A How wise/unwise would it be to attempt to create a strangelet?

  • Thread starter greswd
  • Start date
650
14
Some hypothetical predictions of the strange matter hypothesis are that strangelets could possibly convert ordinary matter to strange matter in a critical reaction, "grey-goo"-like scenario.

Now, the odds of strangelets being created in particle accelerators are slim to none.

However, if we could create a device that would radically increase the odds, for the express purpose of creating strangelets, would it be unwise to do so, given the hypothesis of untold catastrophe?

Or should particle physicists strive to push the boundaries?
 

mathman

Science Advisor
7,614
369
The inference that strangelet production could lead to a catastrophe seems strange. Where did you get that idea?
 
32,586
8,465
There is no natural process that can produce them with any relevant frequency, if at all. If we have reason to expect that any future process might increase the odds over all natural processes we might want to do that on a trajectory that leaves the Solar System.
 
650
14
we might want to do that on a trajectory that leaves the Solar System.
so a precaution in case we could annihilate the earth?
 
32,586
8,465
By the time we might have the chance to create such a thing we'll probably understand its properties better.
 
74
29
It can't be too unwise, since physicists have been trying to do so for at least a half century in the form of searches for an H dibaryon resonance. Obviously, that has not created a catastrophe. If strange matter exists, it most likely would have to be bound by gravity in something like a strange star, which would not be very doable here on earth.
 
529
216
There is no natural process that can produce them with any relevant frequency, if at all. If we have reason to expect that any future process might increase the odds over all natural processes we might want to do that on a trajectory that leaves the Solar System.
The little green men out there might take a dim view of that.
 
32,586
8,465
Space is big. Something that leaves the solar system is not expected to hit anything in the next few billion years, and might never hit anything until the heat death of the universe.
 
529
216
Space is big. Something that leaves the solar system is not expected to hit anything in the next few billion years, and might never hit anything until the heat death of the universe.
Fair enough, but as far as I know, the LGM[1] would like us to keep our space pollution, especially any potentially hazardous anomaly, such as a strangelet, a micro black hole, or a magnetic monopole, as local as may be possible. :oldwink:

[1] LGM = Little Green Men
 

Want to reply to this thread?

"How wise/unwise would it be to attempt to create a strangelet?" You must log in or register to reply here.

Physics Forums Values

We Value Quality
• Topics based on mainstream science
• Proper English grammar and spelling
We Value Civility
• Positive and compassionate attitudes
• Patience while debating
We Value Productivity
• Disciplined to remain on-topic
• Recognition of own weaknesses
• Solo and co-op problem solving
Top