How to measure which slit a photon went through

In summary, the conversation discusses the double slit experiment where individual photons are fired at a screen with two slits. An interference pattern appears, but when the slits are observed to determine which slit the photon went through, the interference pattern disappears. The conversation then explores different ways of "looking" at the photons without changing the experiment, using the Mach-Zehnder interferometer as an example. It is concluded that the "which way information" is enough to destroy interference and that this phenomenon is still a mystery when trying to explain it using the "particle" paradigm.
  • #1
michelcolman
176
2
The double slit experiment is often described like this:
(I'll describe the photon version, but of course the electron one is the same)

"We fire individual photons at a screen with two slits. An interference pattern appears. But when we try to look at the slits to figure out which slit the photon went through, the interference pattern disappears!"

But how do we 'look at' those slits? How do you figure out whether a photon (or electron) went throug a particular slit or not? You could let it interfere with an electron which absorbs the photon and emits a new one, generating some current while doing so. But it's rather obvious that this changes the whole experiment, there's really no mystery! Are there any other ways of 'looking' at those photons that don't completely obviously and unmysteriously change the whole setup?

Otherwise, it's a bit like saying "hey, this tennis ball gun is shooting all balls in the same direction, but when I just 'look at' the balls by hitting them with a tennis racket, they go all over the place!"

Is there something I'm missing? Or is that just all there is to it?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
There is no need of an interaction between light and something else: "which way information" is enough to destroy interference.
See "Mach-Zehnder interferometer":
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mach–Zehnder_interferometer

Referring to the first picture up right, without an obstacle in the position where is the "sample" there is interference and you will have 100% of the light in detector 1 and 0% in detector 2 (the first beam splitter, that is the one closer to the light source, is the analogous to the two slits).

With an obstacle (totally absorbing light) in the position of the "sample": detector 1 will fire 25% of the times, and so detector 2. Explaining this result with the "particle" paradigma is the "mistery": if the photon, after the first beam splitter, takes the route to the right, why should detector 2 fire at all?
 
Last edited:
  • #3
For an easy explanation see:

http://soi.blogspot.com/2011/02/two-slit-experiment.html
 

1. What is the basic principle behind measuring which slit a photon went through?

The basic principle behind measuring which slit a photon went through is known as the "double-slit experiment". This experiment involves sending a beam of photons towards two slits and observing the resulting pattern on a screen. The pattern changes depending on whether the photons are passing through one slit or both slits, allowing us to determine which slit the photon went through.

2. Can we measure which slit a photon went through without affecting its properties?

No, the act of measurement inevitably affects the properties of the photon. In order to determine which slit a photon went through, we must interact with the photon in some way, which alters its trajectory and potentially its energy level as well.

3. What are the different methods used to measure which slit a photon went through?

There are several methods used to measure which slit a photon went through, including the use of polarizers, detectors, and the quantum eraser experiment. Each method involves different techniques for interacting with the photon and gathering information about its path.

4. Can we measure which slit a photon went through in all situations?

No, there are certain factors that can affect our ability to measure which slit a photon went through. These include the speed and energy of the photon, as well as the materials and equipment used in the experiment. In some cases, the uncertainty principle may also prevent us from accurately determining the path of a photon.

5. How is the measurement of which slit a photon went through related to the concept of wave-particle duality?

The measurement of which slit a photon went through is closely related to the concept of wave-particle duality, which states that particles can exhibit both wave-like and particle-like behavior. In the case of measuring which slit a photon went through, the photon behaves like a particle when it interacts with the measuring apparatus, but its overall behavior can also be described by wave-like properties, such as interference patterns on the screen.

Similar threads

  • Quantum Physics
Replies
18
Views
1K
  • Quantum Physics
3
Replies
81
Views
4K
  • Quantum Physics
2
Replies
36
Views
1K
  • Quantum Physics
Replies
14
Views
1K
Replies
19
Views
946
Replies
32
Views
2K
Replies
18
Views
2K
Replies
5
Views
773
Replies
28
Views
536
  • Quantum Physics
Replies
17
Views
876
Back
Top