Person pushes down the length of the handle of a 12.1kg

  • Thread starter Thread starter racecar12
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Length
Click For Summary

Homework Help Overview

The discussion revolves around a physics problem involving a person pushing down on the handle of a 12.1 kg lawn spreader at an angle of 44.1 degrees with the horizontal, aiming to accelerate it from rest to 1.33 m/s in 1.7 seconds. Participants are exploring the forces involved in this scenario, particularly the force required to achieve the desired acceleration.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory, Assumption checking, Mathematical reasoning

Approaches and Questions Raised

  • Participants discuss calculating average acceleration and applying Newton's second law (F=ma) to find the force. There are questions about the components of the force and whether the calculated values seem reasonable. Some participants suggest resolving the force into horizontal and vertical components, while others express uncertainty about the role of gravity and the normal force in the calculations.

Discussion Status

The discussion is active, with participants providing clarifications and corrections regarding the calculations of force components. There is a focus on understanding the geometry of the situation and how to properly resolve forces. Some participants have offered guidance on using trigonometry to find the vertical component of the force based on the angle and the horizontal component.

Contextual Notes

Participants note potential confusion regarding the relevance of gravity and the normal force in the context of the problem. There is also mention of the need to clarify the relationship between the components of force and the overall force vector.

racecar12
Messages
19
Reaction score
1

Homework Statement



Person pushes down the length of the handle of a 12.1kg lawn spreader. The handle makes an angle 44.1 degrees with the horizontal. Person wishes to accelerate the spreader from rest to 1.33m/s in 1.7s. What forece must person apply to the handle?

Homework Equations



F=ma

I imagine a=Δv/Δt

The Attempt at a Solution



I started to find the average acceleration, using a =Δv/Δt. a = 0.78m/s^2

Plug and chug to F=ma and get 9.4N. This seems way too simple of a solution.

Should I carry on with this:
Fx=max
Fy=may

then just find the resultant of F.

Fx = -9.47
Fy = -118.58

Resultant F = 118.96N...that seems way too much?
 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org


racecar12 said:

Homework Statement



Person pushes down the length of the handle of a 12.1kg lawn spreader. The handle makes an angle 44.1 degrees with the horizontal. Person wishes to accelerate the spreader from rest to 1.33m/s in 1.7s. What forece must person apply to the handle?

Homework Equations



F=ma

I imagine a=Δv/Δt

The Attempt at a Solution



I started to find the average acceleration, using a =Δv/Δt. a = 0.78m/s^2

Plug and chug to F=ma and get 9.4N. This seems way too simple of a solution.

Should I carry on with this:
Fx=max
Fy=may

then just find the resultant of F, which is 0.78N?

Yeah, you need to resolve the force into components, because only the horizontal component will contribute to moving the machine horizontally. Obviously the vertical component won't contribute to moving the machine horizontally.

So the procedure would be to find the force Fx that would produce the required acceleration ax, and from that, and the angle, compute the resulting Fy.

EDIT: or just use the angle theta plus Fx to compute the resultant directly.
 


Okay, you added this part into your original post later:

racecar12 said:
then just find the resultant of F.

Fx = -9.47
Fy = -118.58

Resultant F = 118.96N...that seems way too much?

Your Fy is wrong. Plain and simple. Can you post the steps you used to calculate it?
 


To find Fy, I used the mass of the object x the negative acceleration due to gravity.

F= 12.1(-9.8)

I'm missing the normal force, I think? But now, I am unsure how to calculate it
 


racecar12 said:
To find Fy, I used the mass of the object x the negative acceleration due to gravity.

F= 12.1(-9.8)

I'm missing the normal force, I think? But now, I am unsure how to calculate it

Gravity has nothing to do with anything here. You are computing the y-component of the force that the person is applying to the object. It comes out just as a consequence of the geometry of the situation. If he's pushing with an angle of 44.1 degrees below horizontal, and the x-component is 9.4 N, then the y-component is completely determined.

Gravity acts on the object too. It tries to pull it towards the centre of the Earth. But it is countered by the normal force from the ground, and so the object stays put. None of this is relevant to the problem at hand. You're considering force on the object from the person, not from gravity, or from the ground.
 


Thanks for the clarification about gravity :)

I went back to find the y component of the vector...to equal 1.33sin41?

I thought 9.4 was the x component of the Force.

Does 1.33sin41 equal the y comonent of velocity? If so, then I could go about finiding the y component of acceleration and solve for Fy?
 


racecar12 said:
Thanks for the clarification about gravity :)

I went back to find the y component of the vector...to equal 1.33sin41?

No. 1.33 m/s is the speed after 1.7 s, and is entirely horizontal. It has absolutely nothing to do with what you are trying to compute here.

racecar12 said:
I thought 9.4 was the x component of the Force.
Yes.

racecar12 said:
Does 1.33sin41 equal the y comonent of velocity?
Again, no. The velocity is entirely horizontal, and it's not the thing that you are trying to compute (so I'm not sure why you keep talking about it). You're trying to compute the force.

racecar12 said:
If so, then I could go about finiding the y component of acceleration and solve for Fy?

You don't need to find the acceleration first! Just draw a diagram. You have your (overall) force vector. It is angled at 44.1 degrees below the horizontal. Now resolve this vector into component vectors Fx and Fy. Fx is horizontal and Fy is vertical. These three vectors form a right triangle. You know one of the sides (Fx) and you know one of the angles (θ), in addition to the 90 degree angle. Given this information, and the fact that it is a right triangle, how would you solve for Fy? It's entirely trigonometry.
 


Did what you said...

Fx = 9.4
Fy = 9.1

F = 13.1N

Thank you
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
4K
  • · Replies 41 ·
2
Replies
41
Views
5K
Replies
3
Views
6K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
21K
Replies
4
Views
3K