Mechanics questions from textbook

8 replies · 2K views · last reply
TheePhysicsStudent
Messages
21
Reaction score
17
Homework Statement
I know HOW to get the answer as i underwent trial and error, but I don't actually understand the process of why we do what we do:
Relevant Equations
Friction = mgsin θ
Textbook page of mechanics questions 2 to 4, with Figure 6 showing a bowstring pulled back to a 140 degree angle between its two halves, with 70 degree markings and a force arrow pointing left to hold the arrow in place.
These are the questions I am failing to comprehend despite their very basic nature
Answer key for exercise 6.2 listing numerical answers to parts 1 to 4, including values in newtons and angles such as 7.3 N at 31.5 degrees to the vertical.
This is the wonderful support from the book explaining how to get the answer ! (It just gives you the answer no working out which is annoying)
Handwritten free-body diagram of a block on a 30 degree incline showing weight 5.4 resolved into 5.4 sin 30 along the slope and 5.4 cos 30 = 4.7 perpendicular to it, plus a second force vector diagram with arrows labelled 2.7 and 4.7 and 5.4 and a 30 degree angle.
Handwritten diagram of a string AB pulled down at the midpoint by a 4 N weight, with tension T in each half, angles of 73.3 degrees at the join, and sag of 0.12 m over a 0.4 m half-span; below it, the working T = 4 / (2 cos 73) = 6.8.
I
 
I would like to start with 2 B II, the support force from the slope on the object
 
TheePhysicsStudent said:
I would like to start with 2 B II, the support force from the slope on the object
Sorry i looked at the wrong question, I meant Question 4 sorry for any inconvenience I caused you
 
TheePhysicsStudent said:
Sorry i looked at the wrong question, I meant Question 4 sorry for any inconvenience I caused you
No need to apologize: we help voluntarily :smile:

In the mean time I have looked at the first one (2a) and I do have comments on that one:

Handwritten free-body diagram of a block on a 30 degree incline, with annotations 5.4 sin 30 and 5.4 cos 30 = 4.7, a labeled friction arrow, and a note saying 'object in equilibrium'.

You are asked to show the three forces on the object. I see four arrows; two are correct and one is missing

Free-body diagram of a block on an inclined plane, with force arrows labeled N (normal force), F_fric (friction force) and mg (weight) acting from the block's center, the slope hatched beneath it.
Agree ?

You are also asked for the support force from the slope acting on the object. Any suggestions ?

- - - - -

Re Question 4 (PF prefers one item per thread to facilitate referencing and avoid confusion, but never mind...)

Handwritten diagram of a mass held by two strings from points A and B, with tensions T labelled on each string and a downward force 4N, plus a worked line T = 4 / (cos 73°) × 1/2 = 6.8.
What you appear to do looks OK to me, but you are just like the book: you don't tell. What's the very basic nature under this one ?

Equilibrium ##\Leftrightarrow## sum of forces is zero

A better drawing is in order: in your picture the tensions don't act on the object

##\ ##
 
And somehow I get 6.96, i.e. 7.0 N, not 6.8

(golden rule: don't round off intermediate results).

The picture I had in mind:

Free-body diagram of a point mass with tensions T1 and T2 pulling up and outward at 73.3 degrees from the vertical, and weight mg = 4 N pointing down.
General idea clear now ? Basic nature :wink: ?
##\ ##​
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: TheePhysicsStudent
BvU said:
(golden rule: don't round off intermediate results).
Platinum rule: Don't find intermediate angles if you are looking for trig functions.

Free-body diagram of a point mass held by two strings at angle θ from the vertical, tensions T1 and T2 pulling up and outward, weight mg = 4 N pointing down, with a right triangle showing legs 0.12 and 0.80 and angle θ.

Here, $$\sin\theta=\frac{0.80}{\sqrt{0.12^2+0.80^2}}~;~~\cos\theta=\frac{0.12}{\sqrt{0.12^2+0.80^2}}~;~~\tan\theta=\frac{0.80}{0.12}.$$ :wink:
 
Last edited:
  • Haha
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: TheePhysicsStudent and BvU
Ancient dutch expression: there's always boss above boss

Ancient greek expression: turtles all the way down

##\ ##
 
  • Haha
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Juanda and TheePhysicsStudent
WOW! I can't thank you enough, especially for question 4 as I realise that whilst I was sort of there I made it so much weirder than it had to be, Many thanks to you guys
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: BvU, kuruman and berkeman