How do they know distance of the original standard candle?

In summary, astronomers use standard candles such as Type 1a supernovae or cephied variables to calculate the distances of galaxies. However, in order for this method to work, they must first calibrate the standard candle by using other methods such as parallax or the moving cluster method. Parallax involves measuring the slight change in position of stars over time, while the moving cluster method uses Doppler shift and trigonometry to determine the distance of the cluster. Once nearby clusters are used as a reference, the distance scale can be extended to more distant clusters by comparing their main sequence on the Hertzsprung-Russell diagram.
  • #1
james gander
21
1
First thing i want to do is tell you what i do know.

I know to that astronomers use a standard candle such as a Type 1a supernova or a cephied varibale because they are always the same brightness.

I know that a light source is four times less bright when it is twice as distant.

I know that they use supernovae to calculate the distances of galaxies using this information.

The problem is for this method to work then surely they needed to know the distance to the original supernova.

How do they measure the distance of the original original light source they are using as a standard candle?
 
Space news on Phys.org
  • #2
You must first use another method to calibrate the standard candle. The methods that come to mind are parallax and star cluster H-R diagram comparison.
You probably know about parallax (if not, wikipedia has a good article), and the latter method is described e.g. here: http://www.unm.edu/~astro1/101lab/lab10/lab10_C.html or here: http://eaae-astronomy.org/WG3-SS/WorkShops/Cluster.html

this one's probably better:
https://www.e-education.psu.edu/astro801/content/l7_p7.html
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • Like
Likes marcus and james gander
  • #3
In some treatments of the "distance ladder" there is a stage or "rung" in the ladder that comes between parallax and the H-R diagram comparison
It is called "moving cluster" method.
You use doppler shift to tell radial speed. For example if the cluster is moving away then the stars should be be making a smaller and smaller angle to each other. Depending on how far. So you watch the cluster for some tens of years. Then you use TRIGONOMETRY to calculate the distance to the cluster.
This is for small nearby clusters in our galaxy. The doppler shift is for ordinary motion, not cosmological expansion. The Hyades are a good example of a moving cluster that helps to calibrate distance scale.
===quote https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Open_cluster#Astronomical_distance_scale ==
Determining the distances to astronomical objects is crucial to understanding them, but the vast majority of objects are too far away for their distances to be directly determined. Calibration of the astronomical distance scale relies on a sequence of indirect and sometimes uncertain measurements relating the closest objects, for which distances can be directly measured, to increasingly distant objects.[55] Open clusters are a crucial step in this sequence.

The closest open clusters can have their distance measured directly by one of two methods. First, the parallax (the small change in apparent position over the course of a year caused by the Earth moving from one side of its orbit around the Sun to the other) of stars in close open clusters can be measured, like other individual stars. Clusters such as the Pleiades, Hyades and a few others within about 500 light years are close enough for this method to be viable, and results from the Hipparcos position-measuring satellite yielded accurate distances for several clusters.[56][57]

The other direct method is the so-called moving cluster method. This relies on the fact that the stars of a cluster share a common motion through space. Measuring the proper motions of cluster members and plotting their apparent motions across the sky will reveal that they converge on a vanishing point. The radial velocity of cluster members can be determined from Doppler shiftmeasurements of their spectra, and once the radial velocity, proper motion and angular distance from the cluster to its vanishing point are known, simple trigonometry will reveal the distance to the cluster. The Hyades are the best known application of this method, which reveals their distance to be 46.3 parsecs.[58]

Once the distances to nearby clusters have been established, further techniques can extend the distance scale to more distant clusters. By matching the main sequence on the Hertzsprung-Russell diagram for a cluster at a known distance with that of a more distant cluster, the distance to the more distant cluster can be estimated.
==endquote==
 
  • Like
Likes james gander
  • #4
marcus said:
It is called "moving cluster" method.
Cheers marcus, I wasn't aware of this one.
 

1. How do scientists determine the distance of the original standard candle?

Scientists use a method called the "distance ladder" to determine the distance of the original standard candle. This involves using a series of techniques and measurements, such as parallax, spectroscopy, and the cosmic distance scale, to accurately calculate distances in space.

2. What is the original standard candle used for?

The original standard candle, also known as a "standardizable candle," is used as a reference point for measuring distances in astronomy. By knowing the intrinsic brightness of the candle, scientists can compare it to the apparent brightness observed from Earth to calculate the distance.

3. How is the original standard candle calibrated?

The original standard candle is calibrated by measuring the absolute brightness of a large sample of these objects and using statistical techniques to determine an average value. This value is then used as the reference point for measuring distances in space.

4. Can the original standard candle be used for all distances?

No, the original standard candle is only suitable for measuring distances within our own galaxy, the Milky Way. For more distant objects, such as other galaxies, other methods, such as using Type Ia supernovae, are used to determine distances.

5. How accurate is the distance calculated using the original standard candle?

The accuracy of the distance calculated using the original standard candle depends on the precision of the measurements used in the "distance ladder" method. In general, it is considered to have a margin of error of about 10-15%. However, with advancements in technology and techniques, scientists are constantly working to improve the accuracy of these measurements.

Similar threads

Replies
1
Views
996
Replies
46
Views
5K
Replies
4
Views
1K
Replies
16
Views
3K
Replies
93
Views
12K
Replies
9
Views
858
Replies
14
Views
1K
Replies
6
Views
1K
Replies
8
Views
2K
Back
Top