Radiocarbon Dating: Determining Sample Age of 41000-Yrs

  • Thread starter Thread starter blue_lilly
  • Start date Start date
Click For Summary
SUMMARY

The forum discussion centers on calculating the percentage of original carbon-12 atoms remaining in a 41,000-year-old sample using the radiocarbon dating formula (N1/No)=e^-λt. The user initially calculated approximately 1.025% remaining but later corrected their calculation to approximately 0.00702%. The confusion arose from the incorrect interpretation of converting the fraction to a percentage. The correct percentage is derived by multiplying the fraction by 100, not dividing.

PREREQUISITES
  • Understanding of exponential decay and half-life concepts
  • Familiarity with the radiocarbon dating formula (N1/No)=e^-λt
  • Knowledge of natural logarithms (ln) and their application in calculations
  • Basic arithmetic skills for percentage calculations
NEXT STEPS
  • Review the principles of exponential decay in radioactive isotopes
  • Study the derivation and application of the radiocarbon dating formula
  • Learn how to accurately convert fractions to percentages
  • Explore common pitfalls in logarithmic calculations and their implications in scientific contexts
USEFUL FOR

Students studying chemistry, particularly those focusing on radiocarbon dating, as well as educators and professionals in fields requiring precise calculations of radioactive decay and age determination.

blue_lilly
Messages
36
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement


The practical limit to ages that can be determined by radiocarbon dating is about 41000-yr-old sample, what percentage of the original 6 12 C atoms remains?

Homework Equations


(N1/No)=e^-λt

The Attempt at a Solution


Variables:
t = 41,000 yrs
T1/2 of Carbon = 5730 yrs
ln2 = .693

I basically plugged in the numbers and solved because you are given all the variables.
(N1/No)=e^-λt
(N1/No) = e^-(ln2/T1/2)t
(N1/No) = e^-(.693/5730 yrs)(41,000 yrs)
ln(N1/No) = -(.693/5730 yrs)(41,000 yrs)
ln(N1/No) = -(1.2094E-4)(41,000 yrs)
ln(N1/No) = -4.95863
(N1/No) = e^(-4.95863)
(N1/No) = .0102548​

I then calculated for the % because the answer .012548 is a fraction.
.0102548/100 %
=1.025%​

However that answer is incorrect and I'm not exactly sure why. I made sure that I was using the (ln)-function instead of the (log)-function. I don't know if it is my math or if I'm putting it into the website incorrectly.

Any help would be greatly appreciated!
 
Physics news on Phys.org
blue_lilly said:

Homework Statement


The practical limit to ages that can be determined by radiocarbon dating is about 41000-yr-old sample, what percentage of the original 6 12 C atoms remains?

Homework Equations


(N1/No)=e^-λt

The Attempt at a Solution


Variables:
t = 41,000 yrs
T1/2 of Carbon = 5730 yrs
ln2 = .693

I basically plugged in the numbers and solved because you are given all the variables.
(N1/No)=e^-λt
(N1/No) = e^-(ln2/T1/2)t
(N1/No) = e^-(.693/5730 yrs)(41,000 yrs)
ln(N1/No) = -(.693/5730 yrs)(41,000 yrs)
ln(N1/No) = -(1.2094E-4)(41,000 yrs)
ln(N1/No) = -4.95863
(N1/No) = e^(-4.95863)
(N1/No) = .0102548​

I then calculated for the % because the answer .012548 is a fraction.
.0102548/100 %
=1.025%​

However that answer is incorrect and I'm not exactly sure why. I made sure that I was using the (ln)-function instead of the (log)-function. I don't know if it is my math or if I'm putting it into the website incorrectly.

Any help would be greatly appreciated!
I get that e(-4.95863) ≈ 0.00702 .
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: 1 person
SammyS said:
I get that e(-4.95863) ≈ 0.00702 .

You are correct, I must have copied it down wrong.

So then, I would take .00702 and divide by 100 to get the Percentage.

.00702/100 = 7.0225E-5%

This is correct, right?
 
blue_lilly said:
You are correct, I must have copied it down wrong.

So then, I would take .00702 and divide by 100 to get the Percentage.

.00702/100 = 7.0225E-5%

This is correct, right?

Isn't 1/10 equal to 10 % ?

You don't get that by dividing by 100 .
 
SammyS said:
Isn't 1/10 equal to 10 % ?

You don't get that by dividing by 100 .

Where are you getting the 10% from?

I was dividing by 100 because initially you start out with 100% of the material. Or am I incorrect with that idea?
 
blue_lilly said:
Where are you getting the 10% from?

I was dividing by 100 because initially you start out with 100% of the material. Or am I incorrect with that idea?
SammyS was illustrating that diving by 100 does not give the percentage.
What is 0.1 as a percentage? How is it calculated?
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
3K
Replies
3
Views
2K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
2K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
7K