Is Intelligent Design About the Hierarchy of Information in the Universe?

In summary, George Gilder, a member of the Intelligent Design Discovery Institute, argues that intelligent design is not about introducing supernatural ideas, but rather asserts that the universe operates in a hierarchical manner, where information comes from the top down, not the bottom up. He also points out that current scientific explanations for phenomena like human consciousness are unsatisfactory and that the Darwinian theory hinders scientific progress. Gilder concludes that information, not matter, is the primary fact of nature and that the mind and meaning are superior to it. However, many view his beliefs as quackery and driven by his agenda to promote intelligent design.
  • #1
SF
I'm quoting from here: http://www.arn.org/blogs/index.php/2/2006/07/16/lstrongglemgwhy_is_tech_guru_george_gild_1

Gilder makes the key point that intelligent design is not about introducing ideas about the supernatural. It simply insists that the cosmos is hierarchical. That is, information comes from the top down, not the bottom up.
In itself, intelligent design - while anti-materialist, of course - does not require assumptions about the supernatural. It is a statement about how the universe actually works, what it actually is in itself. That is, the universe is top down, not bottom up. Ideas come first and are not generated by matter. Rather ideas either generate or govern matter.

Then, here:
http://www.arn.org/blogs/index.php/2/2006/07/16/lstrongglemgwhy_is_tech_guru_george_gild
Gilder ends by pointing out that we do not currently have satisfactory explanations for key phenomena like human consciousness, and Darwinism is not on the road to offering any. He quotes Nobel-laureate physicist Robert Laughlin of Stanford: "The Darwinian theory has become an all-purpose obstacle to thought rather than an enabler of scientific advance."

He closes with the reflection that the word, information, is the primary fact of nature, not matter, adding, "Superior even to the word are the mind and the meaning, the will and the way. Intelligent people bow their heads before this higher power, which still remains inexorably beyond the reach of science."


what is this? science? quackery?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Biology news on Phys.org
  • #3


The content being quoted here is discussing the concept of intelligent design and its relationship to the hierarchy of information in the universe. The author, George Gilder, argues that intelligent design is not about introducing ideas about the supernatural, but rather about understanding the hierarchical nature of information in the universe. This means that ideas come from the top down, rather than being generated by matter. Gilder also points out that Darwinism, as a theory, does not offer satisfactory explanations for certain phenomena such as human consciousness. He quotes a Nobel-laureate physicist who states that Darwinism has become an obstacle to scientific thought. Gilder concludes by stating that the word "information" is the primary fact of nature, and that the mind and meaning are superior to this concept. This quote raises questions about the validity of intelligent design and its place in the scientific community. Some may view it as quackery, while others may see it as a valid perspective on the nature of the universe. Ultimately, the interpretation of this content is up to the individual reader and their beliefs and understanding of science.
 

Related to Is Intelligent Design About the Hierarchy of Information in the Universe?

What is the hierarchy of information?

The hierarchy of information is a way of organizing and ranking information based on its importance and relevance. It is a useful tool for understanding the relationships between different pieces of information and determining which ones are most critical.

What are the levels of the hierarchy of information?

The hierarchy of information typically consists of three levels: primary, secondary, and tertiary. Primary information is the most important and directly relevant, while secondary information provides additional context and support for the primary information. Tertiary information is the least important and often provides background or general knowledge about a topic.

How is the hierarchy of information useful?

The hierarchy of information is useful because it helps us prioritize and organize the vast amount of information available to us. By understanding the relative importance of different pieces of information, we can make better decisions about which sources to trust and which to prioritize.

How does the hierarchy of information relate to critical thinking?

The hierarchy of information is closely tied to critical thinking because it encourages us to consider the source, relevance, and reliability of information before accepting it as true. By understanding the hierarchy, we can evaluate information more critically and make informed decisions.

What are some examples of the hierarchy of information in practice?

The hierarchy of information can be observed in many different contexts, such as in academic research, news reporting, and decision-making processes. For example, a news article may include primary information from a direct source, secondary information from experts or witnesses, and tertiary information from background research or historical context.

Similar threads

Replies
1
Views
887
  • General Discussion
Replies
4
Views
727
Replies
3
Views
556
  • Art, Music, History, and Linguistics
Replies
1
Views
1K
  • Biology and Medical
Replies
10
Views
4K
Replies
40
Views
9K
  • Sci-Fi Writing and World Building
Replies
15
Views
3K
  • High Energy, Nuclear, Particle Physics
Replies
2
Views
3K
Back
Top