Solve 3D Force Systems Homework | F_A, F_B & F_C

  • Thread starter Thread starter sami23
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    3d Force Systems
Click For Summary
SUMMARY

The discussion focuses on solving a 3D force system involving tensions in cables supporting a bucket with a weight of 17.5 lb. The key equations derived from the system include three force equilibrium equations: 0.74483F_DA - 0.4826F_DC = 0, -0.2643F_DA - F_DB + 0.52834F_DC = 0, and 0.61269F_DA + 0.74448F_DC - 17.5 = 0. The user initially calculated tensions F_DA = 44.1 lb, F_DB = 28.6 lb, and F_DC = 15.7 lb but received feedback indicating a potential typo in their calculations. The discussion emphasizes the importance of careful equation setup and verification in solving for unknown forces.

PREREQUISITES
  • Understanding of vector forces in three dimensions
  • Familiarity with equilibrium equations in statics
  • Knowledge of unit vectors and their calculations
  • Proficiency in algebraic manipulation for solving systems of equations
NEXT STEPS
  • Review the principles of static equilibrium in 3D systems
  • Learn about vector decomposition and unit vector calculations
  • Practice solving systems of linear equations using substitution and elimination methods
  • Explore common errors in force analysis and how to avoid them
USEFUL FOR

Students studying engineering mechanics, particularly those focusing on statics and force systems, as well as educators looking for examples of problem-solving in 3D force analysis.

sami23
Messages
69
Reaction score
1

Homework Statement


A system of cables supports a bucket. The dimensions in the figure are as follows: x_1 = 4.80 ft, x_2 = 1.70 ft, y_1 = 1.10 ft, y_2 = 3.30 ft, z_1 = 2.55 ft, and z_2 = 3.10 ft. If the bucket and its contents have a combined weight of W_1 = 17.5 lb, determine F_A, F_B, and F_C, the tensions in cable segments DA, DB, and DC, respectively.

Homework Equations


vec_F = F(unit vector)
unit vector = vec_r / |r|
\SigmaF = 0
F_DA + F_DB + F_DC + W = 0

The Attempt at a Solution


coordinates: A(4.8,0,2.55) B(1.7,0,0) C(0,3.3,3.10) D(1.7,1.1,0)

r_DA = [(4.8-1.7)i +(0-1.1)j + (2.55-0)k] / \sqrt{(3.1^2+1.1^2+2.55^2)}
vec_F_DA = F_DA [0.74483i -0.2643j + 0.61269k]

r_DB = [(1.7-1.7)i +(0-1.1)j + (0-0)k] / \sqrt{(1.1^2)}
vec_F_DB = F_DB [-1j]

r_DC = [(0-1.7)i +(3.33-1.1)j + (3.1-0)k] / \sqrt{(1.7^2+2.2^2+3.1^2)}
vec_F_DC = F_DC [-0.40826i + 0.52834j +0.74448k]

In the end... my 3 equations with the Foces unknown:
1.) 0.74483F_DA - 0.4826F_DC = 0
2.) -0.2643F_DA - F_DB +0.52834F_DC = 0
3.) 0.61269F_DA + 0.74448F_DC - 17.5 = 0

I solved for F_DA in 1.) and substituted F_DC in 3.) and using back substitution in 2.) I got:
F_DA = 44.1 lb
F_DB = 28.6 lb
F_DC = 15.7 lb

but it was wrong. What am I doing wrong?
 

Attachments

  • bucket.jpeg
    bucket.jpeg
    7.3 KB · Views: 859
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
Hello Sami23,
sami23 said:
In the end... my 3 equations with the Foces unknown:
1.) 0.74483F_DA - 0.4826F_DC = 0
2.) -0.2643F_DA - F_DB +0.52834F_DC = 0
3.) 0.61269F_DA + 0.74448F_DC - 17.5 = 0
Check the number above in red. It's a 'typo' of some sort.
I solved for F_DA in 1.) and substituted F_DC in 3.) and using back substitution in 2.) I got:
F_DA = 44.1 lb
F_DB = 28.6 lb
F_DC = 15.7 lb
But in both cases, with or without the typo, I'm not coming up with same solution as you. Show us your work on how you found the tensions.