Is Linear Momentum Conserved in This Case? (sliding box hits a floor tile)

AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on whether linear momentum is conserved when a sliding block hits a tile. It is concluded that linear momentum is not conserved for the block-tile system due to external forces from the floor. However, when considering the block, tile, floor, and Earth as an isolated system, linear momentum is conserved. The conversation also explores the effects of friction, noting that the coefficient of friction between the block and tile plays a crucial role in the dynamics of the collision. Ultimately, the analysis reveals how the block's center of mass moves post-collision, influenced by both horizontal and vertical impulses.
Heisenberg7
Messages
101
Reaction score
18
Homework Statement
A box with edge 1.5 m is sliding across a floor with speed of 4 m/s. The leading lower edge of the box strikes an upraised floor tile with a completely inelastic impact. What is the angular velocity of the box immediately after the box hits the tile? The mass of the box is 9 kg.
Relevant Equations
##\vec{P} = const##
Hello,

I actually solved this problem using conservation of angular momentum, but I was wondering if linear momentum is conserved. Here's my thought process:
(block + tile system) The block is going to hit the tile with some force ##\vec{F}##. Due to the Newton's third law, that force is also going to act on the block itself. These are internal forces, so they play no role in our investigation. Now, here comes the problem. When the block hits the tile, the tile has to move slightly which could possibly cause an external force due to the floor. This implies that linear momentum of our block + tile system is not conserved.

There is another problem though. The tile itself is a part of the floor. So, if we were to consider the block + floor system, the linear momentum would be conserved, wouldn't it?
1722112124478.png
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Yes, the linear momentum of the block and the tile and the house to which the tile is attached and the Earth to which the house is attached is conserved. You have to have an isolated system, i.e. no external forces.
 
  • Like
Likes Heisenberg7 and Lnewqban
Heisenberg7 said:
When the block hits the tile, the tile has to move slightly which could possibly cause an external force due to the floor. This implies that linear momentum of our block + tile system is not conserved.
It depends on the coefficient of friction between block and tile.

Let us assume for the moment an ideal case with a frictionless tile and a frictionless floor. So 100% of the horizontal force on the block comes from the tile and 100% of the vertical force on the block comes from the floor.

If the horizontal force from tile on block were the only force present during the collision then the result would be a block rotating about its center of mass in such a way that its lower right corner is horizontally motionless. The center of mass would continue horizontally at a reduced speed while the lower right corner rotated down and back beneath it.

But that is not what happens. The floor gets in the way of that rotation.

The vertical force of floor on block will be exactly sufficient to prevent any vertical motion of the lower right corner of the block.

The combined effect of the two forces is that the lower right corner of the block becomes motionless.

Since neither the impulsive horizontal force from the tile nor the impulsive vertical force from the floor have any moment arm about the lower right corner of the block, it is convenient to adopt an axis of rotation at that point. Angular momentum about that axis is conserved across the collision.

We can do a conservation of momentum argument (as you have already done) and solve for the resulting rotation rate about the lower right corner.

But let us return to my original assertion about a coefficent of friction.

With the results of our computation in hand, we know how the block should be moving in the wake of the collision. It is a rotation about a fixed point at the lower right corner. We know the rotation rate.

So we are in a position to calculate the instantaneous velocity of the block's center of mass.

It will have non-zero horizontal velocity. It will have non-zero vertical velocity. Because the center of mass is rotating about the fixed point at the lower right corner.

Since we know horizontal momentum before and after, we know how much horizontal impulse has been applied.

Since we know vertical momentum before and after, we know how much vertical impulse has been applied.

The ratio, vertical:horizontal gives the required coefficient of friction to avoid slipping against the tile and thereby not needing the floor to act as a back stop.
 
Last edited:
Thread 'Minimum mass of a block'
Here we know that if block B is going to move up or just be at the verge of moving up ##Mg \sin \theta ## will act downwards and maximum static friction will act downwards ## \mu Mg \cos \theta ## Now what im confused by is how will we know " how quickly" block B reaches its maximum static friction value without any numbers, the suggested solution says that when block A is at its maximum extension, then block B will start to move up but with a certain set of values couldn't block A reach...
TL;DR Summary: Find Electric field due to charges between 2 parallel infinite planes using Gauss law at any point Here's the diagram. We have a uniform p (rho) density of charges between 2 infinite planes in the cartesian coordinates system. I used a cube of thickness a that spans from z=-a/2 to z=a/2 as a Gaussian surface, each side of the cube has area A. I know that the field depends only on z since there is translational invariance in x and y directions because the planes are...
Thread 'Calculation of Tensile Forces in Piston-Type Water-Lifting Devices at Elevated Locations'
Figure 1 Overall Structure Diagram Figure 2: Top view of the piston when it is cylindrical A circular opening is created at a height of 5 meters above the water surface. Inside this opening is a sleeve-type piston with a cross-sectional area of 1 square meter. The piston is pulled to the right at a constant speed. The pulling force is(Figure 2): F = ρshg = 1000 × 1 × 5 × 10 = 50,000 N. Figure 3: Modifying the structure to incorporate a fixed internal piston When I modify the piston...
Back
Top