Need to interview an engineer for assignment

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around a college student's assignment to interview engineers, focusing on their experiences, education, and insights into the engineering field, particularly mechanical engineering. The scope includes personal reflections, career expectations, and the realities of working in engineering.

Discussion Character

  • Homework-related
  • Exploratory

Main Points Raised

  • One participant is currently working in Power Systems but designs equipment unrelated to that field.
  • Another participant notes that engineering is competitive, leading to choices based on availability rather than preference.
  • Several participants mention that their college education aligns well with their current job requirements, particularly in applying mechanical engineering principles.
  • Work environments vary, with one participant describing their office as adjacent to an equipment holding yard, which they find interesting.
  • Pressure in the workplace is acknowledged, with comments on the demands from colleagues regarding project timelines.
  • Teamwork is emphasized as crucial for success in engineering roles, with mixed preferences for working in teams versus alone.
  • Participants discuss the sacrifices required to succeed in engineering education, with some indicating that many students do not complete their studies.
  • Reflections on job satisfaction vary, with one participant expressing happiness with their work-life balance and set hours.
  • Concerns about the expectations of engineers to have comprehensive knowledge and the stress associated with that responsibility are raised.
  • Advice for prospective engineering students includes being prepared for sacrifices and the possibility of entering a field that may not align with initial interests.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants share similar experiences regarding the challenges and realities of engineering careers, but there is no explicit consensus on the best approach to entering the field or the importance of specific aspects of the job.

Contextual Notes

Some responses reflect personal experiences and subjective views, which may not apply universally. The discussion includes varying degrees of satisfaction with career paths and educational backgrounds.

Who May Find This Useful

This discussion may be useful for engineering students, educators, and professionals interested in the perspectives of recent graduates and the realities of working in engineering fields.

ljbcac
Messages
2
Reaction score
0
Hello. I'm a freshman in college and I'm taking an engineering introduction course. Our assignment for this week is to interview an engineer who has a four-year degree in engineering.

So I'm coming here for help! Any reply much appreciated!

Here are the questions:

1.Which field of mechanical engineering are you in? Automobile, material, etc.

2.Why did you choose this field?

3.How long have you been in the engineering field?

4.Was mechanical engineering the only major you took in college?

5.Does what you learned in college match what you need in your work?

6.Where do you work? In an office building or a factory?

7.Do you like the place you work at?

8.Do you feel much pressure in your work?

9.How important is teamwork in your work?

10.Which one do you enjoy more, working as a team or working alone?

11.What do you think is needed to be a good engineer?

12.Does the money you make now match what you expected when you first decided to enter this field?

13.Are you satisfied with your current status? The balance between career and personal life, salary, relationship with workmates, etc.

14.What is the good things and bad things working as an engineer?

15.Any suggestion for a student who's going to enter this field? Thanks!

Thank you so much for your time!

Also, our instructor require us to include the following information:

Your company / position / degree background / college attended

Please include the information you don't mind including. It's perfectly alright if you wouldn't like to include those. Again, thank you so much for you help. I appreciate that!
 
Last edited:
Engineering news on Phys.org
1.Which field of mechanical engineering are you in? Automobile, material, etc.
Power Systems at the moment. Although, I design equipment, has nothing to do with power systems.

2.Why did you choose this field?
I didn't, engineering is a very competitive field, you end up taking what you can get.

3.How long have you been in the engineering field?
4 years.

4.Was mechanical engineering the only major you took in college?
I did mechanical and aerospace engineering, which is counted as two majors at the uni I went to.

5.Does what you learned in college match what you need in your work?
Yeah, it matches quite nicely. I use stress analysis and other mechanical engineering equations all the time. I wish I paid more attention in these classes.

6.Where do you work? In an office building or a factory?
In an office building right next to an equipment holding yard. It has a lot of large machinery and other cool stuff.

7.Do you like the place you work at?
Yeah, it's different. It's not another boring office building.

8.Do you feel much pressure in your work?
Sometimes. People want things done and keep asking you how it's going and when it's going to be done. THey don't care what other people have asked you to do.

9.How important is teamwork in your work?
Teamwork is everything... you must learn this or fail.

10.Which one do you enjoy more, working as a team or working alone?
It's nice to have a mix of both. It also depends on your team...

11.What do you think is needed to be a good engineer?
Be prepared to give up your life for 4 years. Most people quit before the end of the first year because they aren't prepared for this. It's a long grueling ride. I could list a whole heap of stuff here, but what I think it boils down to is being prepared to do what it takes.

12.Does the money you make now match what you expected when you first decided to enter this field?
I never thought about the money when I left school. Just chose what I thought was cool. I wanted to work on aircraft in defence. Big mistake there.

13.Are you satisfied with your current status? The balance between career and personal life, salary, relationship with workmates, etc.
Yeah, couldn't be happier. It's nice having a weekend and set hours. I've had jobs where I worked weeks ina row with a random changing roster. Making planning anything very difficult.

14.What is the good things and bad things working as an engineer?
Trusting yourself that the things you design and sign off have actually been done correctly. It's always there at the back of your mind. People also expect you to know everything.

15.Any suggestion for a student who's going to enter this field? Thanks!
Besides being preapred to make a lot of sacrifices, be prepared to enter a field you don't want to.

The last things you're after, it wouldn't be wise for anyone to give those out. But I will answer these:

Mechanical Design Engineer / Bachelor of Engineering (Mech and Aerospace), Master of Engineering / The University of Queensland (Australia).
 
Vadar2012 said:
1.Which field of mechanical engineering are you in? Automobile, material, etc.
Power Systems at the moment. Although, I design equipment, has nothing to do with power systems.

2.Why did you choose this field?
I didn't, engineering is a very competitive field, you end up taking what you can get.

3.How long have you been in the engineering field?
4 years.

4.Was mechanical engineering the only major you took in college?
I did mechanical and aerospace engineering, which is counted as two majors at the uni I went to.

5.Does what you learned in college match what you need in your work?
Yeah, it matches quite nicely. I use stress analysis and other mechanical engineering equations all the time. I wish I paid more attention in these classes.

6.Where do you work? In an office building or a factory?
In an office building right next to an equipment holding yard. It has a lot of large machinery and other cool stuff.

7.Do you like the place you work at?
Yeah, it's different. It's not another boring office building.

8.Do you feel much pressure in your work?
Sometimes. People want things done and keep asking you how it's going and when it's going to be done. THey don't care what other people have asked you to do.

9.How important is teamwork in your work?
Teamwork is everything... you must learn this or fail.

10.Which one do you enjoy more, working as a team or working alone?
It's nice to have a mix of both. It also depends on your team...

11.What do you think is needed to be a good engineer?
Be prepared to give up your life for 4 years. Most people quit before the end of the first year because they aren't prepared for this. It's a long grueling ride. I could list a whole heap of stuff here, but what I think it boils down to is being prepared to do what it takes.

12.Does the money you make now match what you expected when you first decided to enter this field?
I never thought about the money when I left school. Just chose what I thought was cool. I wanted to work on aircraft in defence. Big mistake there.

13.Are you satisfied with your current status? The balance between career and personal life, salary, relationship with workmates, etc.
Yeah, couldn't be happier. It's nice having a weekend and set hours. I've had jobs where I worked weeks ina row with a random changing roster. Making planning anything very difficult.

14.What is the good things and bad things working as an engineer?
Trusting yourself that the things you design and sign off have actually been done correctly. It's always there at the back of your mind. People also expect you to know everything.

15.Any suggestion for a student who's going to enter this field? Thanks!
Besides being preapred to make a lot of sacrifices, be prepared to enter a field you don't want to.

The last things you're after, it wouldn't be wise for anyone to give those out. But I will answer these:

Mechanical Design Engineer / Bachelor of Engineering (Mech and Aerospace), Master of Engineering / The University of Queensland (Australia).

Thank you so much for your help! I know it's unreasonable to ask for those information. Sorry about that!

Also, personally I have been interested in the questions above for a long time, so your reply is really a big deal for me! Thanks again!
 
I do the mechanical design of gas turbines.

I've worked many different jobs in the last 4 decades involving many aspects of mechanival, marine, and civil engineering. I tend to change jobs simply for the opportunity to learn new things.

I've studied anything and everything that interested me. But mechanical engineering was my first major and still my primary focus.

What I learned in college was less than 5% of what I needed for any of my jobs. But different jobs used a different 5%. Consider your degree as a license to continue learning.

I've worked in swamps, I've walked high steel, I've rappeled into tanks, I've swam thru sewer pipes, and I've worked in very nice air conditioned offices.

I have liked every one of my jobs, except one that I quit for that reason.

The more pressure the better.

Engineering is a team sport.

I can't remember any job where I worked alone.

11- you need a deep abiding love and passion for it.

I've never really cared how much money I made, but I've always made more than I need. This job is 30K per year less than the last and I don't care because it is so much fun.

I'm very satisfied, and there is no dividing line between personal and professional life because I live my passion in both. I'm still very happily married to the same lady I married at age 17 and we have lots of time to do fun stuff together.

14- is that not self evident?

15- if you don't have a strong driving passion to do this, then find another line of work where you do.
 
ljbcac -- Welcome to the PF.

Unfortunately, for privacy and anti-phishing reasons, we do not allowe interview threads at the PF. This thread is closed.
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
1K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
2K
Replies
6
Views
2K
Replies
13
Views
5K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
2K
  • · Replies 14 ·
Replies
14
Views
2K
Replies
1
Views
2K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
2K
Replies
10
Views
3K