B How do alpha particles interact with electrons in gold foil experiments?

AI Thread Summary
Alpha particles interact minimally with electrons in gold foil experiments due to the significant mass difference, with alpha particles being about 7340.6 times heavier than electrons. Consequently, when an alpha particle approaches an electron, it tends to push the electron aside rather than being deflected itself. The electrostatic forces between the charged alpha particle and the electrons are equal, but the mass disparity means the alpha particle's trajectory remains largely unchanged. Quantum mechanics further complicates this interaction, as electrons are better described as a cloud around the nucleus rather than fixed particles, limiting their ability to deflect heavier particles. Understanding these interactions requires a blend of classical mechanics and quantum theory, highlighting the nuances of particle behavior at the atomic level.
tbn032
Messages
34
Reaction score
7
My current understanding:

The mass of alpha particle is approximately 7340.6 times higher than the mass of electron.in the gold foil scattering experiment the deflection of alpha particle due to electron is approximately zero.
The reason that is given is that since the electron is much lighter than the alpha particle, it is unable to deflect the alpha particle and the electron itself get scatted instead of deflecting the alpha particle.

My questions are:

1)How can the electron be pushed or scattered by the alpha particle when the electron is revolving in its orbit around the nucleus, and when the electron is bound to the nucleus?

2)I am unable to understand how is the mass of electron instead of charge (alpha particle has 3.2x10^-19C charge and gold foil has 79 electrons each having -1.6x10^19C charge)relevant in deciding whether it will deflect the alpha particle. The reason around this is given that alpha particle will push through the electron and hence it will not get deflected. How does it exactly matter that the mass of electron is significantly less than electron, the electrostatic forces between the electrons and alpha particle would be the same regardless of mass.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
If you fire a cannonball at a pea then the pea gets scattered and the cannonball will hardly change direction.

You can see the effect of mass qualitatively by studying particle collisions and using energy and momentum conservation. Mass affects both these quantities. Momentum is ##m\vec v## and all that.

tbn032 said:
My current understanding
The mass of alpha particle is approximately 7340.6 times higher than the mass of electron.in the gold foil scattering experiment the deflection of alpha particle due to electron is approximately zero.
The reason that is given is that since the electron is much lighter than the alpha particle, it is unable to deflect the alpha particle and the electron itself get scatted instead of deflecting the alpha particle.
My questions are.
1)How can the electron be pushed or scattered by the alpha particle when the electron is revolving in its orbit around the nucleus, and when the electron is bound to the nucleus?
The answer to this is more subtle. There is a probability that the alpha particle interacts with the electron. You need QM to get the fully story. The energy of the alpha particle must be sufficient to unbind the electron from the nucleus. A cannonball could take your head off!
tbn032 said:
How does it exactly matter that the mass of electron is significantly less than electron, the electrostatic forces between the electrons and alpha particle would be the same regardless of mass.
Newton's second law ##F = ma##. Same force for the same duration accelerates a small particle more than a large one.
 
  • Like
Likes Vanadium 50
tbn032 said:
How does it exactly matter that the mass of electron is significantly less than electron, the electrostatic forces between the electrons and alpha particle would be the same regardless of mass.
If you’re thinking classically, there is an electrostatic force on the electron from the alpha because they are both charged, and there is an equal and opposite force on the alpha from the electron (by Newton’s third law). But the alpha is far more massive, so the same force moves it much less - basically the electron gets shoved out of the way without appreciably changing the path of the alpha.

Be aware though that there is only so far you can push that classical model. We now know from quantum mechanics that electrons aren’t small solid objects orbiting the nucleus. It’s better (still not right, for that we need quantum electrodynamics with its fairly daunting mathematical price of admission) to think of the electrons as a sort of cloud around the nucleus that no more deflects the alpha than a cloud in the sky deflects a bullet.
 
Nugatory said:
think of the electrons as a sort of cloud around the nucleus
Also, the total charge (79+) of the gold nucleus could be thought of as a replulsive force which would perhaps yield a smaller measured diameter of that nucleus.
 
I think it's easist first to watch a short vidio clip I find these videos very relaxing to watch .. I got to thinking is this being done in the most efficient way? The sand has to be suspended in the water to move it to the outlet ... The faster the water , the more turbulance and the sand stays suspended, so it seems to me the rule of thumb is the hose be aimed towards the outlet at all times .. Many times the workers hit the sand directly which will greatly reduce the water...
Back
Top