Quantum Mechanics Positional Operator

Click For Summary

Homework Help Overview

The discussion revolves around the expectation value of the positional operator in quantum mechanics, specifically for a particle in a one-dimensional box. Participants are analyzing the wave function and its implications for calculating the expectation value, <\hat{x}>.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory, Mathematical reasoning, Assumption checking

Approaches and Questions Raised

  • Participants discuss the wave function \Psi_{n}(x) and its boundaries, questioning the integration process used to find <\hat{x}>. There is an exploration of the integration steps and limits, with some participants suggesting that mistakes may have occurred in the calculations.

Discussion Status

Some participants have provided hints and guidance regarding the integration process, while others are still working through their calculations. There is recognition of potential errors in reasoning, but no explicit consensus has been reached on the final outcome.

Contextual Notes

Participants are operating under the constraints of homework rules, which may limit the extent of guidance provided. There is an acknowledgment of the complexity of quantum mechanics and the challenges faced by those new to the subject.

UbikPkd
Messages
9
Reaction score
0
[tex]\Psi_{n}(x)[/tex] = [tex]\sqrt{2/L}[/tex]sin([tex]\pi[/tex]nx/L), 0 [tex]\leq[/tex]x [tex]\leq[/tex] L


[tex]\Psi_{n}(x)[/tex] = 0, x<0, x>L

[tex]\pi[/tex] is meant to be just normal, not superscript, sorry

n is an integer

show that <[tex]\hat{x}[/tex]> = L/2




<[tex]\hat{x}[/tex]> is the expectation value of the positional operator [tex]\hat{x}[/tex] right?


[tex]\hat{x}[/tex] [tex]\Psi[/tex]= x [tex]\Psi[/tex] i think so...







[tex]\int[/tex]2x/L sin [tex]^{2}[/tex]([tex]\pi[/tex]2nx/L) dx

which gets me L/2 - L[tex]^{2}[/tex]/4n[tex]^{2}[/tex] [tex]\pi[/tex][tex]^{2}[/tex]


but it is supposed to be just L/2 sigh...

any help will be much appreciated :confused:
 
Physics news on Phys.org
UbikPkd said:
[tex]\Psi_{n}(x)[/tex] = [tex]\sqrt{2/L}[/tex]sin([tex]\pi[/tex]nx/L), 0 [tex]\leq[/tex]x [tex]\leq[/tex] L


[tex]\Psi_{n}(x)[/tex] = 0, x<0, x>L

[tex]\pi[/tex] is meant to be just normal, not superscript, sorry

n is an integer

show that <[tex]\hat{x}[/tex]> = L/2




<[tex]\hat{x}[/tex]> is the expectation value of the positional operator [tex]\hat{x}[/tex] right?


[tex]\hat{x}[/tex] [tex]\Psi[/tex]= x [tex]\Psi[/tex] i think so...







[tex]\int[/tex]2x/L sin [tex]^{2}[/tex]([tex]\pi[/tex]2nx/L) dx

Hint: Put everything inside a single tex quote! As in

[tex]\int_0^L ~\frac{2x}{L}~ \sin^{2}(\pi 2 n x / L) dx[/tex]

This seems right (you used the limits to be 0 and L, right?)
Can you show your steps? You must have made a mistake in the integration.
 
ok here goes, i was wary of doing that because, as you can see, that was my first post and it took forever!

sorry that last one should have read:

[tex]\int_0^L ~\frac{2x}{L}~ \sin^{2}(\pi n x / L) dx[/tex] [tex]\int_0^L ~\frac{x}{L}~- ~\frac{x}{L}~ \cos(2 \pi n x / L) dx[/tex]

integrating by parts:

[tex]~\frac{x^{2}}{2L}-(~\frac{x}{L}~~\frac{L}{2n \pi }~\sin(~\frac{2 n \pi x}{L}~)- \int_0^L ~\frac{L}{2 n \pi L}~\sin~\frac{2n \pi x}{L}~dx )[/tex][tex]\left[ ~\frac{x^{2}}{2L}-~\frac{x}{2n \pi}~\sin(~\frac{2 n \pi x}{L}~)- ~\frac{L}{4 n^{2} \pi^{2}}~\cos~\frac{2n \pi x}{L}~ \right][/tex] (between L and 0)

= [tex]~\frac{L}{2}~ - ~\frac{L}{4 n^{2} \pi^{2}}~[/tex]

but it should just be [tex]~\frac{L}{2}~[/tex] ?
 
Last edited:
you have basically worked out the answer, it's just that you forgot that the when zero is put in as a limit in the second part (the cosine part), it gives 1 aswell. i.e. [itex]cos(2 \pi n) = cos(0)[/itex], so the second part that you got disappears, leaving you with just the L/2 which is what you want.

[tex]<x> = ~\frac{L}{2}~ - ~\frac{L}{(2 \pi n)^2}~ + ~\frac{L}{(2 \pi n)^2}~[/tex]
 
Last edited:
ppyadof said:
you have basically worked out the answer, it's just that you forgot that the when zero is put in as a limit in the second part (the cosine part), it gives 1 aswell. i.e. [itex]cos(2 \pi n) = cos(0)[/itex], so the second part that you got disappears, leaving you with just the L/2 which is what you want.

[tex]<x> = ~\frac{L}{2}~ - ~\frac{L}{(2 \pi n)^2}~ + ~\frac{L}{(2 \pi n)^2}~[/tex]

AHHHHHH I've done that so many times, still i haven't learnt, thank you very much, both of you!

nrqed
i read your blog, a few days ago id never done any quantum, they threw us in by asking for the wave function of the 'particle in a box' . It was a steep learning curve that lasted all night and several litres of coffee...got there in the end!
 
UbikPkd said:
AHHHHHH I've done that so many times, still i haven't learnt, thank you very much, both of you!

nrqed
i read your blog, a few days ago id never done any quantum, they threw us in by asking for the wave function of the 'particle in a box' . It was a steep learning curve that lasted all night and several litres of coffee...got there in the end!

That's ok. Only too glad to help. Steep learning curves are the best in the long run, take my word for it :P
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 0 ·
Replies
0
Views
2K
Replies
24
Views
3K
Replies
9
Views
3K
  • · Replies 10 ·
Replies
10
Views
3K
  • · Replies 26 ·
Replies
26
Views
5K
Replies
2
Views
3K
Replies
46
Views
4K
  • · Replies 15 ·
Replies
15
Views
4K
Replies
0
Views
2K