Is Pain Merely a Form of Emotion?

  • Thread starter Thread starter P4PPY
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Emotion Pain
Click For Summary
SUMMARY

The discussion centers on the relationship between pain and emotion, asserting that pain can be perceived similarly to emotions, with both being subject to control and expectation. Participants highlight the physiological aspects of pain, such as nerve signals and spinal cord reactions, while also exploring the psychological dimensions, including the ability to mask emotional responses. The conversation raises questions about the nature of pain as an emotion and the complexities of human perception, suggesting that societal views may influence how pain is experienced and expressed.

PREREQUISITES
  • Understanding of neurobiology, particularly nerve signaling and spinal cord functions.
  • Familiarity with psychological concepts related to emotion and perception.
  • Knowledge of the physiological effects of adrenaline on pain perception.
  • Awareness of societal norms regarding emotional expression and pain.
NEXT STEPS
  • Research the role of the spinal cord in pain perception and its distinction from brain processing.
  • Explore the psychological mechanisms behind emotional control and pain management techniques.
  • Investigate the effects of adrenaline on pain perception in high-stress situations.
  • Examine societal attitudes towards pain and emotional expression in various cultures.
USEFUL FOR

This discussion is beneficial for psychologists, neuroscientists, medical professionals, and anyone interested in the interplay between physical pain and emotional experience.

P4PPY
Messages
17
Reaction score
0
Is pain just an emotion?

I understand that pain is brought about by such things like nerve endings sending signals to the brain in an effort to notify us of danger, much like the hand on the oven burner. Hey… it’s hot, might want to move your hand away from the fire.
But the brain confuses dangerous pain (permanently harming the body) with necessary pain (vaccine shots).
You can control pain in much the same way as you can control an emotion. Such as an emotional person cries during a sad movie and a construction worker does not.
You can control your reaction to physical pain by expecting it. If you know someone is going to be sticking a needle in your arm you can prepare for the pain and stunt the brains natural reaction to move away from it.
This to me seems no different than controlling an emotion.

Sorry, just rambling today. This constantly pops into my head.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
It's possible. I mean, you can, most of the time, look at someone and tell if they're angry, upset, or sad (emotions). And most of the time, you can look at someone and pretty much see the pain on their face. So, yeah, I guess it's an emotion.

Does this make sense?
 
Visually identifying someone who is in pain should be fairly easy I suppose.

But on the other hand... if someone doesn't want you to know they are sad... can't they just hold back the tears and/or fake happiness to hide their sadness?

Why can we not do the same thing with pain? Is it just a more dominant emotion than all of the rest, much harder to disguise?
 
Pain is an obssessive compelling emotion. But the biggest question is - what constitutes an emotion? A short pulse of electricity in a "body" that's otherwise made of quadrillion of opposite electrical charges? The prospect of us ever finding out the full picture of what causes the perception of physical/objective reality looks quite hopeless. You cannot but be amazed at the level of complexity of a human being, or even of a Neanderthal. Even 300 000 years ago they possessed bodies composed of more than 100 trillion cells(a human body is composed of 100 trillion), running altogether more than a quadrillion operations per second in full sync(metabolism, cell repair, cell division, oxygen transfusion, etc). It's frightening to what lengths nature/god has to go to produce this assumed to be meaningless and pointless perception of life/existence. It's hard to say which is true - that the complexity is too great or if we are still too dumb, descending from dumb creatures that hanged for hours from the branches of trees in Africa. But if they had more intelligence to understand what was going on, instead of just relying on their innate survival instincts, they wouldn't put up with their quite miserable painful lives and would commit a mass suicide.(i expect scores of folks to jump on me and explain how their brains were wired differently to find enjoyment in their way of life, regardless how miserable it was).

I can't find the author of the quote, but it was related to the question if we can know everything, and it was to the effect of:

"We can't find all the answers about the system while we are a part of it." (Heisenberg?)
 
Nicely said Wave.

What I'm curious about is the desire to enjoy the feeling of pain, much like someone might enjoy a good cry every once in awhile. If it's nothing more than an emotion... it would seem to be possible.

Or would society be against that? =)
 
Is flatulence an emotion? If so, I'm telepathic.
 
CaptainQuasar said:
Is flatulence an emotion? If so, I'm telepathic.
Yes it is, and I'm skilled in remote viewing (smelling). Stay away until you cut back on the beans and cabbage.
 
P4PPY said:
Nicely said Wave.

What I'm curious about is the desire to enjoy the feeling of pain, much like someone might enjoy a good cry every once in awhile. If it's nothing more than an emotion... it would seem to be possible.

Or would society be against that? =)

Yes. I've seen and met Marines that actually entice you because they enjoy the feeling of pain. But, then again, they've all got a few loose wires because of the war. But, whatever floats your boat...
 
<-- Marine :)

I think you bringing that up reminded me of some of the training back in the early days and how adrenaline can effect your perception of pain.
 
  • #10
P4PPY said:
<-- Marine :)

I think you bringing that up reminded me of some of the training back in the early days and how adrenaline can effect your perception of pain.

No problem. Care to share? Maybe the answers locked inside your training. After all I've seen drill seargeants wearing shirts that say "pain is weakness leaving the body"
 
  • #11
Hey… it’s hot, might want to move your hand away from the fire.

This reaction doesn't actually take place in the brain though, but rather somewhere in your spinal cord
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
4K
  • · Replies 20 ·
Replies
20
Views
3K
  • · Replies 67 ·
3
Replies
67
Views
7K
  • · Replies 7 ·
Replies
7
Views
3K
  • · Replies 287 ·
10
Replies
287
Views
27K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
3K
  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
6K
  • · Replies 20 ·
Replies
20
Views
325K
Replies
27
Views
6K
Replies
23
Views
9K