The discussion revolves around the energy state transitions of a hydrogen atom, specifically focusing on the transition from the n=3 state to the ground state and the associated photon emission. Participants are examining the implications of energy calculations related to this transition.
The discussion is active, with participants questioning the validity of the formula used and the interpretation of the negative energy value. Some guidance has been offered regarding the correct formulation of energy levels, indicating a productive exploration of the topic.
There is mention of potential confusion regarding the derivation of energy levels and the assumptions about ionization energy, which may affect the understanding of the problem.
Dick said:Uh, how did you get a negative ground state energy using that formula?
hhhmortal said:Not too sure. I think that formula would just give you the energy of the level, but doesn't the electron in that level require that amount of energy to be ionised, hence the negative sign.
Dick said:You are right about that. And in fact, I think your answer is right. On the other hand the formula you gave for E is wrong. Why do you try and write down a clear derivation of your result?
hhhmortal said:I'm not too sure, I think I just used that equation then I canceled out certain terms and multiplied it by ћω. This is wrong, but I can't find the right way of doing it.