Minimum voltage for electrons to reach anode in cylindrical geometry

12 replies · 2K views · last reply
PumpkinCougar95
Gold Member
Messages
63
Reaction score
13

Homework Statement


Problem Statement: A system consists of a long cylindrical anode of radius a and a coaxial cylindrical cathode of radius b (b < a). A filament located along the axis of the system carries a heating current I producing a magnetic field in the surrounding space. Find the least potential difference between the cathode and anode at which the thermal electrons leaving the cathode without initial velocity start reaching the anode.

Homework Equations



F = m dv/dt = q( E + v x B )

The Attempt at a Solution


What I have tried: https://drive.google.com/open?id=1sLIz7ZsUwS0wkBW4iGEXWJBrxCenahKs

Handwritten derivation on lined notebook paper: magnetic field into the plane, electron velocity components, equations m dVx/dt = eBVy and integrated form giving V = -e V0^2 I^2/(8 pi^2 m) log(a/b), with a cylinder diagram showing filament current I.

In the last step, I forgot to put a square on the log() term. But what I have written is given as the correct answer. I do not understand what I have done wrong. Help, please?
 
Attachments
  • Handwritten derivation on lined notebook paper: magnetic field into the plane, electron velocity components, equations m dVx/dt = eBVy and integrated form giving V = -e V0^2 I^2/(8 pi^2 m) log(a/b), with a cylinder diagram showing filament current I.
    Ans..jpeg
    49 KB · Views: 463
Last edited by a moderator:
Hello, and welcome to PF!

Why do you think you've made a mistake?
 
The answer I got is not correct. Apart from that, I don't really understand.
 
PumpkinCougar95 said:
The answer I got is not correct. Apart from that, I don't really understand.
In your first post you said that what you had written gives the correct answer. Here you are saying you did not get the correct answer. So, I'm a little confused.
Your answer in the first post looks correct to me (except for possibly a sign issue).
 
Oh sorry for the misunderstanding. In the last step I wrote, you can see I missed a square sign on the log() term from my previous line. What I meant was that the correct answer doesn't have a square on the log() term.
 
I think the correct answer should have a square on the log term.
 
But here it doesn't have a square...

https://drive.google.com/open?id=150Xo6D7BZjyYOkX3oiMmyqtbWZdhIVGA
https://drive.google.com/open?id=1RFOoNg3Pk5N35cuZ9o_Wv5ugz3aMfgIW
 
Equation for kinetic energy (1/2)mv^2 equal to a bracketed expression containing |e|V over ln(a/b), ln(rho/b), and (mu0 I / 2 pi)^2 terms, followed by the condition that the right-hand side must be positive for a > rho > b, giving V >= (1/2)(|e|/m)(mu0 I/2 pi)^2 ln(a/b).

In deriving the second equation from the first equation above, you should get a square on the log term.
[EDIT: The first equation above should have a square on the log in the second term on the right side. The answer for V in the second equation should also have a square on the log.]
 
Attachments
  • Equation for kinetic energy (1/2)mv^2 equal to a bracketed expression containing |e|V over ln(a/b), ln(rho/b), and (mu0 I / 2 pi)^2 terms, followed by the condition that the right-hand side must be positive for a > rho > b, giving V >= (1/2)(|e|/m)(mu0 I/2 pi)^2 ln(a/b).
    upload_2018-2-23_16-34-13.png
    5.3 KB · Views: 396
Last edited:
Yes, i got it. Thanks for your help!
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: TSny
I think you would only need to solve the Fz equation to get the answer, so it doesn't make any difference whether you use cylindrical or cartesian coordinates.

I have no idea on how to solve these equations completely.
 
But if you know ##V_z## you can apply conservation of energy between r=a and r=b. See my first post.