Should I Retake Physics 1 Before Taking Physics 2 After Learning Calculus?

[C5F8576]

Hi,

I took algebra-based Physics 1 (classical mechanics). I have taken up to Calc 2 and Linear Algebra, and I was wondering if it's ok to move on to calc-based Physics 2 (electromagnetism) or if I should take calc-based Physics 1.

I intend to major in physics and received an A- in Physics 1. My GPA is important to me as is having a strong foundation for upper level courses. Please advise.

 

[symbolipoint]

I took algebra-based Physics 1 (classical mechanics). I have taken up to Calc 2 and Linear Algebra, and I was wondering if it's ok to move on to calc-based Physics 2 (electromagnetism) or if I should take calc-based Physics 1.

The correct alternative is enter the course for Calculus-based Physics 1.

 

[Frabjous]

Calc based physics 1. The calculus approach is how physicists actually solve the problems so you need it for a proper foundation.

 

[CrysPhys]

Hi,

I took algebra-based Physics 1 (classical mechanics). I have taken up to Calc 2 and Linear Algebra, and I was wondering if it's ok to move on to calc-based Physics 2 (electromagnetism) or if I should take calc-based Physics 1.

I intend to major in physics and received an A- in Physics 1. My GPA is important to me as is having a strong foundation for upper level courses. Please advise.

Definitely calculus-based Physics 1. It is de rigeur as a strong foundation for upper level physics courses; and, since you've already been exposed to basic physics principles in algebra-based Physics 1 and have already completed Calculus 2, you should be well positioned to do better with respect to grades as well; hence, satisfying both of your goals.

But please clarify your situation. Are you a transfer student who took algebra-based Physics I at a different school (such as community college)? But if not, and you take both algebra-based Physics I and calculus-based Physics I at the same school, can you get credit for both? Did you decide on becoming a physics major only after taking algebra-based Physics I (otherwise, why didn't you take the calculus-based Physics I at the start)?

 

[vela]

I don't think you really have a choice here. Passing calculus-based Physics I is normally a pre-requisite for calculus-based Physics II. I doubt the school will let you enroll in Physics II.

 

[Vanadium 50]

I agree - you probably don't have a choice.
You also may run into the problem that your school will not let you take both courses for credit. In that case, I would recommend auditing Calc-based Physics 1 before taking Physics 2, (If that option is available)