Nucleon and Delta baryons (resonances)

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion centers on understanding nucleon and delta baryon resonances, including their properties, distinctions, and theoretical frameworks. Participants seek references and explanations regarding the nature of these resonances and their historical significance in particle physics.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Technical explanation
  • Historical

Main Points Raised

  • Some participants inquire about good references for understanding nucleon and delta resonances, including how many resonances exist and how they are distinguished.
  • One participant suggests that nucleon resonances can be understood as spin and/or isospin excitations of the nucleon, with the delta baryons being a composite state of the nucleon and a pion.
  • Another participant explains that delta baryons represent a spin excitation of the nucleon doublet, noting the differences in quark spin alignment between nucleons and delta baryons.
  • It is mentioned that the bag model and vector-gluon exchange model provide estimates for the masses of delta baryons in relation to nucleons.
  • A historical note is provided regarding the Delta baryons' role in the development of the concept of color charge in quantum chromodynamics (QCD), particularly in relation to the Pauli Exclusion Principle and the properties of identical fermions.
  • A participant recommends an article that compiles data on baryon resonances and strong QCD, although it may be outdated.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants express various viewpoints and hypotheses regarding the nature and classification of nucleon and delta baryons, with no consensus reached on specific explanations or models.

Contextual Notes

Some claims rely on specific theoretical models, such as the bag model and vector-gluon exchange model, which may have limitations or assumptions that are not fully explored in the discussion.

CarlB
Science Advisor
Homework Helper
Messages
1,246
Reaction score
45
Okay, I decided to start trying to understand the nulceon and delta resonances. Does anyone have suggestions for a good explanation of how these work? How many resonances are there? How are they distinguished? Etc.

Here's the PDG information:

http://pdg.lbl.gov/2006/listings/bxxxcomb.html

I'll add more information as I dredge it up from the web. What I'm really looking for is suggestions on a good reference book.

Okay, here's a good place to get things:
http://www.jlab.org/div_dept/physics_division/events/campaign_blocks_1B.html
In particular, the 6MB 154 page document:
http://www.jlab.org/div_dept/physics_division/talks/Background/Hall_B/Burkert_2004_StAndrews.pdf
 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
CarlB said:
Okay, I decided to start trying to understand the nulceon and delta resonances. Does anyone have suggestions for a good explanation of how these work? How many resonances are there? How are they distinguished? Etc.

Here's the PDG information:

http://pdg.lbl.gov/2006/listings/bxxxcomb.html

I'll add more information as I dredge it up from the web. What I'm really looking for is suggestions on a good reference book.

Okay, here's a good place to get things:
http://www.jlab.org/div_dept/physics_division/events/campaign_blocks_1B.html
In particular, the 6MB 154 page document:
http://www.jlab.org/div_dept/physics_division/talks/Background/Hall_B/Burkert_2004_StAndrews.pdf

That last document you linked to is nice. The nucleon resonances are understood as (someone correct me if I am wrong) spin and/or isospin excitations of the nucleon. The earliest understandings of the Delta were that it could be seen as a composite state of the nucleon and a pion.
 
This is a good start you guys have here... good selection of articles too.

The Delta baryons are a spin excitation of the nucleon doublet. Since the nucleon is the non-strange isospin-1/2 group in the JP = 1/2+ octet (ground state), the Delta resonances are the spin-excited equivalent in the JP = 3/2- decuplet. While the nucleon will have two quark spins aligned and one opposite, and hence only two possible flavor states (uud, udd) corresponding to isospin-1/2, the Delta baryons will have all three quark spins aligned. This allows for the isospin to extend to 3/2 for the Delta's, so there are four possible flavor states (uuu, uud, udd, ddd). The bag model gives a good estimate for the masses of the Delta's in relation to the nucleons, and so does the basic vector-gluon exchange model, both with simple expressions.

The Delta baryon has an interesting historical note attached to it. The Delta++ and Delta- were the first baryons to grab attention when theorists were first considering the problem of partons. You see, the problem is that the Pauli Exclusion Principle does not allow for identical Fermionic particles to fall into the same energy state. As quarks are fermions, and they are grouped in three's to form baryons, then there should be no more than two identical in any grouping of three. But the Delta++ has three identical up quarks in it! This meant that, in order to preserve the Pauli Principle in the Delta++ baryon, there needed to be another quantum number or property that distinguished each of the identical quarks from one another. This became the new SU(3) gauge group of "color", which went along with the non-Abelian "colored" vector gluons.

Since the advent of the non-Abelian gauge group of QCD, the masses of the baryons and mesons alike have been much better understood in such frameworks as the MIT bag model and others. The Delta baryons allowed physicists to discover this important element of nature.
 
Try this link for a good article, putting together the data more conveniently than the PDG, though it might be a few years out of date:

Baryon resonances and strong QCD
E. Klempt
http://www.arxiv.org/abs/nucl-ex/0203002

Carl
 
Last edited: