Interactive Minkowski diagrams tool

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around an interactive tool for creating Minkowski diagrams, which allows users to visualize events and their transformations under Lorentz boosts. Participants explore the functionality of the tool, report on technical issues, and suggest enhancements related to the representation of hyperbolae and grid lines in the context of special relativity.

Discussion Character

  • Technical explanation
  • Debate/contested
  • Exploratory

Main Points Raised

  • One participant shares a link to an interactive Minkowski diagram tool and invites feedback on its functionality.
  • Several participants report issues with the tool, particularly regarding event handling in different web browsers.
  • Suggestions are made for additional features, such as an auto button for creating a space-time grid and the ability to draw hyperbolae that remain invariant under boosts.
  • One participant describes a conceptual scenario involving a hyperbola and a straight line, questioning how boosts affect their relationship.
  • Another participant mentions the clustering of events along hyperbolae and proposes adjustments to improve their distribution.
  • There is discussion about the mathematical representation of hyperbolic distances and how they relate to the events generated in the tool.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants express a mix of agreement and differing views on the functionality and potential improvements of the tool. While some technical issues are acknowledged, there is no consensus on the best approach to implement suggested features or the implications of hyperbolic transformations.

Contextual Notes

Participants note limitations related to browser compatibility and the handling of JavaScript events, as well as the mathematical complexity involved in accurately representing hyperbolae and their transformations.

  • #31
dipole said:
Selecting a scenario doesn't choose a velocity to boost, at least for me.
I didn't expect it to. You should, however, be able to click on a time-like line (one steeper than 45 degrees) and then click on the "Boost to selected line rest frame" button to boost to the frame where that line is vertical. If not, let me know.

dipole said:
I think you should include an example of how to read the diagrams for some of the secarios, and how the diagram explains or not the paradox.
It did occur to me - maybe next week. The short version is that you are looking at a displacement-time graph, with time vertical and displacement horizontal. Something stationary gives a vertical line; something traveling at c gives a 45 degree sloped line. In Newtonian physics, you could transform into the rest frame of a moving object by shearing the graph until the line of interest was vertical. In Einsteinian physics, the transform is a little more complex - and these diagrams are a great way to start building up intuition for what the Lorentz transforms are doing.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: nnunn
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #32
DrGreg said:
At the rist of complicating the diagram too much, you might also like to consider drawing lines from the events through the origin -- the events along different curves are already lined up for this. For the green area, this would then be a grid for Rindler coordinates -- see the first diagram in the Wikipedia Rindler coordinates article.

The whole diagram would then be the Minkowski geometry equivalent of a rotating wheel with spokes in Euclidean geometry.
No time right now (could do with time-dilating my office), but I think it's worth a look. I think I might do that as another button, since it might get a bit busy, as you say.
 
  • #33
I actually worked on a relativity simulator like this a couple years ago: http://www.refsmmat.com/jsphys/relativity/relativity.html

Different idea, though. Instead of letting the user construct a Minkowski diagram, it has a set of built-in scenarios (common teaching examples). It can display the Minkowski diagram or a 2D view of the scene. We also added in Doppler shifting for fun -- if you switch on "Apparent positions" in the Settings menu, you'll see the locations of objects as they would be seen from the cross mark at the center of the screen.

I used it a couple of times in a modern physics course to show examples, but now I've moved out of physics and don't have a good use for it. It's open source, so feel free to play with it.
 
  • #34
DrGreg said:
At the rist of complicating the diagram too much, you might also like to consider drawing lines from the events through the origin -- the events along different curves are already lined up for this. For the green area, this would then be a grid for Rindler coordinates -- see the first diagram in the Wikipedia Rindler coordinates article.

The whole diagram would then be the Minkowski geometry equivalent of a rotating wheel with spokes in Euclidean geometry.
Done! There are two buttons, one for hyperbolae only and one for hyperbolae with spokes. It's quite hypnotic to watch them boosting.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: DrGreg
  • #35
Very nice, I have put it in my bookmarks. Thanks for posting.
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
3K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
2K
Replies
24
Views
8K