How battery position affects pitching moment slope in model aircraft

1 reply · 3K views · last reply
Leo Liu
Messages
353
Reaction score
156
I am trying to determine how the addition of a counterweight affects the ##C_m-\alpha## (in longitudinal direction) graph for a model plane project, where the counterweight can be considered as the battery.

Geometry diagram of a wing-tail combination showing the zero-lift line of the wing body, center of gravity, tail lift L_t, drag D_t, moment M_ac_t, tail angle of attack alpha_t, and freestream velocities V_inf and V'.

Airfoil nomenclature diagram showing relative wind at angle alpha_w, lift L_w and drag D_w, pitching moment M_ac_w, quarter-chord distance h_ac_w c, center of gravity cg, chord c, and height zc.

Suppose we try to place the battery at the back of the current CoM. The new CoM will be at further back, reducing ##l_t## and increasing ##hc##. According to Anderson't Intro to Flight, the equation is as follows:
this will decrease the slope of the ##C_m-\alpha## curve:

Equation (7.28): d C_M,cg / d alpha_a = a [ h - h_ac_wb - V_H (a_t / a)(1 - d epsilon / d alpha) ]

Now I am wondering if it will have a significant impact on the slope; ##h## is larger, while ##V_H## is smaller. Yet I am not sure which change is more significant to the moment slope.

From the equation (7.24) we can see that at $L_{wing}=0$, ##V_H## will become smaller due to a smaller ##l_t##, increasing the value of ##C_{m\,(L=0)}##:
Textbook page section 7.8 'Total Pitching Moment About the Center of Gravity' with equations 7.23 to 7.25 for the moment coefficient about the center of gravity of an airplane.

where
Equation defining the horizontal tail volume coefficient: V_H equals l_t times S_t, divided by c times S.
.

I think the graph of the line will look like either one of the added lines. The blue one will result in a lower equilibrium angle, thus providing a lower ##C_L##; yet the red line will allow a higher flight angle, thus producing more lift.
Graph of moment coefficient C_M,cg against angle of attack alpha_a, showing a black curve with negative slope crossing zero, with a red and a blue line of steeper negative slope; C_M,0 marked on the vertical axis, alpha_e marked where the trimmed point lies.

Could someone please give a bit more insight into this and tell me if my reasoning is correct?
 
Attachments
  • Graph of moment coefficient C_M,cg against angle of attack alpha_a with a negative slope, showing a black line with a blue and a red line for comparison; the black line is labelled Trimmed at alpha_e and the slope is labelled dC_M,cg/d(alpha_a).
    Screenshot 2022-11-28 at 11.23.27 PM.png
    12 KB · Views: 203
Last edited: