Is gravity more fundamental than EM?

In summary, the reason why gravity is not considered a more fundamental force, despite photons emitting virtual gravitons while gravitons don't emit virtual photons, is because the existence of a coupling between the particles in question is determined by their representation in terms of the symmetry groups of the theory. This has no bearing on the relative fundamentality of the particles.
  • #1
Pjpic
235
1
If photons emit virtual gravitons (but gravitons don't emit virtual photons) why isn't gravity considered to be a more fundamental force?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
Suppose a particle A 'emits' some other particle B (real or virtual). This is NOT to say that A is composed of or can be represented by B in any sense. Rather it means that there exists a coupling AAB (incoming A, outgoing A, outgoing B) in your theory. Say A is the photon and B is the graviton. AAB is an allowed coupling in your theory because it does not violate any of the symmetries that you might want. On the other hand, the coupling BBA is not allowed because B, the graviton, is a singlet under U(1)EM (i.e. it has no electric charge), so such a coupling would break U(1)EM gauge invariance, a symmetry of the theory related to charge conservation. In short, whether some A can emit some B depends on the representation of that particle in terms of the symmetry groups of the theory, and this has nothing to do with whether one is more 'fundamental' than the other.
 

1. What is the difference between gravity and electromagnetism?

Gravity is a fundamental force that acts between objects with mass, causing them to be attracted to each other. Electromagnetism is a force that acts between electrically charged particles, causing them to be either attracted or repelled from each other. While gravity affects objects with mass, electromagnetism affects particles with electric charge.

2. Is gravity more fundamental than electromagnetism?

This is a debated topic in the scientific community. Some argue that gravity is more fundamental because it affects all objects with mass, while electromagnetism only affects particles with electric charge. Others argue that electromagnetism is more fundamental because it can be described by a unified theory (electroweak theory) while gravity cannot be fully explained by current theories.

3. Can gravity and electromagnetism be unified into one theory?

Scientists have been working on a unified theory that would combine gravity and electromagnetism, known as the theory of everything. While there have been attempts to unify the two forces, a complete and widely accepted theory has not yet been achieved.

4. Which force is stronger, gravity or electromagnetism?

Electromagnetism is significantly stronger than gravity. For example, the electromagnetic force between two electrons is about 10^42 times stronger than the gravitational force between them. However, since gravity acts on larger scales (such as between planets and stars), it can have a more noticeable effect.

5. How does the concept of spacetime relate to the differences between gravity and electromagnetism?

Einstein's theory of general relativity explains gravity as the curvature of spacetime caused by the presence of mass. In contrast, electromagnetism is described by quantum field theory, which does not involve the concept of spacetime. This difference in how the two forces are described is one reason why they have not yet been successfully unified into one theory.

Similar threads

  • Quantum Physics
Replies
3
Views
771
  • Quantum Physics
Replies
29
Views
2K
Replies
19
Views
1K
  • Quantum Physics
Replies
14
Views
1K
Replies
8
Views
1K
  • Quantum Physics
Replies
1
Views
932
Replies
5
Views
644
Replies
6
Views
755
Replies
4
Views
651
Replies
40
Views
4K
Back
Top