How Does d-d Transition Occur with No Free Higher Energy d-Orbitals Available?

Click For Summary
SUMMARY

The discussion centers on the mechanism of d-d transitions in transition metals when higher energy d-orbitals are occupied by coordinate covalent bonds, specifically with cyanide (CN-). It is established that d-d transitions occur within the metal ion itself and not between atoms, as the d-orbitals form covalent bonds with sp hybrid orbitals on carbon. The conversation also clarifies the distinction between Valence Bond Theory and Crystal Field Theory, emphasizing that while both theories explain different properties of complex compounds, they can be used complementarily to understand phenomena such as coloration and bonding in transition metal complexes.

PREREQUISITES
  • Understanding of d-d transitions in transition metals
  • Familiarity with coordinate covalent bonds and hybridization
  • Knowledge of Valence Bond Theory and Crystal Field Theory
  • Basic concepts of electronic configuration in transition metals
NEXT STEPS
  • Study the principles of Crystal Field Theory and its application to transition metal complexes
  • Explore Valence Bond Theory in detail, focusing on hybridization and bonding
  • Investigate the role of ligands in influencing the electronic structure of transition metals
  • Learn about the spectroscopic techniques used to analyze d-d transitions in coordination compounds
USEFUL FOR

Chemistry students, theoretical chemists, and professionals in materials science seeking to deepen their understanding of transition metal chemistry and the interplay between bonding theories.

leojun
Messages
26
Reaction score
0
upload_2014-11-29_23-35-14.jpeg

how does d-d transition take place when there are no free higher energy level d-orbital's left(as the only two higher energy d orbitals form coordinate bond with CN-?
 

Attachments

  • upload_2014-11-29_22-31-27.jpeg
    upload_2014-11-29_22-31-27.jpeg
    2.6 KB · Views: 629
Chemistry news on Phys.org
The d-orbitals form a covalent 2-electron bond with the sp hybrid orbitals on C. So in each bond there are 2 orbitals involved which can take up up to 4 electrons.
 
DrDu said:
The d-orbitals form a covalent 2-electron bond with the sp hybrid orbitals on C. So in each bond there are 2 orbitals involved which can take up up to 4 electrons.
nope,they form a special covalent bond called coordinate covalent bond with cn- and d-d transition happens within a transition metal or ion only.d-d transition doesn't happen between two atoms especially not with c.
 
The dative bond looks like ## \mathrm{Fe \quad C \uparrow\downarrow \longleftrightarrow Fe \uparrow \quad C\downarrow \longleftrightarrow Fe \downarrow \quad C \uparrow }##.
If you excite a d electron into that bond, you get a weaker 3 electron bond ## \mathrm{Fe\uparrow \quad C \uparrow\downarrow \longleftrightarrow Fe \uparrow \downarrow \quad C\uparrow } ##.
 
DrDu said:
The dative bond looks like ## \mathrm{Fe \quad C \uparrow\downarrow \longleftrightarrow Fe \uparrow \quad C\downarrow \longleftrightarrow Fe \downarrow \quad C \uparrow }##.
If you excite a d electron into that bond, you get a weaker 3 electron bond ## \mathrm{Fe\uparrow \quad C \uparrow\downarrow \longleftrightarrow Fe \uparrow \downarrow \quad C\uparrow } ##.
but there can only be two electrons in an hybridized orbital
 
Yes, if you look, neither the d orbital un Fe nor the sp hybrid orbital on C contains more than 2 electrons in any of the resonance structures.
 
sorry for the disturbance brother,Dr Du . I wasn't satisfied,so i went to a near by book store and searched every single book on this topic.guess what i found...I FOUND THAT THERE WAS NO RELATION BETWEEN VALENCE BOND THEORY AND CRYSTAL FIELD THEORY(they are two different theories used to explain different properties of complex compound's.for example-VALENCE BOND THEORY is used to explain the orientation of the ligands around the central metal atom or ion where as the CRYSTAL FIELD THEORY is used to explain the coloration of complex compound ).
 
It is true that crystal field theory is usually used to explain absorption spectra of complexes. However, that doesn't mean that an explanation in terms of VB theory isn't possible and as a trained theoretical chemist I would be rather worried if there were some qualitative properties of a molecule which I could explain using one theory but not, without good reason, some other.
The diagram you were showing in your first post alludes clearly to valence bond theory, as it introduces d2sp3 hybrids and first shows up in Pauling's book "The nature of the chemical bond", who uses mostly VB theory. Hence I tried to give you an explanation in terms of VB theory. If your question was in reality about crystal field theory, then I wonder why you didn't say so in the first post.
 
To be true,i didn't know that there was a VB theory way to explain it.i thought VB theory and CF theory were interrelated.
what i thought-
step 1 - coordination bond forms between ligand and central metal atom or ion forming complex ion
step 2 - after the formation of complex ion,CF theory comes into play and gives color to the complex ion(through d-d transition)
i wanted to know how d-d transition took place when there were no free higher energy level d-orbital's left(as the only two higher energy d orbitals formed coordinate bond with CN-. this confusion was due to my comprehensive textbook(gives info about all aspects but in a confusing way). thank you for your time:)
 

Similar threads

Replies
4
Views
2K
Replies
3
Views
2K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
2K
Replies
3
Views
3K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
2K
Replies
9
Views
4K
  • · Replies 29 ·
Replies
29
Views
3K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
3K
  • · Replies 56 ·
2
Replies
56
Views
7K