How to be a physicist with my credentials.?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Newtons2ndLaw
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Physicist
Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around the challenges and pathways for a 17-year-old aspiring physicist with a low GPA. Participants explore the importance of hard work, potential educational routes such as community college, and resources for improving understanding in physics and mathematics.

Discussion Character

  • Debate/contested
  • Conceptual clarification
  • Homework-related
  • Technical explanation

Main Points Raised

  • One participant expresses a newfound passion for physics but acknowledges a low GPA and lack of effort in previous studies.
  • Several participants emphasize the necessity of hard work to succeed in physics and question the commitment of the original poster.
  • Some suggest that attending community college could provide a second chance to improve academic standing and prepare for university.
  • There are recommendations for using resources like Khan Academy, but participants stress that watching videos alone is insufficient without rigorous practice and exercises.
  • Participants discuss the importance of a strong mathematical foundation before pursuing physics, recommending specific textbooks for both mathematics and physics.
  • One participant warns that understanding the material requires deep engagement, not just superficial reading.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants generally agree on the need for hard work and the importance of a solid mathematical background for studying physics. However, there is disagreement regarding the original poster's commitment and the effectiveness of their current study habits.

Contextual Notes

Some participants highlight the need for a complete understanding of the material, indicating that the original poster's current approach may not be sufficient. There is also a discussion about the varying levels of difficulty in recommended textbooks, which may depend on the original poster's prior knowledge and readiness.

Newtons2ndLaw
Messages
10
Reaction score
0
Okay, I am a 17 year old African American Male, i have had many changes in what i want to major in when i get to college, First i started with being a scientist, then a chemist but then i actually took the class chemistry (Regents Course) and it blew my mind and frankly i hated it. Then i realized i really enjoy history, so i thought of being a historian. Then when i reached 11th grade i took Physics for the first time, and my eyes were open to a new world, i fell in-love with it immediately..but right now my grades are really messed up. i Probably have less than a 2.0 GPA, its not that i can't do the work...i just don't its shameful honestly, but can you guys tell me what you think about this? Can things turn around for me to actually bring my dream to fruition?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Newtons2ndLaw said:
its not that i can't do the work...i just don't

Then you can't be a physicist. Simple as that. Being a physicist takes work - a lot of it.

Newtons2ndLaw said:
Can things turn around for me to actually bring my dream to fruition?

Nope. You can wait forever for things to turn around by themselves. You can turn them around, though.
 
When i say can things turn that's what i mean, if i work at it...and with me not doing the work, I am starting to realize that's pretty childish and I am starting to do my work and things
 
Thank you for the honesty
 
So you don't want to put in any work. Fine. What do you think you'll ever going to accomplish in this life?? EVERYTHING takes work, not only being a physicist.
If you think your own future is not important enough to put in any work, then by all means, keep doing what you are doing.
 
To counter some of the ''tough love'' responses here, if you want to ''reinvent'' yourself in a way, you need to go to community college, it is your second chance to be able to go to a university. All you need to go to community college is have a GED or High school diploma. You can take all your lower division courses at a community college before transferring, but this time you will have to work hard and earn good grades, so you aren't doomed quite yet.
 
Woopy said:
To counter some of the ''tough love'' responses here, if you want to ''reinvent'' yourself in a way, you need to go to community college, it is your second chance to be able to go to a university. All you need to go to community college is have a GED or High school diploma. You can take all your lower division courses at a community college before transferring, but this time you will have to work hard and earn good grades, so you aren't doomed quite yet.

Quite true. It's never too late. But don't start in a community college unless you're prepared to work hard and give yourself 100%.
 
Woopy said:
To counter some of the ''tough love'' responses here, if you want to ''reinvent'' yourself in a way, you need to go to community college, it is your second chance to be able to go to a university. All you need to go to community college is have a GED or High school diploma. You can take all your lower division courses at a community college before transferring, but this time you will have to work hard and earn good grades, so you aren't doomed quite yet.
the "tough love" is what i need to be honest, but i AM starting to change, I've probably been Googles #1 fan for the past couple of weeks, I am just looking for different feedback from people who like physics too
 
micromass said:
Quite true. It's never too late. But don't start in a community college unless you're prepared to work hard and give yourself 100%.

I know the road ahead is going to be difficult, but i enjoy physics so i don't mind the hard work
 
  • #10
Newtons2ndLaw said:
I know the road ahead is going to be difficult, but i enjoy physics so i don't mind the hard work

Then stop googling and wasting time on the internet. Start working and studying.
 
  • #12
Yes, khan academy is very good. You should keep using that!

But only watching videos is not enough. You need to make A LOT of exercises if you really want to grasp the material. So get yourself a decent textbook and start working exercises. If you combine khan academy and a regular textbook, then you can get very far.
 
  • #13
micromass said:
Yes, khan academy is very good. You should keep using that!

But only watching videos is not enough. You need to make A LOT of exercises if you really want to grasp the material. So get yourself a decent textbook and start working exercises. If you combine khan academy and a regular textbook, then you can get very far.

Do you have any textbooks in mind?
 
  • #14
Newtons2ndLaw said:
Do you have any textbooks in mind?

For which subject specifically?
 
  • #15
micromass said:
For which subject specifically?

Physics, a textbook that can cover basic things (so i can brush up) and more advanced things
 
  • #16
Newtons2ndLaw said:
Physics, a textbook that can cover basic things (so i can brush up) and more advanced things

Before you start physics, I suggest you work on your math first. If you don't know math extremely well, then you shouldn't even think about starting in physics.

A book I always tend to recommend (because it is just THAT good) is "basic mathematics" by Serge Lang. It covers about everything you need to know about high school mathematics. Work that book until you understand everything and until you can work every exercise. Lang's book is not easy however, so you might want to complement it with other sources such as Khan academy.

After that, you can start with studying calculus. I like the book "practical analysis in one variable" by Estep. It contains a lot of information on calculus and it is suitable for a high-schooler. You might want to learn from a more rigorous book later (such as Spivak or Apostol), but they might be overkill for now.

After that, you're ready to start physics. The book by Halliday and Resnick is a good place to start (but only if you know calculus). You don't need to know calculus to start physics, you can also work with an algebra-based physics book, but I don't recommend this.

The books I recommend are books you should really WORK through. Just reading them and skimming theml a bit is not sufficient. You need to understand every sentence and every word, you need to work the exercises and you need to ask a lot of questions. You should aim for a COMPLETE understanding, not a superficial one.
 
  • #17
micromass said:
Before you start physics, I suggest you work on your math first. If you don't know math extremely well, then you shouldn't even think about starting in physics.

A book I always tend to recommend (because it is just THAT good) is "basic mathematics" by Serge Lang. It covers about everything you need to know about high school mathematics. Work that book until you understand everything and until you can work every exercise. Lang's book is not easy however, so you might want to complement it with other sources such as Khan academy.

After that, you can start with studying calculus. I like the book "practical analysis in one variable" by Estep. It contains a lot of information on calculus and it is suitable for a high-schooler. You might want to learn from a more rigorous book later (such as Spivak or Apostol), but they might be overkill for now.

After that, you're ready to start physics. The book by Halliday and Resnick is a good place to start (but only if you know calculus). You don't need to know calculus to start physics, you can also work with an algebra-based physics book, but I don't recommend this.

The books I recommend are books you should really WORK through. Just reading them and skimming theml a bit is not sufficient. You need to understand every sentence and every word, you need to work the exercises and you need to ask a lot of questions. You should aim for a COMPLETE understanding, not a superficial one.

I know you need to be good at Math, I am good from Algebra-Trigonometry...Trig. i could use more brushing up but thank you for all your help, ill be sure to look into those books
 
  • #18
Newtons2ndLaw said:
I know you need to be good at Math, I am good from Algebra-Trigonometry...Trig. i could use more brushing up but thank you for all your help, ill be sure to look into those books

You should be able to solve these questions very fast:

1) Factor x^3-x^2+2x-2.

2) Solve

\left\{\begin{array}{c} 2x+y=4\\ 6x-2y=3\end{array}\right.

3) Prove

(\cos(x)-\sin(x))^2=1-\sin(2x)

4) I'm looking at a tree from a distance. The visual angle between the bottom of the tree and the top of the tree is 10°. I step 2m forwards. The visual angle has now increased until 15°. How high is the tree?

Unless you can solve all these fairly fast, you need more practice.
 
Last edited:
  • #19
micromass said:
You should be able to solve these questions very fast:

1) Factor x^3-x^2+2x-2.

2) Solve

\left\{\begin{array}{c} 2x+y=4\\ 6x-2y=3\end{array}\right.

4) Prove

(\cos(x)-\sin(x))^2=1-\sin(2x)

5) I'm looking at a tree from a distance. The visual angle between the bottom of the tree and the top of the tree is 10°. I step 2m forwards. The visual angle has now increased until 15°. How high is the tree?

Unless you can solve all these fairly fast, you need more practice.

OhKay let me rephrase, i need a lot of brushing up
 
  • #20
you're on winter break right? perfect time to study :)
 
  • #21
Count me in the it's-never-too-late-but-you're-gonna-have-to-start-working-for-realz-now category.

I had the worst study habits in high school. I did practically no work at all. In fact, I missed 34 days of school my senior year of high school; I never went to school unless I had an exam or something. I was just about as lazy as you could be (though I still graduated valedictorian...go figure).

So I get to college, and I wasn't at all prepared for the amount of work that was expected of me. Suddenly, just being smart wasn't good enough. I had to actually study and WORK, something I had never done before. It was a very tough adjustment for me, almost traumatizing. I got far more B's (and even a C...whoops) those first few semesters than I care to admit.

By my junior year, I had finally developed good study and work habits; my grades improved as my study habits improved and I started getting A's. I ultimately graduated with a final GPA just over 3.5, which is relatively low for a prospective grad student.

I'm in a good physics graduate program now, but I got in by the skin of my teeth (I can only assume my LOR writers must have the literary skills of Hemingway or Joyce, 'cause my transcript wasn't stellar). I did very well this past semester (my first semester in grad school), even getting one of the very rare A's that was passed out in an especially difficult course (~30 students in the class and several B-minuses and C's were given...B-minus or below is "failure" by grad school standards). I don't let a day go by where I'm not doing some physics. Even during the current winter break, I'm working on E&M daily.

Best of luck to you.
 
  • #22
Woopy said:
you're on winter break right? perfect time to study :)

\like
 
  • #23
Basic math skills are more important - if you want to study physics at the university level, you'll eventually need to take SATs, and good scores on that can help out subtantially.
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 33 ·
2
Replies
33
Views
10K
  • · Replies 7 ·
Replies
7
Views
2K
  • · Replies 8 ·
Replies
8
Views
3K
  • · Replies 32 ·
2
Replies
32
Views
4K
  • · Replies 11 ·
Replies
11
Views
2K
  • · Replies 7 ·
Replies
7
Views
2K
  • · Replies 9 ·
Replies
9
Views
3K
  • · Replies 19 ·
Replies
19
Views
3K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
2K
  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
5K