Discussion Overview
The thread discusses the life and contributions of David Jones, particularly his work as the writer of the Daedalus column in Nature and his involvement with perpetual motion machines. Participants share reflections on his legacy, explore his writings, and engage with the concept of perpetual motion in the context of his work.
Discussion Character
- Meta-discussion
- Exploratory
Main Points Raised
- David Jones passed away from prostate cancer, prompting reflections on his contributions to science communication.
- Some participants express interest in exploring archives of Jones's writings, including his columns and articles on various topics.
- One participant mentions a specific perpetual motion machine designed by James Cox, suggesting it was powered by atmospheric pressure, but acknowledges that it does not constitute true perpetual motion.
- Another participant emphasizes that perpetual motion machines are impossible due to the laws of thermodynamics, referring to Jones's creations as "fake" perpetual machines intended to challenge scientific understanding.
- Jones's company, DREADCO, is noted as standing for Daedalus Research Engineering And Development Company, highlighting his innovative spirit.
Areas of Agreement / Disagreement
Participants generally agree on the impossibility of perpetual motion machines and express admiration for David Jones's contributions. However, there are varying levels of familiarity with his work and differing perspectives on the implications of his creations.
Contextual Notes
Some discussions reference specific articles and books related to Jones's work, but there is no consensus on the interpretations of his machines or their significance in the broader context of physics.