Proposition 2.3.15: Understanding Sohrab's Basic Real Analysis Proof

  • Topic:
  • Thread starter Math Amateur
  • Start date
2 replies · 2K views · last reply
Math Amateur
Gold Member
MHB
Messages
3,920
Reaction score
48
I am reading Houshang H. Sohrab's book: "Basic Real Analysis" (Second Edition).

I am focused on Chapter 2: Sequences and Series of Real Numbers ... ...

I need help with yet another aspect of the proof of Proposition 2.3.15 ...Proposition 2.3.15 and its proof read as follows:
View attachment 9073
At the end of the above proof by Sohrab we read the following:

" ... ... The proposition now follows from $$\text{ lim sup } (t_n) \leq e \leq \text{ lim inf } (t_n)$$ and Proposition 2.2.39 (f) ... ... "But ... as far as I can tell from Proposition 2.2.39 (f) we require $$\text{ lim sup } (t_n) = e = \text{ lim inf } (t_n)$$ ... in order to conclude $$\text{ lim } (t_n) = e$$ ...

... but we only have the condition $$\text{ lim sup } (t_n) \leq e \leq \text{ lim inf } (t_n)$$ ... ...

So ... how does the proposition 2..3.15 follow ...?

Can someone please clarify the situation above ...
Help will be appreciated ...

Peter
=========================================================================The above post refers to Proposition 2.2.39 ... so I am providing text of the same ... as follows ... :
View attachment 9074
Hope that helps ...

Peter
 
Attachments
  • Textbook page proving that e, defined as the sum of 1/n! from n=0 to infinity, satisfies 2 < e < 3 and equals the limit of (1 + 1/n)^n as n tends to infinity, using limsup and liminf bounds.
    Sohrab - Proposition 2.3.15 ... .png
    26.9 KB · Views: 176
  • Printed text of Proposition 2.2.39 with parts (a) to (f) on bounds, limsup and liminf of a bounded sequence, followed by its proof of part (e) and (f).
    Sohrab - Proposition 2.2.39 ... .png
    34.2 KB · Views: 187
Peter said:
At the end of the above proof by Sohrab we read the following:

" ... ... The proposition now follows from $$\text{ lim sup } (t_n) \leq e \leq \text{ lim inf } (t_n)$$ and Proposition 2.2.39 (f) ... ... "But ... as far as I can tell from Proposition 2.2.39 (f) we require $$\text{ lim sup } (t_n) = e = \text{ lim inf } (t_n)$$ ... in order to conclude $$\text{ lim } (t_n) = e$$ ...

... but we only have the condition $$\text{ lim sup } (t_n) \leq e \leq \text{ lim inf } (t_n)$$ ... ...

So ... how does the proposition 2..3.15 follow ...?
It is always true that $\liminf (t_n) \leqslant \limsup(t_n)$. So in the inequalities $ \limsup(t_n) \leqslant e \leqslant \liminf (t_n) \leqslant \limsup(t_n)$ the last term is the same as the first, and therefore there must be equality throughout.
 
Opalg said:
It is always true that $\liminf (t_n) \leqslant \limsup(t_n)$. So in the inequalities $ \limsup(t_n) \leqslant e \leqslant \liminf (t_n) \leqslant \limsup(t_n)$ the last term is the same as the first, and therefore there must be equality throughout.
Thanks for the help, Opalg ...

Peter