How Quickly Can an Eagle Distinguish Two Mice as Separate Objects?

  • Thread starter Thread starter jlax31
  • Start date Start date
Click For Summary
SUMMARY

The discussion centers on calculating the time it takes for an eagle to distinguish two field mice as separate objects based on its eye's resolving power. The eagle's pupil diameter is 5.93 mm, and the mice are 0.0124 m apart at a distance of 186 m. The initial calculations yield a time of approximately 6.85 seconds, but the correct approach involves using the vacuum wavelength of light (565 nm) and adjusting for the medium (air) to avoid rounding errors. The final resolution requires solving for the distance where the angular separation equals the resolution limit.

PREREQUISITES
  • Understanding of angular resolution and its calculation
  • Knowledge of light wavelength and its effect in different media
  • Familiarity with basic physics concepts related to motion and speed
  • Ability to perform unit conversions and handle significant figures
NEXT STEPS
  • Learn about angular resolution in optics and its applications
  • Study the effects of medium on light wavelength and refraction
  • Explore kinematic equations for calculating time, distance, and speed
  • Investigate the principles of visual perception in birds of prey
USEFUL FOR

Students and professionals in optics, wildlife biology, and physics, particularly those interested in visual acuity and motion analysis in animals.

jlax31
Messages
5
Reaction score
0
Hello all, I'm little stumped on this question. Have tried multiple times and can not find the right answer to it. Here it is:

1. Question

The pupil of an eagle's eye has a diameter of 5.93 mm. Two field mice are separated by 0.0124 m. From a distance of 186 m, the eagle sees them as one unresolved object and dives toward them at a speed of 18.1 m/s. Assume that the eagle's eye detects light that has a wavelength of 565 nm in a vacuum. How much time passes until the eagle sees the mice as separate objects?



3. The Attempt at a Solution

565e-9/5.93e-3 = 9.527824620573355e-5 or approx 1.00x 10^-4 which is the resolving angle
.0124/186 = 6.666666666666667e-5 which is approx 2/3 of resolving angle (this is angle when eagle starts)

if taking 2/3 of 186m I get 124.

124m / 18.1 m/s = 6.85s


However, the answer is wrong. Any advice/help/etc.?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Why don't you just solve for the distance at which the angular separation of the mice is equal to the resolution limit?

(0.0124 m)/(d) = (565 nm)/(5.93 mm)

Solve for d.

Your approach was fine, and equivalent, except that you introduced a huge rounding error by rounding that first angle up.
 
I actually had 7.19s as my first answer which is what you get when you solve for d. This answer is apparently wrong though.. :confused:
 
jlax31 said:
I actually had 7.19s as my first answer which is what you get when you solve for d. This answer is apparently wrong though.. :confused:

Hopefully you realized that your method and "solving for d" are not actually different methods. It's just that your ratio should have been closer to 0.7 rather than 0.667 --- an error that was due to rounding.

In any case, as for why you are getting the wrong answer still: the only think that I can think of is that the problem explicitly mentions that 565 nm is the vacuum wavelength of the light that the eagle is sensitive to. But the eagle and the mice are not in a vacuum. I don't know why else this information would have been specified in the first place, if not so that you could convert this to the wavelength in the appropriate medium (in this case air).
 

Similar threads

Stargazing Calculating the Resolving power of a Telescope
  • · Replies 7 ·
Replies
7
Views
4K
Stargazing What are the limitations of astrophotography and how can they be overcome?
  • · Replies 34 ·
2
Replies
34
Views
14K
Textbooks on Condensed Matter Physics
  • · Replies 19 ·
Replies
19
Views
18K