- #1

- 5,473

- 2,790

You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.

You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.

You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.

- Thread starter Charles Link
- Start date

- #1

- 5,473

- 2,790

- #2

Mentor

- 34,458

- 12,430

This is not an example of nonlinear behavior.Qualitatively however, non-linear behavior can be readily observed. e.g. two impulses with the proper timing can (instead of creating twice the amplitude) bring the system to a stop.

This is only true if you are dealing with non linear media. For linear media superposition holds.Non-linear properties can also be observed in optical interference patterns even though Maxwell's equations are completely linear.

No, in non linear media the equations are non linear.Thereby, non-linear features are also readily observed in optical systems that are governed by linear equations.

Yes. You can always take any linear equation and write a non linear equation using the same terms.This puzzle seems to have a simple but not-so-obvious solution that "not all of the equations governing the properties of these systems are linear." In particular, the energy equations are in general quadratic in the linear parameters so that system properties involving the energy are not required to exhibit linear behavior.

Your conclusion is correct (you can write nonlinear equations for a linear system), but your examples are not correct (the examples you mentioned are linear).

- #3

- 5,473

- 2,790

Yes, the systems are linear, but the non-linear behavior is in the behavior of the energy properties. For example, the spatial energy patterns of each separate source do not superimpose in a linear fashion to form the spatial energy pattern for two mutually coherent sources, even though the system (with Maxwell's equations) is completely linear in the electric and magnetic field parameters and is thereby designated as "totally linear". The energy equations of the electromagnetic system, which also govern the behavior of the system, are U=E^2/(8*pi)+B^2/(8*pi), and are non-linear in the E and B fields. Thereby some features of a non-linear variety (e.g. interference patterns where the energy patterns don't superimpose) can be expected to be observed in electromagnetic systems.This is not an example of nonlinear behavior.

This is only true if you are dealing with non linear media. For linear media superposition holds.

No, in non linear media the equations are non linear.

Yes. You can always take any linear equation and write a non linear equation using the same terms.

Your conclusion is correct (you can write nonlinear equations for a linear system), but your examples are not correct (the examples you mentioned are linear).

- #4

Mentor

- 34,458

- 12,430

Sure, energy is not linear, but these specific points you make are not about energy and are not examples of nonlinearity:Yes, the systems are linear, but the non-linear behavior is in the behavior of the energy properties.

two impulses with the proper timing can (instead of creating twice the amplitude) bring the system to a stop.

As I said above, your conclusion is correct but some of your supporting examples were not. I am not refuting your conclusion but just telling you that some of your examples don't support it. Your argument will be stronger if you stick to examples that support the conclusion.. Non-linear properties can also be observed in optical interference patterns

- #5

- 5,473

- 2,790

With the pendulum, (or a mass on a spring), two impulses (energy) "input" can result in zero (energy) "output". That again indicates non-linear in the sense that the output isn't proportional to the input. In some ways, it's very much a "triviality". A more mathematical example is with Parseval's theorem, which is second order in the parameters and holds for any completely linear system for which Fourier transforms apply. The fact that second order equations appear in the fundamental equations governing the system would indicate that system properties of a non-linear nature could be observed in these linear systems. The discussion probably has limited appeal for you. It's somewhat trivial in a way, but I find it of some interest.Sure, energy is not linear, but these specific points you make are not about energy and are not examples of nonlinearity:

As I said above, your conclusion is correct but some of your supporting examples were not. I am not refuting your conclusion but just telling you that some of your examples don't support it. Your argument will be stronger if you stick to examples that support the conclusion.

- #6

- 5,473

- 2,790

Share:

- Replies
- 1

- Views
- 614

- Replies
- 1

- Views
- 1K

- Replies
- 3

- Views
- 15K

- Replies
- 2

- Views
- 1K

- Replies
- 5

- Views
- 835

- Replies
- 1

- Views
- 728

- Replies
- 23

- Views
- 2K

- Replies
- 8

- Views
- 1K

- Replies
- 2

- Views
- 2K

- Replies
- 3

- Views
- 919