Is My Assumption About Rope Tension Correct?

32 replies · 14K views · last reply
stuc
Messages
20
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement


Diagram of a box hanging from a ceiling by two ropes meeting at a point above it, each rope making a 60 degree angle with the ceiling, each labelled 5N.


Homework Equations


My assumption:-
if one of the ropes have been cut, it mean the object just hang VERTICALLY with one rope with 5N load on it.Is it my assumption is correct?

The Attempt at a Solution


Tension of the other rope = 5N (is it correct)?? base on my assumption [/B]
 
stuc said:
My assumption:-
if one of the ropes have been cut, it mean the object just hang VERTICALLY with one rope with 5N load on it.Is it my assumption is correct?
I would assume they mean the tension at the instant after cutting the other string.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: stuc
Have you studied force vectors? I think your assumption is half correct and your conclusion is wrong. What you are right about is the hanging vertically. All of your statements about force are wrong.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: stuc
haruspex said:
I would assume they mean the tension at the instant after cutting the other string.
Hm ... could be. I didn't interpret it that way but I guess that could be right. stuc, my comments are not based on that assumption.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: stuc
haruspex said:
I would assume they mean the tension at the instant after cutting the other string.
...the tension at the instant after cutting the other string

how to calculate it? it mean my assumption is wrong

i just check an answer..the answer is 5N...but how to get it
 
stuc said:
.the answer is 5N.
Hmm.. that does not fit with either interpretation. But I remain of the view that it's the instantaneous value they're after.
First, can you figure out the weight of the mass?
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: stuc
You have not answered my question about whether or not you have studied force vectors.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: stuc
haruspex said:
Hmm.. that does not fit with either interpretation. But I remain of the view that it's the instantaneous value they're after.
First, can you figure out the weight of the mass?
there is no weight given.:H
 
phinds said:
You have not answered my question about whether or not you have studied force vectors.
learn but always confuse when try to solve it
 
phinds said:
What is the definition of a Newton?
1N = the force needed to accelerate 1kg of mass
 
Hand-drawn free-body diagram of a box hanging from two ropes at 60 degrees to a ceiling, each with 5N tension, with steps 1 to 4 annotated; a handwritten calculation reads Fy = 5N x sin 60 degrees = 4.33N.


Attached is the calculation..any one can verify my ans (4.33N) because the given ans in 5N.

Update:Wrong Arrow for Fy
 
Last edited:
As I posted, the first step is to determine the weight of the mass. No, it's not given, but there is enough information to find it. To do this, just consider the initial set up with two ropes. Write the equation for balance of forces in the vertical direction.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: stuc
stuc said:
Attached is the calculation..any one can verify my ans (4.33N) because the given ans in 5N.

Update:Wrong Arrow for Fy
You got 4.33 N for the upward component of force contributed by each wire. But there are two wires. So what is the weight of the object? If this weight has to be supported by only one wire, what would the tension in that wire have to be?

Chet
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: stuc
haruspex said:
As I posted, the first step is to determine the weight of the mass. No, it's not given, but there is enough information to find it. To do this, just consider the initial set up with two ropes. Write the equation for balance of forces in the vertical direction.

My step to determine the weight of the mass..is it ok? (weight of the mass = 7.071N)
Hand-drawn force diagram of a box hanging from two ropes at 60 degrees to the ceiling, each rope labelled 5N, with a vector triangle showing weight W, tension 5N and a 5N component, and the calculation W = sqrt(5^2 + 5^2) = sqrt(50) = 7.071N.
 
Chestermiller said:
You got 4.33 N for the upward component of force contributed by each wire. But there are two wires. So what is the weight of the object? If this weight has to be supported by only one wire, what would the tension in that wire have to be?

Chet
weight of the mass = 7.071N
Handwritten force diagram of a box hanging from two ropes at 60 degrees to the ceiling, each with tension 5N, with a force triangle for equilibrium showing W and 5N vectors, and the calculation W = sqrt(5^2 + 5^2) = sqrt(50) = 7.071N.
 
stuc said:
My step to determine the weight of the mass..is it ok?
View attachment 91455
No, that doesn't work. Pythagoras applies when two vectors at right angles are to be added.
What is the component of each tension in the vertical direction?
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: stuc
haruspex said:
No, that doesn't work. Pythagoras applies when two vectors at right angles are to be added.
What is the component of each tension in the vertical direction?
:nb)..tq for the info..will be calculate
 
stuc said:
My step to determine the weight of the mass..is it ok? (weight of the mass = 7.071N)
View attachment 91455
In this figure, the 5 N should be the hypotenuse, not one of the other sides. You're using the wrong triangle.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: stuc
haruspex said:
Hint: you already calculated it in post #12.
Hand-annotated diagram of a box hanging from two ropes at 60 degrees to the ceiling, each with 5N tension, with a green dashed cut line and a second sketch of the box's free-body diagram showing Fy = 5N x sin 60 = 4.33N.


Base on the above diagram (arrow edited),

5N x sin 60 + 5N x sin 60 - W = 0
therefore W= 2(5N x sin 60)
= 8.66 N
 
Chestermiller said:
You got 4.33 N for the upward component of force contributed by each wire. But there are two wires. So what is the weight of the object? If this weight has to be supported by only one wire, what would the tension in that wire have to be?

Chet
i get W=8.66N ..but how the answer is 5N:cry:
 
stuc said:
i get W=8.66N ..but how the answer is 5N:cry:
Steady on, so far all we have found is the hanging weight. The tension in one string immediately after the other is cut might be different. So leave the weight in the form ##10\sin(60)N## for now.
Now draw a free body diagram for the weight just after one string is cut. What equation can you obtain for the tension in the remaining string.
 
haruspex said:
Steady on, so far all we have found is the hanging weight. The tension in one string immediately after the other is cut might be different. So leave the weight in the form ##10\sin(60)N## for now.
Now draw a free body diagram for the weight just after one string is cut. What equation can you obtain for the tension in the remaining string.
Handwritten solution: object hanging from ceiling by two ropes at 60 degrees, each tension 5N, with weight W = mg = 10sin 60 N; second diagram after cutting one rope shows triangle with T and 10sin 60 arrow, sin 60 = 10sin 60 / T, T = 10 N.


the ans is 10N after cut the 5N right rope...huhu near but still cannot get the ans
 
stuc said:
View attachment 91592

the ans is 10N after cut the 5N right rope...huhu near but still cannot get the ans
After a rope is cut, the system is no longer stable. There will be an acceleration. The forces in the vertical direction will no longer balance.
You need to consider which way that acceleration will be and apply ##\Sigma F=0## at right angles to it.
 
haruspex said:
After a rope is cut, the system is no longer stable. There will be an acceleration. The forces in the vertical direction will no longer balance.
You need to consider which way that acceleration will be and apply ##\Sigma F=0## at right angles to it.
if one of the ropes have been cut, it mean the object just hang VERTICALLY with one rope with 10sin(60)N load on it.Is it my assumption is correct?

it mean all the calculation in step 25 not require especially step 2 &3 ?
 
stuc said:
if one of the ropes have been cut, it mean the object just hang VERTICALLY with one rope with 10sin(60)N load on it.Is it my assumption is correct?
Not immediately. Although the question does not make it completely clear, I am very confident that you are supposed to find the tension in the remaining rope the instant after one rope is cut. You can take the remaining rope and the mass as being in exactly the same positions as before, and, for the instant, stationary. But now there is a nonzero acceleration.
Which way will the mass accelerate?
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: stuc
haruspex said:
Not immediately. Although the question does not make it completely clear, I am very confident that you are supposed to find the tension in the remaining rope the instant after one rope is cut. You can take the remaining rope and the mass as being in exactly the same positions as before, and, for the instant, stationary. But now there is a nonzero acceleration.
Which way will the mass accelerate?

Do you mean the answer is wrong (Given ans: 5N)..i still stuck
 
stuc said:
Do you mean the answer is wrong (Given ans: 5N)..i still stuck
Yes, it's wrong. (That would be the right answer if the angle were 45 degrees.)
You have established that the weight is 10sin(60) N. Draw a free body diagram, exactly like the original diagram, but with only one rope.
So the rope is still at 60 degrees to the horizontal.
Let the tension in the rope be T. You know the weight, and hence the mass. The tension and the weight are the only forces acting, agreed?
Which way will the mass accelerate?
What can you therefore say about the forces orthogonal to that direction?
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: stuc