Art How the Earth Was Made (or Evolved)

  • Thread starter Thread starter Astronuc
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Earth
AI Thread Summary
The History Channel's series "How the Earth Was Made" presents various geological and historical topics, though it contains some inaccuracies. Notably, it misrepresents carbon-14's instability as a molecular issue rather than a nuclear one. The series also simplifies the process of carbon-14 uptake and decay in plants, failing to clarify that the uptake ceases upon a plant's death, affecting the ratios of carbon isotopes over time. The series discusses significant geological events, such as the eruption around 535 CE that led to a volcanic winter, impacting global temperatures and contributing to historical famines. It also explores the geological history of Scotland and North America, highlighting their past connection during the Jurassic period and the formation of the Old Red Sandstone. The series includes intriguing insights into the Lewisian Gneiss and the geological features of the Marianas Trench and Krakatoa, enriching the viewer's understanding of Earth's geological history.
Astronuc
Staff Emeritus
Science Advisor
Gold Member
Messages
22,340
Reaction score
7,138
The History Channel has developed a series on "How the Earth was made". My wife has been listening to it in the evening and I've caught some of it. Mostly good, but the narration mentions some unnecessary commentary, and in the first program, it gets the description of carbon-14 uptake wrong (it mentions the molecular structure of carbon-14 being a more unstable isotope), so it doesn't rise to the level of quality material for the Earth Science forum. It is the 'nuclear' structure of 14C that makes it unstable, not the molecular structure. A small but significant error.Comments on carbon-14 starts at 15:12 and goes through 15:32. The other somewhat inaccurate comment is that carbon-14 is absorbed by the plant (which it is with 12C and 13C often in the form of CO2), and then decays at a know rate. Well, 14C is continually decaying, however, it is the uptake of CO2 and 14C that stops when a plant dies, and 14C continues to decay, so what changes are the ratios of 14C to 13C and 12C as time goes on. The basis also include the notion that the carbon ratios are relatively constant in the environment, but that can change slightly depending on solar proton, cosmic radiation, atmospheric nuclear weapons testing, and apparently comets.

https://www.geo.arizona.edu/Antevs/ecol438/radiocarbon.html
https://www.nature.com/articles/srep03728

Nevertheless, there is some good information and the topics are interesting.
 
  • Informative
  • Like
Likes pinball1970, Oldman too, Fervent Freyja and 1 other person
Science news on Phys.org
The Deepest Place on Earth | How the Earth Was Made (S1, E2)
The Marianas Trench explored
 
Krakatoa: Devastating Explosion | How the Earth Was Made (S1, E3)There is some interesting discussion about sulfuric acid in ice from Antarctica. Ice cores show layers, which like tree rings, represent annual records. Apparently there is a layer with increased sulfuric acid content around 535 CE, which would indicate a very large eruption. Year 536 had a long cold period. The eruption of Krakotoa (Krakatau) in 1883 caused a similarly large spike in sulfuric acid in the Antarctic.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Volcanic_winter_of_536
Summer temperatures in 536 fell by as much as 2.5 degrees Celsius (4.5 degrees Fahrenheit) below normal in Europe. The lingering impact of the volcanic winter of 536 was augmented in 539–540 when another volcanic eruption caused summer temperatures to decline as much as 2.7 degrees Celsius (4.9 degrees Fahrenheit) below normal in Europe. There is evidence of still another volcanic eruption in 547 which would have extended the cooler period. The volcanic eruptions, accompanied by the Plague of Justinian, which began in 541, caused crop failures, famine, and millions of deaths and initiated the Late Antique Little Ice Age, which lasted from 536 to 660.

I have been under the impression that the volcanic eruption responsible for the 536 climate had occurred in Iceland.
 
Something I did not know. What is now New York and Connecticut were once connected to Scotland! Hills on the Western side of Loch Ness are composed of the same rock as that in the Catskill Mountains. The two regions were connected during the Jurassic period, but separated with the formation of the Atlantic Ocean. Scotland was apparently about 2000 miles south of its present location.



How the Earth was made, Loch Nesshttps://www.geolsoc.org.uk/Policy-and-Media/Outreach/Plate-Tectonic-Stories/Great-Glen-Fault

https://thecatskillgeologist.com/2017/03/30/brick-red-strata-3-30-17/
https://www.earthmagazine.org/article/travels-geology-hiking-catskill-mountain-front/

The layers of red and honey-coloured sandstone that make up the cliffs are between 380 and 370 million years old and date from the Devonian Period, when Scotland lay south of the equator and was part of a huge desert continent. The rocks that formed on this ancient landmass are traditionally known as the Old Red Sandstone. In Devonian times the area including modern-day Orkney, Shetland and north-east mainland Scotland was part of a large depression known as the Orcadian Basin. The rocks that formed in this basin, on desert plains and in lakes, salt flats, dunes and rivers, are preserved today in Orkney to dramatic effect.
https://www.scottishgeology.com/best-places/hoy-orkney/

The Old Red Sandstone is an assemblage of rocks in the North Atlantic region largely of Devonian age. It extends in the east across Great Britain, Ireland and Norway, and in the west along the northeastern seaboard of North America. It also extends northwards into Greenland and Svalbard.[
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Old_Red_Sandstone

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Laurasia#Laurussia

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/North_Atlantic_Craton

Another term occurrent in the video is 'Lewisian Gneiss', a suite of Precambrian metamorphic rocks that outcrop in the northwestern part of Scotland, forming part of the Hebridean Terrane and the North Atlantic Craton. These rocks are of Archaean and Paleoproterozoic age, ranging from 3.0–1.7 billion years (Ga).
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lewisian_complex

I didn't know about "Highlands controversy of Northwest Scotland" either.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Highlands_controversy_of_Northwest_Scotland

Fascinating stuff!
 
Last edited:
Historian seeks recognition for first English king https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/c9d07w50e15o Somewhere I have a list of Anglo-Saxon, Wessex and English kings. Well there is nothing new there. Parts of Britain experienced tribal rivalries/conflicts as well as invasions by the Romans, Vikings/Norsemen, Angles, Saxons and Jutes, then Normans, and various monarchs/emperors declared war on other monarchs/emperors. Seems that behavior has not ceased.
Back
Top