find the degree of each term, which is the exponent for x plus the exponent for y. Let M be the highest such degree in the equation. Then, to make the equation homogeneous, we multiply each term by ##z^{M-d}## where ##d## is the degree of the term. We then have an equation that is homogeneous - hence making a well-defined curve in the projective plane - and which also involves ##z##.

There are a couple of examples of this technique in the author's discussion following Proposition 4.

(d) is easy. Just set ##x## equal to any nonzero constant, such as 1. The equation then becomes ##yz=1##, which is the classic hyperbola equation.

To do (c) we'd need to understand what the author means by 'tangent to' in the context of a projective plane. Do you know what he means by that?
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Math Amateur
andrewkirk said:
I don't know of any general method but, for curves whose equations are polynomial in x and y, the method is easy enough. You just write out the equation and find the degree of each term, which is the exponent for x plus the exponent for y. Let M be the highest such degree in the equation. Then, to make the equation homogeneous, we multiply each term by ##z^{M-d}## where ##d## is the degree of the term. We then have an equation that is homogeneous - hence making a well-defined curve in the projective plane - and which also involves ##z##.

There are a couple of examples of this technique in the author's discussion following Proposition 4.

(d) is easy. Just set ##x## equal to any nonzero constant, such as 1. The equation then becomes ##yz=1##, which is the classic hyperbola equation.

To do (c) we'd need to understand what the author means by 'tangent to' in the context of a projective plane. Do you know what he means by that?
Thanks Andrew ...

By the way, your approach seems to be a general method to extend algebraic curves in the Euclidean plane to the Projective plane ... the book: "Conics and Cubics: A Concrete Introduction to Algebraic Curves"by Robert Bix outlines the method as follows:
Printed textbook page explaining how to extend algebraic curves to the projective plane using homogeneous polynomials, with equations for homogeneous polynomial F(x, y, z) of degree d and the relation F(tx, ty, tz) = t^d F(x, y, z).

Printed textbook page on homogenizing polynomials to extend Euclidean curves to the projective plane, with equations (2) to (4) and a sketch of the hyperbola xy = 1 labelled Figure 3.1.

Book page showing Figure 3.2, a closed circle-like curve drawn on a page, with surrounding printed text about the projective plane and homogeneous coordinates.
 
Attachments
  • Printed textbook page explaining how algebraic curves are extended to the projective plane using homogeneous polynomials F(x, y, z) of degree d and the equation F(x, y, z) = 0.
    Cox et al - Page 32 - Section 1.3.png
    41.5 KB · Views: 549
  • Printed textbook page on extending Euclidean curves to the projective plane via homogenization, with the hyperbola xy = 1 plotted in a small figure labelled Figure 3.1.
    Cox et al - Page 33 - Section 1.3.png
    37.5 KB · Views: 685
  • Printed textbook page showing Figure 3.2, a closed circle drawn above a page of text discussing points at infinity, homogenization and projective curves.
    Cox et al - Page 34 - Section 1.3.png
    70.8 KB · Views: 668