RLC series circuit transient response Vc(t) calculation discrepancy

2 replies · 3K views · last reply
gmm
Messages
4
Reaction score
0
9121. Problem
Schematic of a series RLC circuit: a voltage source Vs with a 33Ω resistor, a 120μH inductor and a .01μF capacitor in a loop with ground.

If we assume that the initial voltage, Vs, is equal to zero, and it rises to five volts at t = 0, derive an expression for the voltage across the capacitor as a function of time. That is, calculate Vc(t)

2. Homework Equations
Handwritten-style printed reference table of transient response formulas for series and parallel RLC circuits, covering the underdamped case with D1, D2 and auxiliary relations for alpha, omega 0, omega d, s1 and s2.

this is a series RLC so I'm trying to calculate for Vc(t). Also I used α=R/2L

3. Attempt at solving
L= 120 *10^-6 H
C=0.01 *10^-6 F
R= 33 Ω
ωo=1/√(120*.01*10^-12)=912,870
α=33/(2*120*10^-6)= 137,500
α<ωo ∴ this is under-damped
ωd=√(912,870^2 - 137,500^2)=902,456
D1=(0-5)V... because voltage across capacitor at t=0 is 0V
D2=(0 + 137500[0 - 5])/902456= -0.7618... the current and the voltage through the capacitor at t=0 are both zero, because the inductor does not allow the current to change instantaneously.
With this I built my Total
Vc(t) = e^(-137500t)*(-5cos(902456t) - .7618sin(902456t)) + 5

I then simulated the circuit in Multisim with a square wave voltage source of 0 to 5 V.
the transient analysis shows that when the voltage source goes from 0 to 5V the peak voltage at the capacitor goes up to about 8.5V Here is the plot, and a zoom into the first pulse.
Transient simulation plot titled Design3 Transient, voltage in V against time in s from 0 to 2.0m, showing a blue square-wave-like capacitor voltage between 0 and 5 V with damped ringing and a spike near 8 V at each rising edge.


Multisim transient plot titled Design3 showing voltage against time: a red step rising from 0 to 5 V at t = 0, and a blue underdamped capacitor voltage oscillating above and below 5 V, peaking near 8 V.


The red is the Source voltage and the blue is the capacitor voltage.
when I plot my Vc(t) it does not resemble this, it gives a lower peak capacitor voltage, Did i mess up in some of the parameters?? Am I missing something?
Desmos graph of a decaying oscillation approaching 5, with a peak of about 8.098 at t = 3.481×10^-6 s, then damped swings around 5 out to 4.5×10^-5 s.


Attached Files:
 
Your calculated plot looks fine to me. I'd be more dubious abut the Multisim accuracy. Simulators are great tools but you need to be a bit careful with them when dealing with high speed transients. See if you can find a simulator menu where you can specify the maximum simulation time step size and play with the value a bit. See what effect it has on the waveform peaks.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: donpacino
gneill said:
Your calculated plot looks fine to me. I'd be more dubious abut the Multisim accuracy. Simulators are great tools but you need to be a bit careful with them when dealing with high speed transients. See if you can find a simulator menu where you can specify the maximum simulation time step size and play with the value a bit. See what effect it has on the waveform peaks.
Ah yes. I adjusted my time step size and re-simulated now it's pretty much identical to my model. Thanks qneill