"Shaggy Dog Stories" relevant to "Cartoon Physics"

  • News
  • Thread starter Bystander
  • Start date
  • Tags
    Physics
In summary, the conversation revolves around the concept of open and closed systems and how it relates to the weight of objects. The speaker shares an anecdote about a bagger at a grocery store who believes that inflating bags of vegetables with air will result in a lighter weight on the scale. The speaker tries to explain that this is not the case, but the bagger remains adamant. The conversation highlights the importance of understanding the principles of open and closed systems and avoiding falling for misconceptions.
  • #1
Bystander
Science Advisor
Homework Helper
Gold Member
5,588
1,702
e.g., the pet store/livestock delivery truck driver who avoids being ticketed for driving an overweight vehicle by hitting the side of his closed van periodically to keep the canaries/parakeets/chickens/turkeys airborne.

https://www.physicsforums.com/threads/sailboats-providing-their-own-wind.980139/
This is an endeavor to define the nature of "open/closed" systems, and, perhaps, to winkle out some of the semantic pitfalls I apparently waded into. I'll leave this open for a month or so to accumulate "folklore/anecdotes and wisdom/comments."
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
While purchasing ingredients for vegetable soup from the grocery store, I carefully sealed each plastic bag by twisting and tying the open edges resulting in a minor air cushion. As the cashier was weighing each bag the bagger stuck her grubby fingers through the side of each bag realeasing the slight air cushion while loudly declaiming nonsense about seniors stealing from the grocer.

Nearly tongue-tied from this display of stupidity, bad manners and poor hygiene; I attempted to explain that the air in the bag of vegetables did not affect the scales. I tried to get the cashier and bagger to at least conduct an experiment and weigh the puffy bags before and after deflation. No go. Bagger was adamant that the slightly puffy bags would float, lighter-than-air like helium balloons, resulting in a lower scale reading. 'Pop!'

Bagger-girl fighting imagined crime one plastic bag at a time. What should you believe: your lying eyes showing no change on the scale after deflation; or some hare-brained crackpot 'theory' that a bag of vegetables weighs less when inflated with surrounding air?
 
  • Like
  • Wow
Likes Hornbein, hmmm27, Bystander and 1 other person

What is a shaggy dog story?

A shaggy dog story is a type of joke or humorous story that is long, meandering, and often anticlimactic. It usually involves a series of events or elaborate set-up that leads to a seemingly important or interesting conclusion, only to end with an unexpected and often silly punchline.

How do shaggy dog stories relate to cartoon physics?

Shaggy dog stories often incorporate elements of exaggeration and absurdity, which are key components of cartoon physics. In cartoons, physical laws are often stretched or ignored for comedic effect, and shaggy dog stories use similar techniques to create humor.

What makes a shaggy dog story funny?

The humor in a shaggy dog story comes from the unexpected and often ridiculous twist at the end. It also relies on the build-up and anticipation created by the long and meandering story, making the punchline even more surprising and amusing.

Are there any famous examples of shaggy dog stories in cartoons?

Yes, there are many famous examples of shaggy dog stories in cartoons. One well-known example is the Road Runner and Wile E. Coyote cartoons, where Wile E. Coyote's elaborate plans to catch the Road Runner always end in failure and often with a humorous twist.

Why are shaggy dog stories popular?

Shaggy dog stories have been around for centuries and continue to be popular because they offer a break from reality and allow people to laugh at the absurdity of everyday life. They also require a certain level of intelligence and understanding of humor to appreciate, making them appealing to a wide range of audiences.

Back
Top