Inner Product vs. Dot Product Confusion in Quantum Physics?

4 replies · 3K views · last reply
lawlieto
Messages
15
Reaction score
2
I started learning quantum, and I got a bit confused about inner and dot products.
I've attached 2 screenshots; 1 from Wikipedia and 1 from an MIT pdf I found online.

Wikipedia says that a.Dot(b) when they're complex would be the sum of aibi where b is the complex conjugate.

The PDF from MIT (https://ocw.mit.edu/courses/physics...all-2013/lecture-notes/MIT8_05F13_Chap_04.pdf) page 2 says that the inner product is taken <a|b>, then when doing a1b1+a2b3+... the complex conjugate of a is taken. I thought this would be the same thing as taking the dot product with complex numbers (like what I mentioned above in the 2nd paragraph). But in the dot product, the complex conjugate of b is taken, whereas here the complex conjugate of a is taken.

Could someone demystify this for me please?

Thanks
 
Attachments
  • Formula for the complex dot product: a dot b equals the sum over i of a_i times the complex conjugate of b_i, with the conjugate bar over b_i. Below, text reads where the bar b_i is the complex conjugate of b_i, with complex conjugate linked.
    wikipedia.png
    4.4 KB · Views: 546
  • Equation (1.4) defining an inner product for two-component complex vectors a and b, written as <a|b> = a1*b1 + a2*b2, with a1* and a2* the complex conjugates of a1 and a2.
    MIT screenshot.png
    7.2 KB · Views: 586
lawlieto said:
I started learning quantum, and I got a bit confused about inner and dot products.
I've attached 2 screenshots; 1 from Wikipedia and 1 from an MIT pdf I found online.

Wikipedia says that a.Dot(b) when they're complex would be the sum of aibi where b is the complex conjugate.

The PDF from MIT (https://ocw.mit.edu/courses/physics...all-2013/lecture-notes/MIT8_05F13_Chap_04.pdf) page 2 says that the inner product is taken <a|b>, then when doing a1b1+a2b3+... the complex conjugate of a is taken. I thought this would be the same thing as taking the dot product with complex numbers (like what I mentioned above in the 2nd paragraph). But in the dot product, the complex conjugate of b is taken, whereas here the complex conjugate of a is taken.

Could someone demystify this for me please?
In the MIT materials they are defining an inner product as they show in equation 1.4. There are many ways that an inner product can be defined, including the one you show from the Wikipedia article.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: lawlieto
Mark44 said:
In the MIT materials they are defining an inner product as they show in equation 1.4. There are many ways that an inner product can be defined, including the one you show from the Wikipedia article.

Thanks for your reply, so it's just a matter of how you define it? But then you could define anything to be anything?
 
lawlieto said:
Thanks for your reply, so it's just a matter of how you define it? But then you could define anything to be anything?
No, it has to satisfy some properties like linearity in its arguments. Another requirement is usually, that ##\langle a,a \rangle \geq 0##. In the case of complex components, this is the reason for the conjugate in either of the arguments. Whether you choose the first or second doesn't matter, just don't confuse them.
 
Although not required, it is customary to take the complex conjugate of the right hand term.