New member seeking expert advice in particle physics

[AllthingsEM]

How did you find PF?

Recommended by co-Pilot as a forum for expert answers on physics questions.

I am an organic medicinal chemist that sometimes wanders outside the lines and could use grounding and a reality check on strange notions and topics several playgrounds over. I am hopeful that the forum can provide this within reason and expert members might engage on ideas I've been thinking about. I am thinking currently about the proposition that matter consists of stable, closed electromagnetic cycles whose topology and exposure geometry determine particle identity, stability, interactions, and transitions with the help of co-Pilot, but I don't know whether the output is just an AI-generated science fantasy.

 

[berkeman]

Welcome to PF.

Please keep in mind that we do not allow discussion of personal theories or speculation. All discussions must be based on the published professional scientific literature (peer-reviewed journal articles and mainstream textbooks). This is indeed a great place to get answers on physics and STEM questions, but please be sure to find articles that discuss what you are wanting to ask about, and post links to those articles to start the discussions. Thanks.

 

[renormalize]

I am thinking currently about the proposition that matter consists of stable, closed electromagnetic cycles whose topology and exposure geometry determine particle identity, stability, interactions, and transitions with the help of co-Pilot, but I don't know whether the output is just an AI-generated science fantasy.

Personal theories and the use of AI are explicitly prohibited here on Physics Forums, per its usage rules:

Thread 'Physics Forums Global Guidelines'

Sep 2, 2003

Welcome to Physics Forums!

In an effort to maintain the integrity of this site and to provide a comfortable environment for people to communicate, we ask that you please follow these Guidelines when posting on this site. These guidelines are global and apply to every area of this site. Mentors may choose to enact specific guidelines for individual forums, which are to be taken as an extension to the global guidelines when posting and visiting that specific forum. These specific guidelines are usually sticky topics placed at the top of the specific forum.

Application and...

• Greg Bernhardt
• Replies: 2
• Forum: Feedback and Announcements

• 

• ChatGPT and AI-generated text
  • Posting AI-generated text without attribution is categorically disallowed and will lead to a warning and an eventual permanent ban with continued use.
  • Answering a science or math question with AI-generated text, even with attribution, is not allowed. AI-generated text apps like ChatGPT are not valid sources.
  • Threads about the technology and cultural impact behind AI like ChatGPT are allowed
  • Usage of AI-generated text output in entertainment threads in General Discussion with attribution is allowed.
• Speculative or Personal Theories:
  Physics Forums is not intended as an alternative to the usual professional venues for discussion and review of new ideas, e.g. personal contacts, conferences, and peer review before publication. If you have a new theory or idea, this is not the place to look for feedback on it or to ask for help developing and publishing it.

You should seek out a different venue for posting your speculations.

 

[russ_watters]

I will say this though:

I am thinking currently about the proposition that matter consists of stable, closed electromagnetic cycles whose topology and exposure geometry determine particle identity, stability, interactions, and transitions with the help of co-Pilot, but I don't know whether the output is just an AI-generated science fantasy.

Unfortunately that sounds like exactly what you fear it is. That's what you are going to get most of the time, and what you wrote sounds like word salad.