Discussion Overview
The discussion revolves around the salaries of physicists, particularly focusing on academic positions versus industry roles. Participants share personal experiences and statistics regarding compensation at various stages of an academic career, as well as insights into salaries in different fields related to physics and engineering.
Discussion Character
- Exploratory
- Technical explanation
- Debate/contested
- Mathematical reasoning
Main Points Raised
- Some participants suggest that a university researcher can expect to earn $18-20k during their PhD years, followed by $35-50k as a postdoc, and potentially $50-90k in a tenure-track position.
- Others argue that salaries can vary significantly based on the institution and field, with some postdocs earning as much as $70k in high-demand areas.
- Concerns are raised about the typical academic salary structure being based on 9-month contracts, which may not reflect total annual earnings when summer work is considered.
- Statistics from NYU indicate mean salaries for full, associate, and assistant professors, prompting discussions about how these figures may be skewed by disciplines like law and medicine.
- Some participants challenge the reported salaries, citing different figures from Canadian universities, suggesting that assistant professors there earn more than their American counterparts.
- Insights into industry salaries reveal that physics PhDs in finance can earn over $150k, while those in statistics or programming may earn between $70-120k.
- Participants note that many professors in engineering also engage in consulting or have side companies, significantly increasing their total income.
- There is mention of petroleum engineers earning high salaries, particularly when involved in consulting for oil companies.
Areas of Agreement / Disagreement
Participants express a range of views on salary figures, with no consensus on specific numbers. There are competing perspectives on the accuracy of reported salaries and the impact of different fields and institutions on compensation.
Contextual Notes
Discussions include references to various salary sources, and participants highlight the importance of considering factors such as location, institution type, and additional income from consulting or summer work.
Who May Find This Useful
Individuals interested in pursuing a career in physics or related fields, those considering academic versus industry roles, and anyone looking for insights into salary expectations in STEM disciplines.