How Do You Calculate Vector Change in 2D Elastic Billiard Ball Collisions?

4 replies · 2K views · last reply
MatusVeselka
Messages
2
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement


Hello I am trying to predict vector after collision of 2 ball in biliard. I am using angle-free representation formulas from wikipedia : https://wikimedia.org/api/rest_v1/media/math/render/svg/14d5feb68844edae9e31c9cb4a2197ee922e409cx1 and x2 are positions of balls, m1 and m2 are masses of balls, v1 and v2 are vectors of direction before collision and the angle brackets indicate the inner product (or dot product) of two vectors.

my values are :
x1 = (0.5 , 0)
x2 = (0 , 1)
m1,m2 = 1
v1 = (0.5, 1)
v2 = (0, 0)

Untitled-1.png


Homework Equations


Two displayed equations giving the post-collision velocities v1' and v2' of two balls in an elastic collision, using positions x1 and x2, masses m1 and m2, and velocities v1 and v2.

The Attempt at a Solution


Handwritten working on grid paper: V1' = (0.5, 1) - (2-1)/(1+1) · <(0.5,1),(0.5,-1)>/||(0.5,-1)||² · (0.5,-1), then V1' = (0.5, 1) - 1 · (-0.75)/(1.1180) · (0.5,-1), then the boxed result V1' = (0.835, 0.329). Below is a sketch of two circles on a horizontal line with axes, and an arrow pointing to the lower circle.

[/B]
And here its my solution with vector (0.835 , 0.329), but this result can't be correct can somebody help me what I am doing wrong ? My result is total wrong and i don't know why
 
Attachments
  • Untitled-1.png
    Untitled-1.png
    59.7 KB · Views: 707
  • Two displayed equations giving the post-collision velocities v1' and v2' of two balls in an elastic collision, using positions x1 and x2, masses m1 and m2, and velocities v1 and v2.
    terms.png
    3.3 KB · Views: 828
  • Handwritten working on grid paper: V1' = (0.5, 1) - (2-1)/(1+1) · <(0.5,1),(0.5,-1)>/||(0.5,-1)||² · (0.5,-1), then V1' = (0.5, 1) - 1 · (-0.75)/(1.1180) · (0.5,-1), then the boxed result V1' = (0.835, 0.329). Below is a sketch of two circles on a horizontal line with axes, and an arrow pointing to the lower circle.
    solution.png
    127.7 KB · Views: 706
Hello Matus, :welcome:

Who says it's totally wrong ?
As it happens, the wikipedia page has an animation of 2 5 SF pieces colliding in exactly (##\approx##) this way. You could take screen shots and measure the vectors !
 
When i simulate my example on some online calculators then vectors must look like this for my parameters
Two-panel diagram titled Before and After showing two circles with velocity arrows: before collision a grey circle sits above an orange circle, and after collision the circles have moved and their arrows have changed direction.

But my final vector after collision its going to wrong direction :(
 
Attachments
  • Two-panel diagram titled Before and After showing two circles with velocity arrows: before collision a grey circle sits above an orange circle, and after collision the circles have moved and their arrows have changed direction.
    beforAfter.png
    5 KB · Views: 723
MatusVeselka said:
some online calculators
Hogwash: there ##\vec v_2\ne0##