Sailboats providing their own wind

  • #1
2
6

Summary:

If you aimed a fan on a boat at its own sails, could it blow the boat forward?
I happened to be watching this cartoon and this one scene seriously bothered me...


This... just feels like it wouldn't be a workable solution. Am I wrong?

I can't say I perfectly understand how fans or propellers work, but I would imagine that by pushing air or water in one direction, equal force is created in the opposite direction for the base. Thus how a boat moves forward by pushing water back, or a plane moves forward by pushing air back...

In this case, pushing air forward towards a sail should push the boat backward, and the sail catching that created air-current should then counteract that, creating forward force roughly evening things out and keeping the boat stationary.

Am I wrong? When stuff like this is done under the masquerade of an educational series I can't help but wonder if they might be trying to troll adults who watch this or get them pestered by angry kids who can't make it work.
 
  • Like
Likes scottdave, atyy, OmCheeto and 2 others

Answers and Replies

  • #2
Bystander
Science Advisor
Homework Helper
Gold Member
5,203
1,225
Your intuition is correct; Wile E. Coyote has done extensive research on "cartoon physics."
 
  • Like
Likes DaveE, davenn, sysprog and 2 others
  • #3
anorlunda
Staff Emeritus
Insights Author
9,135
6,120
No. Your question borders on perpetual motion, but it is not PMM if the fan is powered by batteries.

But again no. The fan's wind on the sails would produce a forward thrust, but the fan blade would produce a reverse thrust. Think of the fan like the propeller on a single engine airplane, but this propeller blows in the wrong direction for forward thrust.

Saying it again with other words, if you hang a parachute behind a propeller airplane, it will not fly backwards.
 
  • Like
Likes hutchphd and phinds
  • #4
A.T.
Science Advisor
11,024
2,491
...roughly evening things out and keeping the boat stationary...
The key word here being "roughly". Depending on how the sail is shaped the boat can go forward, but it's not as efficient, as just using the propeller.

 
  • Like
  • Informative
Likes scottdave, atyy, tech99 and 5 others
  • #5
Bystander
Science Advisor
Homework Helper
Gold Member
5,203
1,225
how the sail is shaped the boat can go forward, but it's not as efficient, as just using the propeller.
"Balloon" does not equal "propeller."
 
  • Like
Likes davenn
  • #6
A.T.
Science Advisor
11,024
2,491
"Balloon" does not equal "propeller."
Did you watch the whole video before replying? Go to 4:00 min.
 
  • Like
Likes Dale
  • #7
Bystander
Science Advisor
Homework Helper
Gold Member
5,203
1,225
Don't have to; delta P goes from non-zero before to zero after; ergo movement. A fan/propeller starts from delta P equals zero and ends at delta P equals zero; ergo no movement.
 
  • Sad
Likes DEvens and hutchphd
  • #8
DaveC426913
Gold Member
19,178
2,674
It can be done in theory, using a principle known as entrainment.

Even though the fan is attached to the boat, and pushes back with equal force, the air is viscous, and carries some air next to it along for the ride. You can get a little forward motion (if you angle the sail right), but its very inefficient.

It does not violate conservation of energy, since, after all, you are adding energy into the system, by whatever powers the fan. And it doesn't violate Newton;s Laws of motion because it's not a closed system.

This has been demonstrated.
 
  • Like
Likes OmCheeto and sysprog
  • #9
A.T.
Science Advisor
11,024
2,491
  • Like
Likes nasu and Dale
  • #10
2,076
457
A fan/propeller starts from delta P equals zero and ends at delta P equals zero; ergo no movement.
Does a jet engine counts as a fan? Than google for thrust reversal. A sail can do this job as well (but it is very ineficcient).
 
  • Like
Likes atyy, vanhees71, anorlunda and 2 others
  • #11
A.T.
Science Advisor
11,024
2,491
It can be done in theory, using a principle known as entrainment.
It's much simpler. Replace the sail with a board, and let the passenger collect balls from the ground and throw them at the board, so they bounce off and leave with backwards momentum. The boat gets the opposite forward momentum.
 
  • Like
Likes tech99, hmmm27 and sysprog
  • #12
DaveC426913
Gold Member
19,178
2,674
It's much simpler.
Sure, but that's not the ask.
 
  • #13
Bystander
Science Advisor
Homework Helper
Gold Member
5,203
1,225
The boat gets the opposite forward momentum.
..., after losing momentum to the ground as the passenger scoops them up; net zero.
 
  • #14
950
418
I think you may be missing the point. It is supposed to be instantly recognizable as impossible. That’s why it’s funny when it works. It’s exactly like a cartoon character picking themselves up by their bootstraps.
 
  • Like
Likes russ_watters and Bystander
  • #15
Ibix
Science Advisor
Insights Author
2020 Award
7,396
6,480
..., after losing momentum to the ground as the passenger scoops them up; net zero.
Not if the ball is rolling backwards after it lands. The ball has a acquired negative momentum from somewhere.
 
  • #16
Bystander
Science Advisor
Homework Helper
Gold Member
5,203
1,225
negative momentum from somewhere.
..., and that would be...?
 
  • #17
Ibix
Science Advisor
Insights Author
2020 Award
7,396
6,480
..., and that would be...?
The only other entity in the experiment is the boat, so the boat's forward momentum must have increased. What else could it be?
 
  • #18
Bystander
Science Advisor
Homework Helper
Gold Member
5,203
1,225
so the boat's forward momentum must have increased. What else could it be?
Bootstrap violation of "conservation of momentum?"
 
  • #19
1,961
1,194
Does a jet engine counts as a fan? Than google for thrust reversal. A sail can do this job as well (but it is very ineficcient).
My Daddy taught his kids enough about tacking into the wind -- having the wind blowing full face opposite against your intended direction is very pleasing when it's compared to being becalmed --

"Water, water, every where,
And all the boards did shrink;
Water, water, every where,
Nor any drop to drink."

From The Rime of Ancient Mariner, by Samuel Taylor Coleridge
 
  • Like
Likes Nik_2213
  • #20
Dale
Mentor
Insights Author
2020 Award
30,852
7,454
Myth busters did this:
 
  • Like
Likes tech99, russ_watters, OmCheeto and 2 others
  • #21
1,961
1,194
Here's a video of someone displaying a method by which a fan can be employed to propel a boat, which method is not as ludicrous as trying to impel a sail with a not-especially-dissimilar fan . . .

 
  • #23
jbriggs444
Science Advisor
Homework Helper
9,580
4,242
Thought this had been discussed previously; guess the provoking cartoon was Finding Nemo.
It's an open system. The air enters, is pushed by fan, is pushed by sail and exits. It need not exit at zero velocity. Hence thrust reversers as have been mentioned already.
 
  • Like
Likes hutchphd
  • #24
A.T.
Science Advisor
11,024
2,491
... net zero.
The balls end up moving backward.
The boat ends up moving forward.
The net momentum is zero.

Bootstrap violation of "conservation of momentum?"
The boats movement here is a consequence of conservation of momentum, not a violation.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Likes cjl and nasu
  • #25
tech99
Gold Member
2,023
735
However, if you have a windmill on a boat, driving a water propeller, it can push the boat against the wind.
 
  • Like
Likes Nik_2213

Related Threads on Sailboats providing their own wind

  • Last Post
Replies
3
Views
2K
Replies
21
Views
6K
Replies
4
Views
5K
Replies
3
Views
2K
  • Last Post
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • Last Post
Replies
5
Views
10K
  • Last Post
2
Replies
43
Views
19K
  • Last Post
Replies
5
Views
841
Replies
3
Views
2K
Replies
1
Views
2K
Top