Did the Hunter's Moon Really Look Like a Second Sun in North America?

  • Context: High School 
  • Thread starter Thread starter cnh1995
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Canada Moon Usa
Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around the phenomenon reported in North America where the Hunter's Moon was said to appear as a second sun in the sky. Participants explore the validity of this claim, considering astronomical principles, potential photo manipulation, and the timing of moonrise and sunset.

Discussion Character

  • Debate/contested
  • Conceptual clarification

Main Points Raised

  • One participant mentions a news report claiming that the moon and sun appeared simultaneously, suggesting that the moon's brightness could make it look like a second sun due to its reflection of sunlight.
  • Another participant counters this by stating that the moon can only reflect sunlight when it is positioned opposite the sun in the sky, citing basic geometric principles.
  • Some participants express uncertainty about the authenticity of the images, questioning whether they could be photo hoaxes.
  • There are references to previous similar misleading images circulated on social media, indicating a pattern of such claims being debunked.
  • A participant reflects on their past misunderstanding of the situation, indicating a personal learning experience from the discussion.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants do not reach a consensus on the validity of the claim regarding the moon appearing as a second sun. There are competing views on whether the phenomenon is real or simply a result of photo manipulation.

Contextual Notes

Some participants express confusion about the timing of moonrise and sunset, and there are unresolved questions about the nature of the images shared in the initial claim.

cnh1995
Homework Helper
Gold Member
Messages
3,489
Reaction score
1,163
My facebook timeline was showing a news which said "North America and Canada witnessed two Suns in the sky". (I know fb is not a reliable source for such information).Because of the change in orbits, the moon rises and the Sun sets at the same time and the moon reflects the sunlight so bright that it appears as another Sun. I read in an article that the time between sunset and moonrise is shorter for Hunter's moon. But do they both appear at the same time like in these pictures?
images (3).jpg

Is this true? I have a limited knowledge of astronomy, so I don't understand this change of orbit thing. From what I read on the internet, some news reports say it's true while some say it's fake.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
cnh1995 said:
the moon rises and the Sun sets at the same time and the moon reflects the sunlight so bright that it appears as another Sun

No way. Moon can reflect the light from the Sun only when it is in the sky (as seen from the Earth) on the opposite side the Sun is. Very simple and basic geometry.

img039.png
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: russ_watters, davenn and cnh1995
Borek said:
Very simple and basic geometry.
That was very stupid of me!o0) Don't know why I couldn't see that...
Thanks!
 
cnh1995 said:
That was very stupid of me!

After all my yesterdays blunders (not necessarily related to PF) I am glad to hear others have weaker days too :wink:
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: cnh1995
So what could be the explanation then? Just a photo hoax?
 
Zylia said:
Just a photo hoax?
yup just more garbage, just like that other "photo" that was doing the rounds for several yrs on FB and other places of the Sun and the full moon between 2 palm trees, it, as the one above are impossibleDave
 
davenn said:
yup just more garbage, just like that other "photo" that was doing the rounds for several yrs on FB and other places of the Sun and the full moon between 2 palm trees, it, as the one above are impossibleDave
Thank you Davel!
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: davenn
Zylia said:
Thank you Davel!
Sorry Dave
 
Zylia said:
Sorry Dave

sorry for what ?
 
  • #10
davenn said:
sorry for what ?
I had your name wrong in the first reply
 
  • #11
Zylia said:
I had your name wrong in the first reply
ohhh I didn't even notice haha
nice to meet you, enjoy your time on PF :smile:Dave
 
  • #12
davenn said:
ohhh I didn't even notice haha
nice to meet you, enjoy your time on PF :smile:Dave
Nice to meet you too..and thanks again for the speedy reply. This settled an argument between me and my "know-it-all" husband, and I'm ashamed to say I lost..again. Next time, I'm coming to the forum before I reply to anything he says😬
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: davenn
  • #13
cnh1995 said:
My facebook timeline was showing a news which said "North America and Canada witnessed two Suns in the sky". (I know fb is not a reliable source for such information).Because of the change in orbits, the moon rises and the Sun sets at the same time and the moon reflects the sunlight so bright that it appears as another Sun. I read in an article that the time between sunset and moonrise is shorter for Hunter's moon. But do they both appear at the same time like in these pictures?
Can't believe I was that stupid two and a half years ago!o0)

(Mods, is there a way to close this thread so nobody brings it up again?)
 
  • #14
I am
Zylia said:
Sorry Dave
I am afraid I can't do that.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: BillTre, russ_watters and Bystander

Similar threads

Writing: Read Only What Does Great Lakes Earth Look Like from Space?
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
4K