Hooke's Law Q3: Does Increasing Cross Sectional Area Reduce Work?

4 replies · 2K views · last reply
ravsterphysics
Messages
57
Reaction score
1
Two photographs of a foot-pedal exercise device with two rubber cords: left, a hand grips the handle and pulls the cords taut; right, a person stands on the footplate and pulls the handle up.
Printed text part (d): Explain whether more or less work would be done applying the same maximum total stretching force to a similar exercise device with rubber cords of twice the cross-sectional area.

3. The Attempt at a Solution


My thinking is that if cross sectional area of the cords increase wouldn't the cords be heavier and thus it would require more work to pull/stretch the device? So more work is done?

(But the answers say less work is done because there is a smaller extension/won't stretch as much)
 
What concepts and equations are involved? Note that the weight of the cords is irrelevant here, it can be taken as negligible compared to the force associated with stretching them (think massless springs).
 
gneill said:
What concepts and equations are involved? Note that the weight of the cords is irrelevant here, it can be taken as negligible compared to the force associated with stretching them (think massless springs).

Okay can we then look at stress = force applied / area ?

So if area (cross sectional area) increases then stress decreases which means youngs modulus of the material increases? so it can handle more stress on it?
 
Young's constant for a given material will be constant. Look into how the elasticity of the cords would vary with the cross sectional area (i.e., investigate how the Hooke's law spring constant is related to Young's modulus for a material).