Solve Quadratic Equation Q1: x^2+4x-5=0

Click For Summary

Homework Help Overview

The discussion revolves around solving a quadratic equation, specifically x^2 + 4x - 5 = 0. Participants are tasked with factoring the equation, finding its roots, and determining the intervals where the left-hand side is positive.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory, Conceptual clarification, Mathematical reasoning, Problem interpretation

Approaches and Questions Raised

  • Participants discuss the factorization of the quadratic and question the notation used for the roots. There are inquiries about the interpretation of the term "solve" and whether different methods, such as graphing, should be employed. Some participants suggest analyzing the signs of the factors to determine where the expression is positive.

Discussion Status

The conversation is ongoing, with participants providing insights into different methods of approaching the problem. There is an exploration of various interpretations of the tasks, particularly regarding the requirements for part (c) and how to express the intervals mathematically.

Contextual Notes

Some participants express confusion over the terminology used in the problem, particularly the word "solve," and discuss the implications of different methods for finding solutions. There is also mention of potential grading concerns related to notation and expression of answers.

Danatron
Messages
25
Reaction score
0
Question 1

(a) Solve the quadratic equation

x^2 + 4x -5 = 0

(b) Factorise its left hand side.

(c) Find interval(s) of x where the left hand side is positive


Q1
(a)
(x+-1) (x+5)
x= 1 x=-5
is that solving the equation?

(b)
didnt i already factorise the left hand side of the equation when i solved for in (a)?
(x+-1)?

(c)
not sure on this one
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Hi there, you have solved the equation in a). Yes you did already factorise the equation, but perhaps the question assumed you might have solved it a different way (by the quadratic equation). For part c you need to use the fact the two negative numbers multiplied together will give you a positive number etc.
 
Danatron said:
Question 1

(a) Solve the quadratic equation

x^2 + 4x -5 = 0

(b) Factorise its left hand side.

(c) Find interval(s) of x where the left hand side is positive


Q1
(a)
(x+-1) (x+5)
x= 1 x=-5
is that solving the equation?

(b)
didnt i already factorise the left hand side of the equation when i solved for in (a)?
(x+-1)?

(c)
not sure on this one

Your notation x+-1 is meaningless, and should never be used. If x=1 is a root then one of the factors is x-1; if x = -1 is a root, one of the factors is x+1.
 
You should try graphing the quadratic

y=x^2+4x-5

You should know that the quadratic is convex (in the shape of a u) instead of concave (in the shape of an n) because the coefficient of x2 (multiple of x2) is 1 and hence positive (if it were negative the quadratic would be concave).

You've also found that it crosses the x-axis at x=1 and x=-5 because this is where the quadratic =0 hence y=0 for those x values.

Putting these two ideas together, it's quite obvious what the domain is (values of x) for where the quadratic is positive.
 
Danatron said:
Q1
(a)
(x+-1) (x+5)
x= 1 x=-5
is that solving the equation?
Yes, you have found the values of the unknowns which will make the right side equal to the left side.

(c)
not sure on this one
You are trying to determine your answer without sketching the graph? ✻shame✻

Always sketch the graph, so you can see what you are dealing with.
 
For c), besides sketching the graph you can analyse the sign of the terms individually.

(x-1)(x+5)

When is (x-1) positive? When is it negative?
Same to (x+5).

What must be the signs of (x-1) and (x+5) so that (x-1)(x+5) > 0?
 
quadratic

ok so i have graphed the quadratic and circled in red all the positive values of x, how would i write this?

[PLAIN]http://i.imgur.com/WwvsteW.jpg?1[/PLAIN]
 
Danatron said:
ok so i have graphed the quadratic and circled in red all the positive values of x, how would i write this?

[PLAIN]http://i.imgur.com/WwvsteW.jpg?1[/PLAIN]
What you're asked for is:

All of the x values for which the y values are positive .
 
so that would be everything before -5 and everything after 1 right?
 
  • #10
Danatron said:
so that would be everything before -5 and everything after 1 right?

Yes. So just turn that into a mathematical expression. What's "everything before -5" and "everything after 1" in mathematical terms?
 
  • #11
x < -5 & x > 1
 
  • #12
Danatron said:
Question 1

(a) Solve the quadratic equation

x^2 + 4x -5 = 0

(b) Factorise its left hand side.

(c) Find interval(s) of x where the left hand side is positive


Q1
(a)
(x+-1) (x+5)
x= 1 x=-5
is that solving the equation?

(b)
didnt i already factorise the left hand side of the equation when i solved for in (a)?
(x+-1)?

(c)
not sure on this one

hmm. In part (a), "solve" does seem confusing in this problem. There are many other ways of solving. Sometimes textbooks want you to graph first. You could also use a rational root test, or something like that. Some books give problems with ##ax^2 + bx + c = N##. The concept of "solving" is to graph this as two functions and find their intersection points. Of course, it seems like a lot more work than necessary.

There is a concern I have with what you wrote in part (a). The expression ##(x + -1)(x+5)## does not mean ##x = 1## or ##x = -5##. You have to state ##(x + -1)(x+5) = 0## to find those solutions for ##x##. I think you KNOW that you are doing this, you just didn't write it. If you did that on a test, a teacher might take points off.

This is also a big idea that connects with part (c). In part (a) you are using the zero property: Zero times a number is zero. In part (c) you are using the following concepts about multiplication of real numbers: "a positive times a positive is a positive"; "a negative times a negative is a positive"; etc. Again these positive & negative multiplication rules are for real numbers, not the imaginary numbers.
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
2K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
2K
  • · Replies 8 ·
Replies
8
Views
2K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
3K
Replies
1
Views
2K
  • · Replies 7 ·
Replies
7
Views
2K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
3K
  • · Replies 8 ·
Replies
8
Views
2K
  • · Replies 14 ·
Replies
14
Views
2K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
2K