(simple Q) Cutting yourself with substances on your skin.

  • Thread starter Thread starter Liokh
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Cutting Skin
Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around the effects of water and other substances on the skin's susceptibility to cuts when handling knives, particularly in the context of washing dishes. Participants explore the physics and biology behind skin structure and how moisture influences its integrity and vulnerability to incisions.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Technical explanation
  • Conceptual clarification
  • Debate/contested

Main Points Raised

  • One participant hypothesizes that water softens the skin, making it more fragile and easier to cut, while also suggesting that water molecules might deflect the blade.
  • Another participant questions the assumption that water molecules would deflect the blade, prompting further examination of the hypothesis.
  • A different viewpoint suggests that denser materials are generally harder to cut, but acknowledges that if water reduces the skin's structural integrity, it could make cutting easier.
  • One participant provides a detailed explanation of skin composition, noting that the outer layer consists of keratinized cells and that washing with soap removes natural oils, potentially increasing susceptibility to cuts due to osmotic effects that inflate skin cells.
  • This participant argues that the combination of water and soap may further compromise the skin's resistance to mechanical damage.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants express differing views on the role of water and its effects on skin integrity, with no consensus reached on the mechanisms involved or the implications of these effects.

Contextual Notes

There are unresolved assumptions regarding the interaction between water, skin structure, and cutting dynamics. The discussion also highlights the complexity of skin biology and the influence of various substances on its properties.

Liokh
Messages
9
Reaction score
0
I am looking for an explanation about a simple physics phenomen.

When washing plates and ustensils, I would manipulate knives and, from times to times, would cut myself a bit. Does it matter if your hands are wet or dry and what does the water do on the surface of the skin that can influence the blade to make or not an incision in your skin.

My remark is that water soften your skin and makes it more fragile therefore it should be easyer to cut it. My hypothesis is that by making it soft, the water protects the skin by filling holes and makes the skin more difficult to be cut since the water molecules will have a tendency to deflect the blade. What's the real explanation of that daily experience ? What changes with other substances ? Which makes it easyer or thougher to cut ?

P.S: Sorry if this is posted on the wrong forum
 
Biology news on Phys.org
What makes you think that water molecules will deflect the blade?
 
something that is more dense will generaly be harder to cut(i think), but if the water reduces the structure in our skin, then it might make it easier. like diamonds are very dense with C, but also have a very strong structure.
 
Liokh said:
I am looking for an explanation about a simple physics phenomen.

When washing plates and ustensils, I would manipulate knives and, from times to times, would cut myself a bit. Does it matter if your hands are wet or dry and what does the water do on the surface of the skin that can influence the blade to make or not an incision in your skin.

My remark is that water soften your skin and makes it more fragile therefore it should be easyer to cut it. My hypothesis is that by making it soft, the water protects the skin by filling holes and makes the skin more difficult to be cut since the water molecules will have a tendency to deflect the blade. What's the real explanation of that daily experience ? What changes with other substances ? Which makes it easyer or thougher to cut ?

P.S: Sorry if this is posted on the wrong forum

The surface of our skin is composed of 15 to 30 layers of Keratinized cells. Basically a layer of dead cells filled with keratin. The maintenance of this layer depends on oils secreted from the sebaceous gland. When you are washing dishes you are using an emulsifier (soap) which washes away the oil on your skin. Another Factor to consider is that skin is water resistant, not water proof. So when you immerse your skin in fresh water, eventually osmotic forces may cause water to move into the epidermis(skin), which makes the cells get inflated like ballons. Since the cells are swollen, the membranes of the cells are not as flexible and are more likely to burst if pressure is applied to the membrane. So I am assuming skin is more susceptible to mechanical damage (cuts by knives) when immersed in water. When you add soap into the picture, I think skin would be even more susceptible to mechanical damage, since your washing off the oils, which maintain the skin cells.
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
3K
  • · Replies 19 ·
Replies
19
Views
10K