Phase of sound reflected from a closed end pipe

1 reply · 2K views · last reply
Vivek98phyboy
Messages
34
Reaction score
5
Homework Statement
While studying the fundamentals of sound waves in organ pipe, I noted that the fact about phase of reflected waves is contradicting while referring multiple sources
Relevant Equations
*
While studying the fundamentals of sound waves in organ pipe, I noted that the fact about phase of reflected waves is contradicting while referring multiple sources

This book of mine describes the reflection from a rigid surface/closed end to be in phase

Printed textbook page titled 'Reflection of Sound Waves' explaining that at a rigid boundary displacement is zero, pressure variation is maximum, and a reflected pressure wave has the same phase as the incident wave.
Whereas this one describes the reflection from a closed end to be 180° out of phase

Printed textbook page titled Conditions at the Boundary of an Organ Pipe, describing a closed pipe where a longitudinal wave reflects 180 degrees out of phase at the closed end, so compressions reflect as rarefactions and the closed end is a displacement node.


Yet, both the books says that, "compression returns as compression and rarefaction returns as rerefaction, from a hard surface" and I found it to be true in all the sources i referred. But this phase change described by them is completely contradicting with each other. I found the same issue while referring some online portals on this topic.

Why are these books contradicting each other?

Initially I thought that one of them might be discussing about pressure wave and another one about displacement wave, as they have a 90° phase difference at any point of time. But even in such case, a phase of difference of 180° shouldn't be produced, right?
 
Vivek98phyboy said:
one of them might be discussing about pressure wave and another one about displacement wave, as they have a 90° phase difference at any point of time.
Quite so.
The pressure and displacement functions can be a quarter cycle out of phase in opposite directions, so the two waves can be in phase for pressure but half a cycle out of phase for displacement.