Is "When the Sun is Shining, Is it Hot?" a Logical Sentence?

  • Level: High School 
  • Thread starter Thread starter iii
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Hot Sun The sun
Join the discussion
Registration is free. Start your own thread to ask a follow-up.
3 replies · 4K views
iii
Messages
46
Reaction score
0
Do the sentence "when the sun is shining then it is hot" is a logic sentence ?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
It merely states a proposition, rather than presenting any argument.
 
iii said:
when the sun is shining then it is hot
is a meaningful declarative sentence, its content/meaning is often referred to as a proposition, it states a fact [in a peculiar manner]
: "sun warms
[air]"
[the meaning of a sentence] a proposition has the property of being true/ false, not logical. [the unnecessary, redundant use of "when-then" may generate confusion].
Logical, can be only an ordered set of sentences: a deductive/ inductive argument.
A logical argument [has logical form] is valid and the conclusion, the conclusive proposition, is true
 
Last edited:
You can maybe consider two possible settings: truth-functional logic and predicate logic.

In TFL , an argument consists of two collections of sentences ; the first being the premises, and the second one being the conclusion, and where the premises purport to prove the conclusion, so that a truth assignment in {T,F} can be made of the sentence.
Then maybe your statement is an argument with an empty set of premises, and you can declare it to be either true or false at will.

In Predicate logic, I guess this could be a sentence within an interpretation,where there are predicates for 'hot', for shining, and maybe some non-logical inference rule that tells us what
happens when the sunis shining, and , then, within the interpretation, one can conclude that the sentence is true or false.

Maybe we could also use temporal logic to show the dependence of 'hotness' when the sun shining somehow.