Proving Convergence of Sequences: Analysis Series Proof

7 replies · 4K views · last reply
dancergirlie
Messages
194
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement


Let (a_n) and (b_n) be sequences with bn > 0 for all n in N. Assume that lim (an/bn) = L with L > 0.
Prove that the series:
[tex]\sum{a_n}[/tex] converges if and only if [tex]\sum{b_n}[/tex] converges


Homework Equations





The Attempt at a Solution



Since this is an if and only if proof, i know that I need to first assume if the an series converges, then so does the bn series. Next, I need to show if I assume the second series converges, then so does the first.

Alright, this is what I tried so far:

Assume [tex]\sum{a_n}[/tex] converges.
Meaning that the sequence (an) converges to zero.

If (an) converges to zero that means that for epsilon greater than zero there exists an N in N so that for n>=N:

|an|<epsilon

Since we are assuming lim (an/bn) converges to L>0 that means for epsilon greater than zero, there exists an N in N so that for n>=N:
|(an/bn)-L|<epsilon

I think that to show this, I need to show that bn converges to zero as well, but I'm not too sure how to do that. Or also, there is a theorem stating if an and bn are sequences satisfying 0<=an<=bn for all n in N then
if [tex]\sum{b_n}[/tex] converges then [tex]\sum{a_n}[/tex] converges.

So I guess if I can show that an is larger than bn for all n in N then I can prove that the series converges as well.

Any help/hints would be great!
 
Just because bn converges to zero, that does not mean the series of bn will converge. It looks like the theorem you stated might be a good approach, but I'm not for sure. Note that if you can show bn≤can, for some constant c, that might help. Because if an converges, then can converges as well. I haven't worked this proof out, but these are just some thoughts.
 
this was what I was thinking... since the limit of an/bn>0 that means that an has to be >=bn for all n in N.
We're also assuming bn>0 for all n in N which would mean
0<=bn<=an for all n in N
Which would mean if we assume that the series of an converges, that implies that the series of bn would converge.

Is my assumption about the limits correct or am I way off?

Also, then how would I go about proving that an converges if bn does if an is greater than or equal to bn for all n in N. Would I have to use the fact that if bn converges to zero if the series of bn converges?
 
sorry i meant would i have to use the fact that if the series converges, then the sequence converges to zero
 
Hi,

I'll give you some hints to prove that if [itex]\sum{a_n}[/itex] converges, then so does [itex]\sum{b_n}[/itex]:

1. When proving that an infinite sum converges, you can disregard any finite number of terms (the value of the sum might be affected, but not the convergence).
2. If [itex]\sum{a_n}[/itex] converges and c is any constant, then [itex]\sum{ca_n}[/itex] also converges.
3. If [itex]ca_n \geq 0[/itex] for some constant c and if [itex]|b_n| < ca_n[/itex] for all but finitely many n, then [itex]\sum{b_n}[/itex] converges (Comparison Test).
4. We know that [itex]\lim_{x\rightarrow \infty}\frac{a_n}{b_n} = L > 0[/itex]. Use the [itex]\epsilon[/itex] definition of convergence with [itex]\epsilon = \frac{L}{2}[/itex]:

There exists an N > 0 such that if n > N, then

[tex]\left| \frac{a_n}{b_n} - L \right| < \frac{L}{2}[/tex]

Simplify this inequality to conclude that

[tex]0 < b_n < \frac{a_n}{\frac{L}{2}}[/tex]

Now use observation #3 above to conclude that [itex]\sum{b_n}[/itex] converges. Note that the simplified inequality implies that [itex]a_n \geq 0[/itex] for all but finitely many [itex]a_n[/itex], justifying the use of #3.

Let me know if this isn't clear, or if you would like more hints.

Petek
 
Petek said:
[tex]\left| \frac{a_n}{b_n} - L \right| < \frac{L}{2}[/tex]

Simplify this inequality to conclude that

[tex]0 < b_n < \frac{a_n}{\frac{L}{2}}[/tex]

That's what confusing to me...
How do you get from
|an/bn-L|<L/2 to that inequality? I know that 0<bn, but how do yo justify that an/(L/2)>b?

Also, to show that an converges if bn converges would I have to find a constant c so that
0<c*seriesan< series of bn?
 
oh wait nevermind, I understand, i was confused cause I was looking at the part showing that an<=(3/2)L*bn
But that is what I will use to prove that if bn converges then so does an. Thanks so much for your help!