Solve Enjoyable Enigmas with Mr.E's Challenge
- Thread starter Enigman
- Start date
Join the discussion
Registration is free. Ask a follow-up in this thread, or start your own.
1,043 replies · 213K views
Physics news on Phys.org
zoobyshoe
- 6,514
- 1,255
I fit that description, and it took a long time before I saw it. You're just very number-minded.
zoobyshoe
- 6,514
- 1,255
Even easier, but I found it fun:
Magic Nines
"Each digit from 1 to 9 is used only once. The first and second row of digits are added to obtain the sum in the bottom row.
Rearrange these digits in seven similar boxes so that the sum increases each time by nine. More than one solution is possible."
(I suggest putting lower digits on top.)
Magic Nines
"Each digit from 1 to 9 is used only once. The first and second row of digits are added to obtain the sum in the bottom row.
Rearrange these digits in seven similar boxes so that the sum increases each time by nine. More than one solution is possible."
(I suggest putting lower digits on top.)
Attachments
Enigman
- 647
- 311
That would work...zoobyshoe said:Are you suggesting blowing into one end of the straw while you try and push the other end into the spud?
may work but wholly unnecessary...collinsmark said:Hmm.
This might work, maybe. It reminds me of a trick one can use to make a straw pop pretty loud when snapped with a finger (that process destroys the straw). Anyway, here's a modification of that, that might instead work for this one.
But I have not tried this due to temporary lack of straws and potatoes. It's just a guess.
o Take the straw and bend it in the middle.
o Twist each end around so there is a noticeable, sharp, bend/twist thing around in the middle. Be careful though, you don't want to twist so much that it compromises the straw's integrity.
o Keeping the twist in place, hold one end of the straw between a pair of fingers or between a finger and thumb (the finger and thumb is probably easier).
o Do the same with the the other end of the straw and the other hand.
o Pinch both ends of the straw at all times.
o Move both hands in a circular motion with a axis parallel to left and right. The goal is to place twists on both ends of the straw to trap the air inside. If done right, you should be able to feel the straw bulge a little bit in the middle parts, due to the trapped air.
o Don't twist so much that the straw bursts though. Just inflate it enough so it resists bending.
o Bring your hands together, causing the inflated parts of the straw to bend in half. Now there are two inflated parts of the straw with a sharp bend in the middle.
o Use the sharp bend in the middle to impale the potato. This might take a bit of a balancing act to keep the potato from rolling out from under the straw. It also might require chipping/drilling away at the potato skin at first, perhaps with the sharper "bend" in the straw, just to get a divot going that can then be used to ease the process potato goring.
o Once the straw has sufficiently skewered the potato, perhaps it will hold tight enough to lift the potato?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8Ewpwylbxec
consciousness
- 132
- 13
Monks With Eye Problems PART 2-
There is an island of monks where everyone has either brown eyes or red eyes. Monks who have red eyes are cursed, and are supposed to commit suicide at midnight. However, no one ever talks about what color eyes they have, because the monks have a vow of silence. Also, there are no reflective surfaces on the whole island. Thus, no one knows their own eye color; they can only see the eye colors of other people, and not say anything about them. Life goes on, with brown-eyed monks and red-eyed monks living happily together in peace, and no one ever committing suicide.
These monks will believe anything others say, as long as it isn't certain that they are lying.
Then one day a greedy and evil logician comes to the island. He recognizes that this system is very unstable and decides to take advantage of it. He wants the entire island to himself, but he knows that if he speaks an obvious lie the monks will kill him.
Think of a statement he can make to get all of the monks on the island to kill themselves as quickly as possible.
-------------------------------
This is much harder than the first because there we had to find the consequences of a statement while here we have to make the statement. I suggest trying the first one before this(its on page 35).
There is an island of monks where everyone has either brown eyes or red eyes. Monks who have red eyes are cursed, and are supposed to commit suicide at midnight. However, no one ever talks about what color eyes they have, because the monks have a vow of silence. Also, there are no reflective surfaces on the whole island. Thus, no one knows their own eye color; they can only see the eye colors of other people, and not say anything about them. Life goes on, with brown-eyed monks and red-eyed monks living happily together in peace, and no one ever committing suicide.
These monks will believe anything others say, as long as it isn't certain that they are lying.
Then one day a greedy and evil logician comes to the island. He recognizes that this system is very unstable and decides to take advantage of it. He wants the entire island to himself, but he knows that if he speaks an obvious lie the monks will kill him.
Think of a statement he can make to get all of the monks on the island to kill themselves as quickly as possible.
-------------------------------
This is much harder than the first because there we had to find the consequences of a statement while here we have to make the statement. I suggest trying the first one before this(its on page 35).
zoobyshoe
- 6,514
- 1,255
Probably not, now that I see how it's done. You need some momentum.Enigman said:That would work...
consciousness
- 132
- 13
consciousness said:Monks With Eye Problems PART 2-
There is an island of monks where everyone has either brown eyes or red eyes. Monks who have red eyes are cursed, and are supposed to commit suicide at midnight. However, no one ever talks about what color eyes they have, because the monks have a vow of silence. Also, there are no reflective surfaces on the whole island. Thus, no one knows their own eye color; they can only see the eye colors of other people, and not say anything about them. Life goes on, with brown-eyed monks and red-eyed monks living happily together in peace, and no one ever committing suicide.
These monks will believe anything others say, as long as it isn't certain that they are lying.
Then one day a greedy and evil logician comes to the island. He recognizes that this system is very unstable and decides to take advantage of it. He wants the entire island to himself, but he knows that if he speaks an obvious lie the monks will kill him.
Think of a statement he can make to get all of the monks on the island to kill themselves as quickly as possible.
-------------------------------
This is much harder than the first because there we had to find the consequences of a statement while here we have to make the statement. I suggest trying the first one before this(its on page 35).
Clarification- The logician can go away making the statement and come back later to find an empty island. The main thing is that the monks shouldn't immediately realize that he was lying.
consciousness
- 132
- 13
This is too hard so I will provide some help.
How to start with the problem-
How to proceed with it-
How to start with the problem-
Suppose that there are n Red Eyed Monks(REM) and m Blue Eyed Monks(BEM).
Now, every REM knows that there are either (n-1) or n REMs and correspondingly m or (m+1) BEMs.
Every BEM knows that there are either m or (m-1) BEMs and correspondingly n or (n+1) REMs.
Now, every REM knows that there are either (n-1) or n REMs and correspondingly m or (m+1) BEMs.
Every BEM knows that there are either m or (m-1) BEMs and correspondingly n or (n+1) REMs.
How to proceed with it-
The tricky part is to convince a BEM that he is a REM without saying an obvious lie. In most solutions a REM can infer that he is a REM when a BEM kills himself.
There two ways to do this- Imply that there are (m-1) BEMs or that there are (n+1) REMs.
We have to imply it in such a way that REMs can't immediately know that we are lying.
For example- "There are (m-1) BEMs" and "There are (n+1) REMs" don't work.
Now all you need is a stroke of insight!
There two ways to do this- Imply that there are (m-1) BEMs or that there are (n+1) REMs.
We have to imply it in such a way that REMs can't immediately know that we are lying.
For example- "There are (m-1) BEMs" and "There are (n+1) REMs" don't work.
Now all you need is a stroke of insight!
consciousness
- 132
- 13
Did I kill this thread? 
The answer was-

The answer was-
"The number of REMs is odd" if n is even or "The number of REMs is even" if n is odd. Similar thing with the number of BEMs also works.
Enigman
- 647
- 311
Hang on or Let Go?
A painter (you) is high up on a ladder, painting a house, when unfortunately the ladder starts to fall over from the vertical. What to do:
let go of the ladder right away and fall to the ground, or hang on to the ladder all the way to the ground?
A painter (you) is high up on a ladder, painting a house, when unfortunately the ladder starts to fall over from the vertical. What to do:
let go of the ladder right away and fall to the ground, or hang on to the ladder all the way to the ground?
zoobyshoe
- 6,514
- 1,255
Enigman said:A painter (you) is high up on a ladder, painting a house, when unfortunately the ladder starts to fall over from the vertical. What to do:
let go of the ladder right away and fall to the ground, or hang on to the ladder all the way to the ground?
Under the circumstances, the tip of the ladder will be going faster than the velocity of its center of gravity when it hits the ground. So, your best bet is to let go.
On the other hand, I just realized that you holding onto the ladder creates a thing with a different center of gravity than the ladder alone, so I'm not sure which way gets you injured less.
Enigman
- 647
- 311
Correct.zoobyshoe said:Under the circumstances, the tip of the ladder will be going faster than the velocity of its center of gravity when it hits the ground. So, your best bet is to let go.
This was used in a psychological study:
You are given with the following task: how to fix a lit candle on a wall (a cork board) in a way so the candle wax won't drip onto the table below. To do so, one may only use the following along with the candle:
- a book of matches
- a box of thumbtacks
zoobyshoe
- 6,514
- 1,255
Only if you are massless, I think. See my second spoiler above.Enigman said:Correct.
Edit after more thinking: Yes, by holding onto the ladder you are shifting its (the human-ladder system's) COG up and retarding the descent of the tip. The ladder, though, is shifting your COG down, such that it is still slightly better to let go of it.
Last edited:
Enigman
- 647
- 311
Oh dear, did I give my answer away too soon?
The total impact energy is going to be the potential energy at the start. So either you absorb the impact of both masses or just one mass. The most elegant solution however is to try and slide down the ladder reducing the impact to minimal
drizzle
Gold Member
- 202
- 58
Enigman said:Correct.
This was used in a psychological study:
You are given with the following task: how to fix a lit candle on a wall (a cork board) in a way so the candle wax won't drip onto the table below. To do so, one may only use the following along with the candle:
- a book of matches
- a box of thumbtacks
Psychological study you say... Now I'm afraid to give my answer.
Pin the candle totally perpendicular to the wall using the thumbtacks and then lit it. Oh just do it under the table surface' level, so the wax won't drip on it. 
Enigman
- 647
- 311
Gad said:Psychological study you say... Now I'm afraid to give my answer.
Pin the candle totally perpendicular to the wall using the thumbtacks and then lit it. Oh just do it under the table surface' level, so the wax won't drip on it.
Won't work, wax is too soft and the candle will just fall down, roll towards the legs of the table and set the table on fire.

drizzle
Gold Member
- 202
- 58
Enigman said:Won't work, wax is too soft and the candle will just fall down, roll towards the legs of the table and set the table on fire.
![]()
Fine then, use the matches to form two words 'LIT CANDLE' and pin them on the wall using the thumbtacks.
zoobyshoe
- 6,514
- 1,255
Didn't you already post this candle enigma?
drizzle
Gold Member
- 202
- 58
Did he?... *checks the previous enigmas*
zoobyshoe
- 6,514
- 1,255
It seems familiar, but I can't find it. Anyway...
If the thumb tack box were suitably shaped, I would try pinning it to the corkboard from the inside, sticking out like a little shelf, and put the candle on it.
drizzle
Gold Member
- 202
- 58
I KNEW the box thing has to do something here.
Enigman
- 647
- 311
zoobyshoe said:Didn't you already post this candle enigma?
Nope, but it's pretty popular with self-help authors.
Follow these steps and see if you can figure this out.
1) Get a brown, cardboard box.
2) Get purple, orange, and turquoise paints.
3) Paint the box orange.
4) Paint on purple spots.
5) Paint on turquoise stripes.
7) Turn it upside down.
8) Lie on your side.
What is missing from this sequence?
zoobyshoe
- 6,514
- 1,255
Enigman said:What is missing from this sequence?
Step # 6
zoobyshoe
- 6,514
- 1,255
Here's what I was saying about the ladder:
Video:
[Youtube]BV7TPvk__kE[/youtube]
Explanation:
http://www.darylscience.com/Demos/Faster g.html
Video:
[Youtube]BV7TPvk__kE[/youtube]
Explanation:
http://www.darylscience.com/Demos/Faster g.html
Get a film clip of a falling industrial chimney. This is the explanation of why they snap in half BEFORE they hit the ground. At the chimney begine to topple over, it's center of mass accelerates at 10m/s2. This, however, tries to force the TOP of the chimney to accelerate FASTER than 'g'! This causes tremendous strain on the structure and it crumbles on the way down. Cool!
Jonathan Scott
Gold Member
- 2,358
- 1,272
Enigman said:Oh dear, did I give my answer away too soon?
The total impact energy is going to be the potential energy at the start. So either you absorb the impact of both masses or just one mass. The most elegant solution however is to try and slide down the ladder reducing the impact to minimal
Yep, I can confirm that sometimes works!
zoobyshoe
- 6,514
- 1,255
After two days I still haven't the faintest idea. Need a clue.Enigman said:Follow these steps and see if you can figure this out.
1) Get a brown, cardboard box.
2) Get purple, orange, and turquoise paints.
3) Paint the box orange.
4) Paint on purple spots.
5) Paint on turquoise stripes.
7) Turn it upside down.
8) Lie on your side.
What is missing from this sequence?
Enigman
- 647
- 311
zoobyshoe said:After two days I still haven't the faintest idea. Need a clue.
You already answered it...
Another psych enigma
You are given 2 cords hanging from the ceiling, and a plier. You must connect the cords, but they are just far enough apart that one cannot reach the other easily.
zoobyshoe
- 6,514
- 1,255
WOW! I was authentically just being a wise-***!Enigman said:You already answered it...
![]()
You must confirm or deny, or no one really knows what sort of answer is required.
zoobyshoe
- 6,514
- 1,255
I have seen this one before, so I'll recuse myself. I bet Gad can answer this one.Enigman said:You already answered it...
Another psych enigma
You are given 2 cords hanging from the ceiling, and a plier. You must connect the cords, but they are just far enough apart that one cannot reach the other easily.
drizzle
Gold Member
- 202
- 58
zoobyshoe said:I have seen this one before, so I'll recuse myself. I bet Gad can answer this one.
Cut the cords with the plier then tie them together? 
Similar threads
High School Enjoyable Enigmas #2: Who Wins the Matchstick Game?
- Enigman
- · Replies 7 ·
- General Math
- Replies
- 7