Suggestion Increase Attachment Size Limit

[PainterGuy]

Hi,

I think it would be a good idea if the size limit for image attachments could be increased. Most of the images I try to use on this forums get blurry because the size limit is quite small. Thank you!

 

[Borek]

Are you sure it is not the thumbnail preview that is blurry?

(random image from my disk, 1280*853, 877kB)

 

[pbuk]

That image has been resized to a width of 800px.

 

[PainterGuy]

For example, check the images in the following post. Each image was almost 200 KB but still they got blurred.

https://www.physicsforums.com/threads/the-pressure-exerted-by-radiation.1005913/post-6534988

 

[DaveE]

That image has been resized to a width of 800px.

But it's not blurry.

Resolution tends to be more of an issue for me with things like graphs and drawings where the aliasing shows up more or the text fonts are too small. But, I don't think it's too limited for my stuff. My issue is that I have to edit the images down in size with a bit of trial and error, since I'm too lazy to find the size limits in advance.

So, what are the size limits?

 

[pbuk]

For example, check the images in the following post. Each image was almost 200 KB but still they got blurred.

https://www.physicsforums.com/threads/the-pressure-exerted-by-radiation.1005913/post-6534988

The images have been resized to a height of 620px; this is too small for the text to be properly legible.

But it's not blurry.

It doesn't contain much fine detail so you don't notice the pixellation.

So, what are the size limits?

From the above two examples the maximum appears to be 800px wide by 620px high.

 

[phinds]

Here's a pic that is 4000 x 3000 on my computer

Yep, it gets resized to 800 x 600

 

[phinds]

For example, check the images in the following post. Each image was almost 200 KB but still they got blurred.

https://www.physicsforums.com/threads/the-pressure-exerted-by-radiation.1005913/post-6534988

I don't think there's any way that's the fault of the forum. I believe I can post a pic with similar sized font and it will not be so blurry. Let's try:

That looks a bit more blurred than I expected but nothing like what you are experiencing.

Did you up-size your image before uploading it?

Here's a comparison of the two:

See ... there's nothing wrong with the forum but there IS something wrong with your image. I think you are confusing file size with resolution. Your image HAS to be low resolution (which has nothing to do really, with file size) before you uploaded it since, as you can clearly see, the forum does NOT make an image fuzzy/blurry the way yours is.

 

[DaveE]

Here's a pic that is 4000 x 3000 on my computer
View attachment 288412

Yep, it gets resized to 800 x 600

Thanks! Good to know. I mostly recall my images getting rejected, not resized.

 

[PainterGuy]

In the posting, https://www.physicsforums.com/threads/the-pressure-exerted-by-radiation.1005913/post-6534988, which I linked in post #4 above, the image with:

light brownish background is 32.09 KB and resolution is 596x1027
white background is 269.68 KB and resolution is 834x1274

 

[phinds]

In the posting, https://www.physicsforums.com/threads/the-pressure-exerted-by-radiation.1005913/post-6534988, which I linked in post #4 above, the image with:

light brownish background is 32.09 KB and resolution is 596x1027
white background is 269.68 KB and resolution is 834x1274

That's not the resolution, it's the SIZE. At that size, the resolution could be 200 DPI or it could be 24 DPI. THAT would be the resolution.

I suspect that PF has a standard resolution but that's irrelevant. What is relevant is the resolution of the image you upload. If you upload an image w/ 24DPI resolution and PF shows it at 72 DPI it's still going to look like crap.

For example, here are stats showing the size of an image (which you called the resolution, which it is not) and the actual resolution

EDIT: and one more thing: if you take a hi resolution image of a blurred pic, it will stay blurred.

 

[phinds]

My issue is that I have to edit the images down in size with a bit of trial and error ...

OOPS ... this post was based on my mistaken assumption that I was addressing the OP. Sorry.

And when you do that you are probably reducing the resolution (which, as I have already pointed out is not tied directly to size **). What tool are you using to reduce the image size.

** just for clarity, the FILE size is tied to the resolution. If you keep the dimension the same but reduce the resolution, the file size goes down.

 

[phinds]

Thanks! Good to know. I mostly recall my images getting rejected, not resized.

There's probably a file size limit as well as an image size limit.