Is Everyday Technology Killing Us?

  • Context: Medical 
  • Thread starter Thread starter stpmic
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Technology
Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion centers around concerns regarding the potential harmful effects of everyday technology, particularly electromagnetic radiation emitted by devices, as raised by a video presented by David Wolfe. Participants explore the implications of this technology on human health, including specific populations that may be more vulnerable.

Discussion Character

  • Debate/contested
  • Technical explanation
  • Exploratory

Main Points Raised

  • One participant expresses concern about the technology emitting 20-1000 MHz of electricity, suggesting it could cause seizures and other negative health effects.
  • Another participant argues that the energy in this frequency band is low and that the wavelengths are too large to interact significantly with human cells, stating that the most likely effect is heat energy transfer, which is not harmful in normal conditions.
  • Some participants challenge the credibility of the video and its presenter, labeling him as a "crackpot" and questioning the validity of his claims about grounding and radiation exposure.
  • Questions are raised about the potential differential effects of electromagnetic radiation on specific populations, such as individuals with pacemakers or epilepsy, and whether children might be more affected than adults.
  • A participant notes that while some frequencies of light can induce seizures in susceptible individuals, they are unsure about the effects of other forms of energy waves.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants generally agree that the video in question lacks credibility and is likely a sales pitch. However, there remains disagreement regarding the potential health effects of electromagnetic radiation, particularly for vulnerable populations, and the discussion does not reach a consensus on these points.

Contextual Notes

Participants acknowledge the need for more research on the effects of electromagnetic radiation on specific groups, highlighting that earlier concerns about pacemaker interference with microwaves may no longer be relevant due to advancements in technology.

stpmic
Messages
2
Reaction score
0
Mod note: link removed[/color]

I work in a school district as the Director of Instruction. A parent came to me with a concern based on the video link above. The main point David Wolfe is trying to make is that the technolgoy we are using is harmful to our bodies becasue it is emiting 20-1000 mhz of electricty that has been known to casue seaizures and other negative side effects to humans.

What is the truth?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Biology news on Phys.org
stpmic said:
Mod note: link removed[/color]

I work in a school district as the Director of Instruction. A parent came to me with a concern based on the video link above. The main point David Wolfe is trying to make is that the technolgoy we are using is harmful to our bodies becasue it is emiting 20-1000 mhz of electricty that has been known to casue seaizures and other negative side effects to humans.

What is the truth?

The energy in this frequency band is low and the wavelengths associated are so large that they do not interact with us much on an atomic level. At 1000 MHz, the wavelength is about 1/3 of a meter or about 1 foot. Not much energy will be transferred to our cells to cause damage to them since they're physically so much smaller than that wavelength. The most likely kind of energy transferred to them would be heat energy, but your cells receive heat energy all the time even in the absense of electromagnetic radiation. The wavelengths are too large and so low energy that they cannot ionize the atoms in our cells, which is usually the type or radiation we link to cancer and other harmful effects.

There are cases that electromagnetic radiation can cause harm, but this is at very high intensity and we don't even come close to this with cell phones and electronics devices.

As to that video, the guy is a crackpot and I don't even want to start going on how wrong he is and the assumptions he is making. Also notice all the "health" products he's trying to sell in his living room.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
DragonPetter said:
As to that video, the guy is a crackpot and I don't even want to start going on how wrong he is and the assumptions he is making.

:bugeye: How does he figure that grounding himself means he's no longer being bombarded by the radiation?
 
Are their studies or the effects pertaining to certainin populations (reference groups) of people... for example would the effect be different for someone with a pacemaker, or epilepsy, small children vs adults?

Side Note: The sales pitch was a dead give away for me, however I needed to ask the question. I often think about the harmful effects of our daily intentional actions like loud music, inattentive driving, dkrinking, smoking, etc...this seemed way low on my radar as a harmful effect. Thanks for the fast reply!
 
stpmic said:
Are their studies or the effects pertaining to certainin populations (reference groups) of people... for example would the effect be different for someone with a pacemaker, or epilepsy, small children vs adults?

Side Note: The sales pitch was a dead give away for me, however I needed to ask the question. I often think about the harmful effects of our daily intentional actions like loud music, inattentive driving, dkrinking, smoking, etc...this seemed way low on my radar as a harmful effect. Thanks for the fast reply!

Given the general agreement that the site in question is just a scammy sales pitch, I'll avoid discussing it directly.

I'll just address the one most common misconception...that microwaves interfere with pacemakers. Back in the early days of pacemakers and the early days of microwave ovens with poor shielding or inadequate safety mechanisms, it was possible to have interference (albeit much lower risk than warning signs might have suggested). Today, however, pacemakers are designed not to have problems with interference from these common household appliances, and microwave ovens are well-shielded too.

Some frequencies of light patterns can induce a seizure in those prone to seizures, but I don't know anything about other forms of energy waves being an issue.
 
DaveC426913 said:
:bugeye: How does he figure that grounding himself means he's no longer being bombarded by the radiation?

Err... Some kind of Faraday cage bs argument?