How Do You Calculate Elevator Cable Tension Accurately?

Click For Summary

Homework Help Overview

The discussion revolves around calculating the tension in an elevator cable, specifically in a scenario where the elevator is raised with an initial upward velocity. Participants reference an applet that illustrates the problem and mention energy bar graphs to aid in their understanding of the situation.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory, Conceptual clarification, Mathematical reasoning, Problem interpretation

Approaches and Questions Raised

  • Participants explore the relationship between mass, velocity, distance, and acceleration to determine tension. They discuss using kinematic equations and energy principles, questioning the initial conditions and the significance of the energy values provided in the applet.

Discussion Status

Several participants have engaged in deriving equations and discussing the implications of their calculations. There is an ongoing exploration of different methods to arrive at the tension value, with some participants offering alternative approaches for verification. The discussion is active, with participants clarifying concepts and checking each other's reasoning.

Contextual Notes

Participants note the importance of significant figures in their calculations and the constraints of the problem, such as the need for specific values like mass and distance. There is also mention of the energy values marked in the applet, which are relevant to the calculations being discussed.

polymerase
Messages
28
Reaction score
0
omg I am so lost for this question,

look at this video first
http://mp.pearsoncmg.com/probhtml/applets/setup5_5_3.html

It shows an elevator with a small initial upward velocity being raised by a cable. The tension in the cable is constant. The energy bar graphs are marked in intervals of 600 J.

Question: Find the magnitude of the tension T in the cable. Be certain that the method you are using will be accurate to two significant figures.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Do they give the mass of the object?

From the applet. What is the initial velocity? What is the final velocity? What is the distance?

From these 3 you can get acceleration... then you can get the tension in the cable if you know the mass of the object, or the weight.
 
learningphysics said:
Do they give the mass of the object?

From the applet. What is the initial velocity? What is the final velocity? What is the distance?

From these 3 you can get acceleration... then you can get the tension in the cable if you know the mass of the object, or the weight.

(v_2)^2 = (v_1)^2 + 2ad
0 = 16 + 2(a)(4)
a=2

U = mgh
2400 = m(9.8)(4)
m=61.22

f=ma
=2(61.22)
= 122.45 N

Is that right?
 
polymerase said:
(v_2)^2 = (v_1)^2 + 2ad
0 = 16 + 2(a)(4)
a=2

a = -2

U = mgh
2400 = m(9.8)(4)
m=61.22

Good! I forgot about that 600J part... so you have the mass.

f=ma
=2(61.22)
= 122.45 N

Is that right?

Net force = ma

so T - mg = ma

from that you can get T... you need to use a = -2...

another way to do this problem (I didn't think of it before), and probably the better way is that you can say:

Work done by tension = final mechanical energy - initial mechanical energy

So
T*4 = mgh_{final} + (1/2)mv_{final}^2 - mgh_{initial} - (1/2)mv_{initial}^2<br />

<br /> v_{final} = 0.<br />

<br /> h_{initial} = 0<br />

so this becomes

<br /> T*4 = mgh_{final} - (1/2)mv_{initial}^2<br />

this way, you should get the same T as above... so it's a way you can double check your answer.
 
Last edited:
learningphysics said:
a = -2



Good! I forgot about that 600J part... so you have the mass.



Net force = ma

so T - mg = ma

from that you can get T... you need to use a = -2...

another way to do this problem (I didn't think of it before), and probably the better way is that you can say:

Work done by tension = final mechanical energy - initial mechanical energy

So
T*4 = mgh_{final} + (1/2)mv_{final}^2 - mgh_{initial} - (1/2)mv_{initial}^2<br />

<br /> v_{final} = 0.<br />

<br /> h_{initial} = 0<br />

so this becomes

<br /> T*4 = mgh_{final} - (1/2)mv_{initial}^2<br />

this way, you should get the same T as above... so it's a way you can double check your answer.

THANK YOU THANK YOU THANK YOU...
just one aside question...the equation that u have on top there how come you multipled the tension by 4?
THANK YOU THANK YOU THANK YOU
 
no prob. the 4m is just the final height - initial height... 4 - 0 = 4m

it is the distance through which the tension acts... hence work by tension = T*4m
 
learningphysics said:
no prob. the 4m is just the final height - initial height... 4 - 0 = 4m

it is the distance through which the tension acts... hence work by tension = T*4m

oh i see. ok so let me get this straight. is this statement true?

W = mgh_{final} + (1/2)mv_{final}^2 - mgh_{initial} - (1/2)mv_{initial}^2
but since W = F\Deltad, where F in this case is the tension, then therefore,
F\Deltad = mgh_{final} + (1/2)mv_{final}^2 - mgh_{initial} - (1/2)mv_{initial}^2

would you be able to help me on another physics problems??:smile:, its already posted, its called Impulse and average force
 
Yes, that's right. The way I keep track of it is... the forces that go in the left side of the equation are all the forces that aren't being dealt with as potential energy...

That's only T. although gravity is a force acting on the object, it is being dealt with as potential energy on the right side... so it doesn't go into the left side...

if I didn't want to use gravitational potential energy... I could say:

(T - mg)*4 = 1/2mvfinal^2 - 1/2mvinitial^2

this is mathematically exactly the same as before... but conceptually slightly different... I'm not choosing to deal with the gravitational force as energy...

it's always more convenient to use energies when you can.

of course change in kinetic energy must always be included on the right side.
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
3K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
3K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
4K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
2K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • · Replies 8 ·
Replies
8
Views
70K
Replies
2
Views
3K
Replies
4
Views
3K
Replies
9
Views
8K
Replies
4
Views
4K