How can I find the optimal launch angle for maximum distance?

  • Thread starter Thread starter hippolyta2078795
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Hard Projectile
Click For Summary

Homework Help Overview

The discussion revolves around determining the optimal launch angle for maximizing the distance a thrown object can travel, specifically in the context of a historical anecdote involving George Washington throwing a silver dollar. The problem involves projectile motion and requires consideration of both horizontal and vertical motion equations.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory, Mathematical reasoning, Problem interpretation, Assumption checking

Approaches and Questions Raised

  • Participants discuss the equations of motion for projectile motion and the challenge of eliminating time to express distance solely as a function of angle. There are attempts to combine horizontal and vertical motion equations, with some participants questioning the assumptions about the trajectory's starting point.

Discussion Status

There is an ongoing exploration of the mathematical relationships involved, with some participants offering guidance on how to manipulate the equations. Multiple interpretations of the problem's setup are being considered, particularly regarding the initial conditions of the throw.

Contextual Notes

Participants are working under the constraints of the problem's historical context, which includes specific values for initial velocity and height. There is also skepticism about the feasibility of the scenario presented, which may affect the assumptions being made in the calculations.

hippolyta2078795
Messages
12
Reaction score
0
George Washington, first President of the United States of America, is purported to have thrown a silver dollar across the Potomac River from the lawn of his home in Mt. Vernon...The Potomac is approximately 5280ft across at that point. Washington was 6foot2 and threw the coin at an initial velocity of 80 miles/hr.

What is the farthest distance Washington could have thrown the coin?
What angle was the coin thrown at to achieve this distance.
What was the height of the coins' trajectory at its highest point?
How long was the coin in flight?

I know how to optimize, but how do I maximize the function accounting for the fact that there are two unknowns. Time and angle.

Thanks
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Realize that you have two equations: one for horizontal, one for vertical. Combine them to eliminate time and get horizontal distance as a function of angle only.
 
still stuck. How do I combine them. It is not ideal parabolic motion because it doesn't start at the origin.
 
It certainly is an exact parabolic trajectory!
 
I mean that it is not ideal because it does not start at the origin.
 
What are your equations of motion and what have you tried to eliminate one of the variables?
 
x(t)=117.3cos(a)t
y(t)=6.167 + 117.3sin(a)t -16t^2
Distance is in feet. Time is in seconds.

I've tried to eliminate variables but I have only yielded new variables.
 
There should be no new variables! Try rewriting t from the x equation and subbing it into the y equation. Its also much easier if you stick to symbols and plug the numbers in at the end.
 
"George Washington, first President of the United States of America, is purported to have thrown a silver dollar across the Potomac River from the lawn of his home in Mt. Vernon...The Potomac is approximately 5280ft across at that point. Washington was 6foot2 and threw the coin at an initial velocity of 80 miles/hr."

Ok, maybe it's just me, but this sounds absurd. I just can't see how a man can throw a silver dollar 1-mile. Nope, don't believe it.
 
  • #10
Besides, there were those pesky Indians about, then, weren't they?
 
  • #11
hippolyta2078795 said:
x(t)=117.3cos(a)t
y(t)=6.167 + 117.3sin(a)t -16t^2
Distance is in feet. Time is in seconds.

I've tried to eliminate variables but I have only yielded new variables.
From the x equation, t = {x_f \over v_i cos \theta} whre x_f represents the final x position. So
<br /> y_f = y_ i + v_i sin \theta { x_f \over v_i cos \theta} - {1 \over 2} g {x_f^2 \over v_i^2 cos^2 \theta}

This can obviously be simplified (in particular, the relation sec^2 \theta = 1 + tan^2 \theta allows you to rewrite everything in terms of tan theta)
 
  • #12
in nrged's equation both y_f,\ y_i, v_i are known quantities. The only unknowns are x,\ \theta. Now we know the x distance traveled is a funtion of the launch angle. We want to know for what launch angle x will be a maximum. Which means that for \frac{dx}{d\theta}=0.
 

Similar threads

Replies
2
Views
3K